The Mets’ first-base situation has gone from stable to unsettled in a hurry, and this offseason looks like the moment to finally sort it out.
For years, Pete Alonso gave New York a daily answer at the position and eventually became the franchise’s home run leader. Then he left in free agency for a five-year deal with the Baltimore Orioles last offseason, and the Mets have been trying to piece things together ever since. The Jorge Polanco experiment at first base went nowhere, and the club spent the season cycling through different options.
That makes first base one of the biggest items on David Stearns’ offseason checklist. One possible answer could come from Minnesota, where Royce Lewis is viewed as a player who may be available and has a connection to newly hired Derek Falvey.
Lewis has had a tough run with injuries during his time with the Twins, and that has reportedly played a role in why his future there is uncertain. Even so, the fit for New York is easy to see.
In five big league seasons, Lewis has hit .246/.302/.429 with 61 home runs, 213 RBIs and a .731 OPS across 683 games. He also just put together a career-high 125 games played this past season.
What makes him especially interesting for the Mets is the versatility. Lewis has spent most of his career at first base and third base, which gives New York some flexibility if it wants to build a platoon. One possible setup mentioned is Lewis pairing with Jared Young, who would be on the roster in 2027.
There’s also the bat profile. Lewis hit right-handed pitching well enough to stand out against a Mets lineup that struggled in that area for much of last season.
Against lefties, he slashed .252 with five home runs and struck out only 32 times. Against righties, he hit 10 homers but batted just .216 and struck out 98 times.
Falvey’s ties to Lewis run deep. He spent the previous 10 years in the Twins’ front office as executive vice president and chief baseball officer, as well as president of baseball operations, and he drafted Lewis first overall in 2016.
And from a trade-cost standpoint, Lewis may not require much to land. His uneven tenure in Minnesota and the Twins’ desire to retool a young roster could make him attainable.
If the Mets are looking for a quieter move that still addresses a glaring need, Lewis fits the profile. It may not be the flashiest fix, but it could be the kind of under-the-radar addition that helps push the club back toward playoff contention in 2027.
In Other News...
Royals Just Got Pulled Into A New Infield Trade Market Twist
The offseason infield market has already started to shift, and the Royals are in the middle of it whether they planned on being or not. ESPNs Jeff Passan reported that the Giants are exploring trade options involving infielder Casey Schmitt as they look to add pitching help, a sign that clubs are beginning to line up their priorities before the December lockout tightens the calendar.
For Kansas City, the timing matters because the recent Maikel Garcia trade has already shown how quickly the market can move around infield pieces. Nothing is finalized on the Giants side, but the possibility of another infielder being shopped only adds to the sense that teams are trying to act early, and the Royals will be watching closely as the market keeps taking shape. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Trade Return Could Reshape More Than Fans Expected
A reported swap between Seattle and Kansas City would send Maikel Garcia to the Mariners, bringing one of the Royals most versatile infielders into a new setting after he established himself as a steady defensive presence with solid offensive production in recent seasons. For Kansas City, the deal would mark the kind of roster move that can ripple beyond a single position, since Garcias value has always come from the ability to cover multiple spots and keep the lineup moving.
Bryce Miller would head to Kansas City in return, giving the Royals a different kind of piece to evaluate as they look to shape the roster around their next phase. The Mariners, meanwhile, would be adding flexibility to their lineup, though how they ultimately arrange things remains unclear for now, leaving the full impact of the trade to be sorted out once the dust settles. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Move On From Former Starting Center Fielder After Roster Crunch
The roster squeeze that followed the Royals trade for Bryce Miller came at a familiar spot in the outfield, where Kyle Isbel had been a regular presence since taking over as the teams starting center fielder in 2023. Kansas City designated Isbel for assignment to open a 40-man roster spot, a move that reflects how quickly the clubs priorities have shifted as it reshapes the roster around the new addition.
Isbels time in Kansas City has been defined by a steady decline in both offense and defense, leaving the Royals to make a difficult but unsurprising call. He is not expected to be back with the club next season, and his next stop could come as a fourth outfielder elsewhere, if another team sees value in his experience and versatility. [Read more 🡒]
