Royals Bullpen Rebuild Comes Down To A Tough Call Ahead

With the non-tender deadline looming, the Royals face crucial decisions about their pitching staff as they aim to rebound from a disappointing 2026 season.

The Royals have already started reshaping a pitching staff that unraveled in 2026, but the next move could come down to a few hours and a hard payroll decision.

Kansas City’s rotation and bullpen were battered by injuries and a string of disappointing seasons, and the result was ugly: the club allowed the fourth-most earned runs in baseball, 755. That kind of damage made it hard to stay in games, let alone finish them off, and it left the Royals scrambling for answers heading into the offseason.

General manager J.J. Picollo has already begun attacking the problem.

The Royals pulled off a blockbuster trade with the Seattle Mariners to land Bryce Miller and two other MLB pitchers, then added relief pitcher Angel Bastardo from the Boston Red Sox in exchange for infielder Jack Pineda. And according to ESPN’s Jeff Passan, the team also reached a $1.35 million agreement with Randy Dobnak for the 2027 season, a deal that avoids arbitration and keeps one of Kansas City’s more underrated arms in the fold after a season in which he delivered real value when the Royals needed it most.

Even with those moves, the work is far from done.

The November 20 non-tender deadline is now the next major checkpoint, and Kansas City has to decide whether to keep pitchers Lucas Erceg, Nate Pearson, and Anthony Gose. Together, they would cost more than $5 million to retain next season, and with the Royals trying to reset after a rough year, there’s a real chance the front office decides to clear the deck and rebuild the bullpen around a new mix.

Pearson looks like the easiest name to move on from. He is set to make $2 million in 2027, and while his fastball lives in the upper 90s, he has remained surprisingly hittable over a six-year big league career.

Kansas City could decide that money is better spent elsewhere, especially after bringing in lefty Jose A. Ferrer in the Maikel Garcia deal.

Erceg is a tougher call. His projected $2.3 million salary would make him a significant piece of the budget, but the Royals may still see a rebound candidate rather than a lost cause.

He just went through the worst season of his major league career, and his walks per nine rate ballooned to 6.0 in 2026. Even so, he stayed elite at avoiding barrels and getting soft contact on the ground.

If he gets back to his 2024 level, he could matter a lot to this team.

Gose sits at the other end of the cost spectrum. His $1.1 million contract would barely move the needle, and his 2026 numbers are hard to ignore: a 0.66 ERA and a 0.951 WHIP in 14 games.

He is also still something of a mystery at the big league level, with only 45.2 innings on his career ledger, and at 36 years old he is nearing the end. Still, that kind of production is enough to make the Royals think twice.

Picollo has already said he wants to be careful with bullpen spending this offseason, and that could make this a simple numbers game. The Royals may not find three relievers with this kind of price tag and upside again.

In Other News...

Royals Offseason Plan Just Shifted After A Trade Fans Will Debate

The pitching market keeps moving, and Tarik Skubal is now part of the conversation after the Padres met with the free agent left-hander, joining other clubs that have already had discussions with him. Around the same time, the Royals made one of the more notable moves of the offseason by completing a six-player trade with the Mariners, a deal that sent Maikel Garcia, Bryce Miller, Jose A. Ferrer, Logan Evans and James McArthur into the spotlight as both teams reshaped their plans.

For Kansas City, the trade is the kind of move that can ripple through the rest of the winter, especially with rival clubs still active in pitching pursuit and the Twins also adding Sonny Gray on a two-year deal. Fans will debate the direction of the swap for a while, since it changes the Royals' immediate outlook and may affect how aggressively they need to keep shopping for help in the months ahead. [Read more 🡒]

Patrick Mahomes Weighed In On A Royals Move Fans Will Feel

Patrick Mahomes had a familiar kind of split reaction to the Royals move involving Maikel Garcia, the All-Star third baseman who was dealt to the Seattle Mariners. As part of the clubs ownership group, Mahomes has a stake in the long view, and he framed the trade in the same practical terms the front office would - a step aimed at improving the pitching staff and keeping the team in the mix for the postseason.

Still, the emotional side of it was hard to miss, because Garcia had become one of the more recognizable pieces on the roster. Mahomes said he wished him well, even as he acknowledged the business of the move, and his attention is also being pulled toward another Kansas City title chase with the Current heading into the NWSL Championship Game. [Read more 🡒]

Royals Trades That Helped Build Kansas Citys Winning Identity

Some of the Royals best stretches have been shaped as much by the trade market as by the draft, and the franchise has a long list of deals that helped define its winning identity. Moves for players like John Mayberry from Houston and Jeff Montgomery from Cincinnati brought real value to Kansas City, giving the club impact talent that fit neatly into the way it wanted to compete.

More recently, the Royals and Mariners lined up on a multi-player trade that added another chapter to that history of roster reshaping. The details of any one deal can fade with time, but Kansas Citys track record suggests these kinds of moves have often mattered most when they quietly strengthened the foundation around the core. [Read more 🡒]