When the Royals and Reds swapped Brady Singer for Jonathan India and Joey Weimer in 2024, it looked like the kind of trade both sides could live with. Two years later, it has become a much uglier story.
Kansas City hoped India would give its lineup a needed jolt after an 86-win season and a playoff trip in 2024. The Royals had a surplus of pitching, especially in the rotation, and J.J.
Picollo’s front office saw a chance to add some offense while the window to contend still felt open. India, coming off a .248/.357/.392 line in 2024, seemed like a reasonable bet to be an above-average bat at second base.
He had cooled from his Rookie of the Year peak in 2021, when he hit 21 home runs, but the profile still looked useful.
That never really materialized.
India gave the Royals almost nothing in 2025, opening the season with a .590 OPS through the end of April and never fully shaking the decline that had already started to show in his bat. He finished with just 38 extra-base hits and a career-worst .346 slugging percentage, 50 points below his career average.
He still showed an elite eye and rarely chased pitches outside the zone, but he wasn’t driving the ball with any kind of consistency. The end result was a frustrating season for Kansas City’s new second baseman.
Then came 2026, which made things even worse. India played only 17 games before shoulder surgery ended his season in April.
Singer’s side of the deal has gone from steady to disastrous. During his five years in Kansas City, he was the definition of up-and-down, capable of looking dominant one month and hittable the next.
But after posting a solid 2.6 fWAR in 2024, the Royals decided to sell high. At the time, that made sense.
Singer’s inconsistency had been part of the package, and Kansas City believed it could turn him into a lineup upgrade while it still had value.
For a while, it seemed the Reds might be the winners. Singer made 32 starts in 2025, allowing 150 hits in 169.2 innings with 163 strikeouts and 2.8 fWAR.
Cincinnati went 18-14 in his starts, won 83 games and reached the playoffs for the first time since 2020. That only deepened the sting for the Royals, who missed the postseason themselves.
But 2026 changed the entire picture. Singer opened the year badly and never recovered, finishing with a 5.85 ERA and a 1.592 WHIP. He was one of the worst starting pitchers in baseball and a major reason the Reds fell short of the playoffs.
Singer has had rough stretches before, but this season was a full collapse from the former first-round pick. It doesn’t erase India’s injury or his struggles at the plate, yet it does soften the blow for Kansas City a bit. With both players set to hit free agency after the season, what once looked like a trade that might work out for everyone now feels like a lose-lose.
In Other News...
Royals Could Be Headed For A 2027 Shakeup Quatraro Can't Ignore
The Royals are already being forced to think beyond the usual offseason churn, because the conversation around this club has shifted from simple retooling to whether a larger reset is coming by 2027. Matt Quatraro has felt the heat after a pair of disappointing seasons, and the front office is now staring at a roster that still needs more impact talent if Kansas City wants to climb in the AL Central rather than keep treading water.
For all the attention on who stays and who goes, the bigger issue is how many of the current pieces fit the next version of the team. Kyle Isbel and Alex Lange are among the names viewed as unlikely to be part of the long-term answer, which puts even more pressure on the organization to develop its young prospects and get the evaluation process right. The Royals can talk about patience, but the longer the gap remains between promise and wins, the harder it becomes to avoid a real shakeup. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Ended On A High Note With One Offseason Question Growing
The Royals closed their 2026 season with a 3-2 win over the Guardians, and it came with a familiar type of lift from Vinnie Pasquantino. He powered the offense with two solo homers, including the go-ahead shot in the eighth inning, while Daniel Lynch IV gave Kansas City 5 1/3 innings to keep the game within reach before Lucas Erceg finished it off with the save.
It was a clean ending to a long season, even if the bigger picture still points elsewhere. Kansas City finished 69-93 while Cleveland moved on to the postseason, and the final result only sharpened the offseason conversation around a roster that can still produce moments like this but has plenty to sort through before next spring. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Already Face One Bullpen Decision That Could Shape The Offseason
With the 2026 season now in the books, the Royals are staring at an offseason roster puzzle that reaches beyond the usual free-agent churn. Kansas City currently has five players heading toward unrestricted free agency, and the list includes some familiar names in Jonathan India, Matt Strahm, John Means, Craig Kimbrel and Tony Gonsolin, giving the front office plenty to sort through as it maps out the next phase.
The bullpen, though, may present the first real decision point. Carlos Estvez is sitting on a $13 million club option for 2027, and whether Kansas City exercises it will tell plenty about how aggressively the club wants to shape its relief mix going forward. The Royals are expected to keep updating their roster choices throughout the offseason, but this is the kind of call that can quietly set the tone for everything that follows. [Read more 🡒]