The Royals’ 2025-26 offseason was supposed to be the kind of push that keeps a team moving forward. Instead, it turned into a lesson in what happens when a club shops at the margins and calls it a plan.
Kansas City had just finished an 82-win season in 2025, missing the playoffs by five games after ending an eight-year drought the year before. That should have been the signal to turn up the aggression.
Instead, general manager J.J. Picollo leaned into short-term bets, low-cost additions and role-player fixes - and the Royals slipped all the way to the bottom of the AL Central.
The biggest splash on the free-agent side was Lane Thomas, who signed for $5 million on a one-year deal. Starling Marte arrived on another one-year pact, and reliever Alex Lange was also brought in on a one-year deal. In total, Picollo spent just $7.15 million on the open market, and the rest of the offseason followed the same pattern: thin investments and modest swings.
Kansas City was busy in trades, but the volume didn’t match the impact. The Royals landed Matt Strahm, who had been one of baseball’s better relievers from 2023-2025, along with outfielder Issac Collins, who had finished fourth in NL Rookie of the Year voting, and reliever Nick Mears from the Milwaukee Brewers.
Angel Zerpa went the other way in that deal. The front office also made three more moves, adding relievers Mitch Spence and Mason Black in separate trades and bringing in outfielder Kameron Misner.
The common thread was hard to miss: outfielders and bullpen arms everywhere.
The best work Picollo did last winter came from keeping his own core in place. Maikel Garcia got a five-year extension at a strong value.
Vinnie Pasquantino signed a two-year deal that bought out his first two arbitration seasons. Salvador Perez also returned on a two-year contract.
Those were the clean hits.
Everything else? Much rougher.
Thomas struggled badly enough defensively that he was moved at the deadline. Marte lasted only 59 games before he was designated for assignment and released.
Collins never came close to matching his rookie production, hitting .213 in 145 games with a .641 OPS. Misner played only 18 games for Kansas City before being DFA’d and shipped to the Philadelphia Phillies for cash.
The bullpen additions were even tougher to stomach. Together, they produced minus-3.1 fWAR.
Strahm cratered, putting up a 7.32 ERA and 7.11 FIP in 41 appearances before being optioned to the minors. Lange finished with a 6.75 ERA over 60 innings.
Black logged a 4.31 ERA with a 6.48 FIP in 30 innings. Mears had a 5.12 ERA in 20 appearances.
Spence made just three appearances and posted a 21.21 ERA.
That’s what made the offseason approach so damaging: Kansas City spent like a team trying to find bargains, not like a team trying to solve problems. Thomas was coming off multiple trips to the IL, and Marte was 37 and already deep into decline. The Royals got some value back from Thomas when they traded him later, but that doesn’t erase the original gamble.
The rotation issue was just as glaring. Picollo didn’t add the kind of major league-ready depth the Royals needed, and that left the team leaning on pitchers who couldn’t stay healthy. The staff’s instability ended up mattering all season long.
The bigger point is simple. The Royals chose bargain hunting over real investment, whether that meant money or prospects.
If they spend this offseason, it has to be on proven free agents. If they make trades, it has to be for players with a track record.
The bargain bin already showed what it can do, and Kansas City can’t afford another winter like that.
In Other News...
Royals Downtown Ballpark Push Leaves One Huge Question For Fans
The Royals are moving from broad talk to the real work of planning a downtown ballpark district, and Brooks Sherman said the organization has now entered the master-planning stage. For now, the focus is on the stadium itself, even as the larger vision includes revitalizing the surrounding district while keeping existing tenants in place. It is the kind of early, foundational step that signals momentum without yet answering every practical question that comes with a project this size.
One of the biggest unresolved pieces remains what happens in Crown Center, where no decisions have been made about demolitions. Until that part gets sorted out, the plan still has a major layer of uncertainty hanging over it, even as the club pushes ahead on the ballpark concept. Elsewhere around the organization, there is also ongoing attention on pitcher Randy Dobnak, Tyler Tolberts progress at the plate and former outfielder MJ Melendez choosing free agency, but the downtown project is the storyline with the widest ripple effect for fans. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Still Have A Kauffman Problem They Didn't Expect
The Royals went into 2026 hoping the new Kauffman Stadium dimensions would help create a more even offensive environment, one that would translate better from home to road and make hitting less of a guessing game. Instead, the first season with the changes produced a striking split, with Kansas City turning in a much stronger offensive profile in its own park than away from it, a result that stood out across baseball and gave the club another Kauffman-related issue to sort through.
What makes the gap so awkward is that no one around the team has pinned down a clean explanation yet. It could be tied to the altered dimensions, simple year-to-year variance, or something else entirely, but whatever the cause, the Royals now have a home-road offensive divide that runs counter to what they were trying to accomplish and leaves a fresh question hanging over how well the new setup is actually working. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Suddenly Face A Tough Seth Lugo Decision
Seth Lugos third season in Kansas City has put the Royals in an increasingly familiar spot for a contender trying to balance present value with future flexibility. After a strong 2024, his performance has dipped over the past two years, with his ERA climbing and his pitch effectiveness slipping as he wrapped up his 11th major league season. Even so, he has remained one of the more recognizable veterans in the clubhouse and a pitcher the organization has leaned on as part of the rotation mix.
The trade deadline brought the possibility of a move, but the Royals are now weighing something more complicated than simple value on the market. Rotation depth is a real concern, and Lugos presence carries weight beyond the numbers because of what he means to the staff day to day. Whether Kansas City chooses to keep him or eventually explore a different direction, the decision says a lot about how aggressively the club wants to chase wins versus protecting itself for the long haul. [Read more 🡒]