Randy Dobnak was never supposed to be more than extra pitching depth for the Mariners. Seattle signed him to a minor-league deal, parked him in Tacoma, and treated him like the kind of arm you keep around for emergencies while he got regular work.
Instead, he’s turned into something more for the Kansas City Royals.
Since getting to Kansas City’s major-league roster, Dobnak has gone 2-0 with a 1.16 ERA and 1.19 WHIP over 31 innings. He has gone at least four innings in all six of his appearances, four of them starts, and he recently picked up his first MLB win since 2021 by tossing seven shutout innings against the Twins.
For Seattle, every one of those outings is a reminder of what slipped away.
His full line with Tacoma didn’t jump off the page at first. Dobnak finished there with a 4.24 ERA, a 1.44 WHIP and 39 strikeouts in 70 innings.
On the surface, that looked like ordinary depth work. But the last month before Kansas City got him told a different story.
Dobnak left Tacoma on a run of four straight quality starts. Over those 24 innings, he posted a 2.63 ERA, worked six innings in each start and walked only three batters. His six quality starts were tied for third-most in the minors when the Royals acquired him.
Kansas City didn’t overhaul him. They just had room to use him.
The same approach that worked in Tacoma has carried over: he changes speeds, leans on his secondary pitches and keeps hitters guessing. He’s not overpowering anyone, but he’s keeping games under control.
Seattle’s path to keeping him was blocked by a crowded rotation when Dobnak triggered the upward-mobility clause in his contract. The Mariners were still using six starters, and the organization was already high on Kade Anderson and Ryan Sloan.
There wasn’t much room for Dobnak. What stands out is that moving him into a bridge-reliever role apparently never became an option.
Once the clause kicked in, Seattle had to add him to the 40-man roster or expose him to other teams. Kansas City gave him a roster spot and a cleaner path to the majors, and the move made sense on paper. Still, it looks like the wrong call now.
The Mariners decided Dobnak was replaceable even after his strong finish in Tacoma. The Royals saw him as someone who could help steady an injured rotation.
His current run probably isn’t built to last forever - Baseball Savant has him at a 4.87 expected ERA, and his strikeout and walk numbers don’t leave much margin for error. A sub-2 ERA is not something to bank on.
But that’s not really the point.
If Seattle had a chance to carry a bulk reliever, that had real value over the course of a long season. They had one in Dobnak. And they let him go.
In Other News...
Noah Camerons Sudden Royals Breakthrough Has One Clear Turning Point
Noah Camerons latest outing fit the kind of form the Royals have been waiting to see, and it came in a tight 2-1 win over the Twins. He worked eight innings, allowed one run and struck out nine, matching his career highs in both innings and strikeouts while extending a run of back-to-back starts with eight innings and just one earned run allowed across his last 23 innings.
The surge is especially notable because it has come after a rough patch earlier in the summer, when Cameron was searching for answers. His recent turnaround has been tied to a change in how he and the Royals have handled the game plan on the mound, and the difference has been obvious enough that his last several outings now look nothing like the stretch that came before it. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Fans Just Got Two Very Different Signals About The Future
The Royals week offered a tidy snapshot of where the organization stands, from the upper levels of the farm to the big league club. Michael Masseys go-ahead homer helped Kansas City slip past Minnesota 2-1 despite an earlier defensive mistake, while Noah Cameron delivered eight innings of one-run ball and matched career highs in innings and strikeouts. In the minors, Michael Lombardi and Jhon Reyes combined for a no-hitter in a Low-A game, another reminder that the system still has arms worth watching.
At the same time, recent first-round pick Zion Rose got his first taste of pro ball with Quad Cities, a debut that came with the usual growing pains attached. The bigger-picture message for Royals fans is a little harder to pin down, though, because the front office has been signaling patience around the roster while the club keeps trying to balance now and later. There are still questions about how aggressively Kansas City will keep shaping that future, even after one deadline decision in particular helped settle at least part of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]