The Royals are staring at a familiar problem again: who closes games if Carlos Estévez isn’t the answer?
After Estévez went down at the start of the season, Kansas City’s bullpen unraveled and never really recovered. Matt Strahm’s nightmare 2026 season only added to the mess, and injuries kept piling up across the pitching staff. By the end of the year, the Royals had one of the worst bullpens in the league, with very few bright spots to point to.
That’s why the team’s decision to decline Estévez’s option for the 2027 season matters, even if it was the financially sensible move. The 33-year-old would have cost $13 million, so Kansas City opted for the $2 million buyout instead.
That doesn’t close the door on a reunion, though. The Royals could still bring him back on a new deal, and they’d clearly benefit from having him back in the ninth inning - just not at that price.
Estévez’s case is simple enough. He led all of baseball with 42 saves in 2025 and earned his second career All-Star nod, looking like a pitcher ready to repeat that level of success.
Injuries wrecked that plan. If the market doesn’t get out of hand, a return remains on the table.
If the Royals go elsewhere, though, the options are a mixed bag. With Emilio Pagán reportedly headed to the Detroit Tigers on a one-year deal, the closer market is already shifting, and Kansas City may have to pay up to land a proven late-inning arm.
Here’s how the replacement candidates stack up:
Bryan Abreu sits at the top of the list. Kansas City may be priced out of the biggest names, including David Bednar and Adrián Morejón, but Abreu would be a strong fallback.
He battled command issues in 2026, yet still struck out 11.5 batters per nine over 62.2 innings for the Houston Astros and allowed only 44 hits. The stuff is still there, and with a mechanical adjustment, he could be a real weapon in late-game spots.
Raisel Iglesias is the steady veteran option. He has posted at least 29 saves in each of the last four seasons with the Atlanta Braves, and age hasn’t seemed to slow him much.
He’ll be 37 when the 2027 season begins, whenever that may be, but his effectiveness has held up even as his average fastball velocity has dipped. On a short-term deal, he’d give the Royals the kind of reliable presence they’ve been missing.
JoJo Romero brings a different kind of value. He has never been a full-time closer over his seven-year career, but he does have some experience in the role.
His sinker helped him generate ground balls at about a 51% rate in 2026, and that could pair nicely with one of the best defensive infields in baseball. The question is whether that translates into actual saves.
Lucas Erceg is the least appealing of the group, even though he was the obvious stopgap after Estévez’s injury. He converted his first five save chances, but the overall numbers were rough: a 5.59 ERA and a 1.800 WHIP in 2026. His late-season demotion seemed to help him sort out a few things in September, but he still has plenty to prove before anyone can trust him with the job again.
And then there’s the possibility of bringing Estévez back himself. That would be the cleanest answer if the Royals can make the money work. For now, though, Kansas City has to weigh whether it wants to pay for a proven closer, gamble on a rebound, or try to patch the ninth inning together another way.
In Other News...
Bobby Witt Jr Is Forcing A Bigger Royals Legacy Conversation
Bobby Witt Jr. keeps adding another layer to the Royals history book, and the latest chapter came at the MLB Awards on Nov. 11, where he was named to the All-MLB First Team at shortstop for the third straight year. For a player who debuted in 2022, that kind of recognition is already rare company, and it has become difficult to talk about Witt without also talking about where he fits in the broader arc of Kansas City baseball.
The conversation is no longer just about stardom in the present tense. With 879 hits and 33.6 fWAR already on the ledger across five seasons, Witt is starting to push into territory that invites comparisons with franchise icon George Brett, especially if he keeps producing at this pace and stays on the field long enough. For the Royals, that is the sort of long-view discussion that only happens when a player is doing more than living up to expectations. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Prospects Are Sending Very Different Signals In Arizona
The Arizona Fall League has become a useful late-season measuring stick for the Royals farm system, and this years group is offering a mixed read. Nine Kansas City prospects are in the showcase circuit, giving the organization another chance to compare progress against the backdrop of recent minor league seasons, injuries, and developmental hurdles. For a club that has spent plenty of time trying to sort out which young players are ready to matter in Kansas City, the AFL is less about box scores than about separating real forward movement from a short burst of good results.
Some of the early returns have been encouraging, with a few players showing signs that their recent work is carrying over in a meaningful way. Others have left a more complicated impression, either because the production has lagged or because health and consistency remain part of the conversation. For the Royals, that split matters, because the fall league is often where the organization gets its clearest look at who is pushing toward a bigger role and who still has more proving to do. [Read more 🡒]
Bobby Witt Jr. Keeps Giving Royals Fans A Bigger MVP Debate
Bobby Witt Jr. keeps stacking up the kind of seasons that make award voters and Royals fans revisit the same question in a bigger way each winter. He just became the first shortstop to earn three All-MLB First Team selections since the honors began in 2019, a marker that speaks to both his consistency and the standard he has set at a premium position.
The 2026 season only sharpened the case. Witt led American League shortstops in batting average, slugging percentage and doubles while continuing to impact games on defense, and now he is one of the finalists for the American League Most Valuable Player Award. For Kansas City, the debate is no longer about whether he belongs in the conversation. It is about how far that conversation can go. [Read more 🡒]