The Royals went into the winter looking for bullpen help, and the Matt Strahm move was supposed to be the one that made sense. Instead, it’s turned into the kind of trade that stings more every time you check the box score.
Kansas City’s relief corps has taken a step back for a mix of reasons - injuries, bad luck, roster construction, and player decisions all played a part. The group that finished 2025 ranked seventh in bullpen ERA and third in left-on-base percentage, even while sitting 29th in K/9, was supposed to be upgraded with veteran additions.
Nick Mears arrived from Milwaukee. Alex Lange came in as a free agent.
And the headliner was Strahm, acquired in a deal that sent Jonathan Bowlan to Philadelphia.
At the time, the move drew praise. Bowlan was part of the Royals’ 2018 draft class, one of five college arms Kansas City picked as it tried to reboot after the championship window slammed shut. But with the Mid-Summer classic just days away, the trade looks a lot different now.
Strahm has been a mess in his first season back in Kansas City, the same organization that drafted him in 2012 out of Neosho Community College. At age 33, he’s posting career-worst numbers and never found a real rhythm. Knee inflammation sent him to the IL and interrupted what had been a decent start.
Before the IL stint on May 15, Strahm had a 3.86 ERA in 16.1 innings, though the 4.88 FIP hinted at trouble underneath. Since then, the numbers have fallen off a cliff: a 10.80 ERA, 8.63 FIP, 4.80 K/9, and a 48.4% left-on-base rate after the break. His home run rate has jumped from 1.65 per nine innings to 3.60, and his ground-ball rate has dropped from 32.6% to 25.0%.
Since returning on June 2, it’s been rough almost from the jump. There was a stretch where he allowed home runs in four straight outings, including five of his first six appearances back.
Bowlan, meanwhile, has looked like a real bullpen piece for Philadelphia. He’s in the middle of a breakout season with a 2.93 ERA and 38 strikeouts in 30.2 innings.
The Phillies originally used him as a starter in the minors, where he made 77 starts in the Royals’ system, before moving him to the bullpen full-time in 2025. Kansas City never really gave him a long runway in the majors, optioning him to Triple-A Omaha eight times last year.
Now he’s thriving in a late-inning role. Bowlan was throwing 95-96 mph with the Royals last season, but this year his fastball is averaging 97.3 mph, which puts him in the 90th percentile in baseball.
He’s also leaned more heavily on offspeed stuff, going from 61 changeups in 2025 to 68 already this season, while adding a sweeper to the mix. That extra wrinkle has helped make the fastball play up even more.
The Phillies are 54-43 and hold the second wild card spot in the National League. Their bullpen leads the majors with a 10.04 K/9 and ranks eighth in FIP, and Bowlan has been a major part of that group. His 11.15 K/9 is a career high, and he has the fifth-most innings among Phillies relievers.
What was supposed to be a move that softened the blow of losing a pitcher who finally started producing has gone the other way. Kansas City is left with a struggling arm, while Philadelphia has a reliever who looks like part of its future.
Not exactly how J.J. Picollo and Co. drew it up.
In Other News...
Royals Day 2 Draft Haul Might Have More Upside Than Expected
The Royals kept adding to their draft class on Day 2, using a run of picks to stock the system with a mix of college arms, high school talent and a few intriguing upside bets. Ethan McElvain, Justin LeGuernic and Camden Johnson were among the names added as Kansas City continued the familiar draft approach of chasing depth and development, with each selection bringing a different profile and path to the majors.
What stands out is how much room there still seems to be for these picks to outgrow their slot. McElvain and Johnson arrived with notable prospect buzz, while the group also included players with size, polish or comeback angles that can make a draft class look stronger a few years down the road than it does on paper now. For a Royals organization still leaning on the draft as a core way to build, the rest of this class may end up mattering as much as the names that drew the most attention on the first day. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Hit By Pitch Drama Just Took A Much Worse Turn
A tense moment in the Orioles-Royals game has spilled well beyond the box score, with Kansas City reliever Lucas Erceg drilling Blaze Alexander in the hand after a home run and setting off a flurry of reaction from both sides. The immediate aftermath brought players from the dugouts and bullpens onto the field, turning a routine sequence into one of those incidents that lingers after the final out.
The bigger concern for Baltimore is the damage to Alexander, who was forced out of the game and is expected to miss time after the injury. The episode has also taken on a life of its own online, where Alexander and Royals infielder Vinnie Pasquantino traded comments about what happened, keeping an already heated moment in the spotlight long after the pitch itself. [Read more 🡒]
Jac Caglianones Derby Moment Comes With A Personal Twist Royals Fans Will Love
Jac Caglianone is heading into the 2024 All-Star Game Home Run Derby with plenty of buzz around him, and not just because of the power that made him a natural fit for the event. The Royals outfielder has been working through the new swing-based format, which changes the rhythm of the competition and puts a premium on efficiency as much as raw pop, while DraftKings has him among the early favorites to win.
Ahead of the Derby, Caglianone also got a little perspective from one of the best to ever do it in Pete Alonso, a two-time champion who happens to share a Henry B. Plant High School connection with him. Alonsos advice should help, but the personal side of this Derby setup may end up mattering just as much as any scouting report, especially with the kind of familiar support Caglianone has around him in Baltimore. [Read more 🡒]