The Red Sox may be staring at the same problem again: who handles shortstop every day.
Trevor Story’s injury history and struggles at the plate forced Boston to patch together the position all season long, with five different players cycling through the middle infield. Isiah Kiner-Falefa was part of that mix, but he’s now an unrestricted free agent.
And with the shortstop market looking thin, led by Mauricio Dubon and J.P. Crawford, the Red Sox may need to swing bigger if they want a real upgrade.
That’s where a trade idea from Bleacher Report’s Zachary D. Rymer enters the picture. He pointed to Bobby Witt Jr. as a possible target, noting that Boston had shown interest before the deadline.
"According to Alex Speier of The Boston Globe, Bobby Witt Jr.'s name came up while the Red Sox were weighing trades for various stars before the trade deadline. It's unclear if they actually spoke to the Kansas City Royals about their three-time All-Star shortstop, but either way, the idea to trade for him was there in some form," Rymer wrote.
Witt would be a massive get. He has put up 6.7 bWAR or better in each of the last three seasons, and his game checks every box: power, speed and elite defense at shortstop.
Rymer also argued the Royals should at least entertain the possibility, even though Witt signed an 11-year contract in 2024.
"He signed an 11-year contract in 2024, but opt-outs starting after 2030 could effectively make it a seven-year deal," he wrote. "He's now three years into it, and the Royals are looking ahead at what could be the last four from the wreckage of a 93-loss season. Their contention model needs a course correction, badly."
In the proposed deal, Boston would send left-hander Payton Tolle, right fielder Wilyer Abreu, shortstop Franklin Arias and outfielder Justin Gonzales to Kansas City.
That’s a steep price, and the Red Sox would almost certainly think hard before including Tolle, whose ace upside has made him a fast-rising fan favorite. Arias would be another painful loss, especially with the prospect ranked No. 2 in baseball.
"It's a haul, alright, but it would return nothing less than the best shortstop in baseball. And arguably, the best player at any position that the sport has to offer," Rymer concluded.
It’s the kind of blockbuster that would stop the sport in its tracks, and one people would argue about for a long time afterward.
In Other News...
Royals Could Signal Their 2027 Intentions With One Big Outfield Move
The Royals long-term planning has started to come into focus as they look ahead to 2027, and the outfield is one of the clearest places where they can make a meaningful jump. Offensive help is part of that picture, too, which is why Randy Arozarena has surfaced as such a natural fit. The Seattle left fielder brings the kind of bat that can change the shape of a lineup, especially with his track record against left-handed pitching.
For Kansas City, this is the sort of move that would say plenty about how seriously the club views its next competitive window. Arozarena would not just fill a need in the grass, he would also give the Royals a more dangerous presence in the middle of the order. Whether the fit turns into a real pursuit will be one of the more interesting questions as the teams 2027 intentions start to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Make A Tough Pitching Decision With Real Rotation Stakes
The Royals made a pair of familiar winter moves with real rotation and roster implications, picking up Tony Gonsolins 2027 club option while letting Carlos Estvez hit free agency. Gonsolin will earn $2.5 million next year, a relatively modest commitment for a pitcher the club still sees as worth keeping in the fold after the injury issues that have followed him in recent seasons.
Estvezs situation is the sharper pivot, with Kansas City passing on his $13 million club option and instead taking the $2 million buyout. His own injury history has made the decision less surprising than it might have seemed on paper, but it also leaves the Royals with another meaningful bullpen question to sort through as they weigh health, price and reliability heading into the offseason. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Already Have A Tough Rule 5 Decision Brewing
The Royals are already sorting through an offseason decision that can shape more than just their winter roster. With the Rule 5 Draft scheduled before a possible lockout, Kansas City has to decide which prospects it wants to keep off the market, and that means weighing development, depth, and the risk of losing a young player for nothing. Six names stand out in the conversation: Carson Roccaforte, Gavin Cross, Brett Squires, Lucas Braun, Jacob Berry and Peyton Wilson, each with enough recent momentum or organizational value to make the protection picture complicated.
For a club trying to avoid getting stuck in place, this is the kind of move that matters beyond the moment. The Royals want to keep building toward a stronger 2027, and that starts with making sure the right pieces stay in the system long enough to matter. Even in a winter clouded by uncertainty, this part of the process forces the front office to define which prospects are part of the next wave and which ones could be exposed to another team before Kansas City ever gets the chance to see them arrive. [Read more 🡒]