Jonathan India arrived in Kansas City with a real purpose, and the Royals built a plan around him that never got the chance to breathe.
The idea was straightforward enough. After trading Brady Singer to the Cincinnati Reds before the 2025 season, the Royals filled a need and got the kind of bat they wanted near the top of the lineup.
India was supposed to be the starting second baseman in 2026, with less pressure this time around. Maikel Garcia opened the year in the leadoff spot, and India was set to stay at second base full-time, his least bad defensive position.
The hope was simple: let him settle in, stack quality at-bats, and deepen the lineup.
Instead, his season was over almost immediately.
India appeared in just 17 games, hit . . . well, he posted an 81 wRC+, and then landed on the injured list on April 20. A week later, on April 28, he underwent successful surgery on his left labrum, ending his year before it really got started.
That injury put a sharp spotlight on a player whose first season in Kansas City already had not gone the way anyone wanted. In 2025, India produced a -0.2 fWAR and an 89 wRC+. There were reasons for the rough patch: he was hit in the face by an errant pitch early in the season, and the Royals shuffled him around the field, using him in the outfield, at third base, and at second base without finding much success anywhere.
The shoulder issue, though, adds another layer. In a conversation with PJ Green of the Kansas City Star, India said he had been dealing with shoulder subluxations for five years. He described the routine as follows:
“Sounds psychotic, but just the person I am when I’m on that field,” India told reporters Tuesday.
His left shoulder, the side he catches with, would pop out of place and he would pop it back in himself.
Matt Quatraro also addressed the decision to have surgery, and the Royals manager made clear that India had come around to the idea that it was the best long-term move.
“I think he understood that this was probably the best thing long term. He was going to be a free agent at the end of the year, all those things, and he’s been playing hurt for at least the year-plus that we’ve had him.”
That naturally raises some uncomfortable questions about the Royals’ side of the equation. What did they know about the shoulder when they traded for him?
If he had already been playing hurt for more than a year, should the surgery have happened last season instead of waiting? We do not get to see the medical file, and these decisions are made as a group, but the end result was a disappointment for both sides.
It also matters in the larger context of the trade. Singer was the Royals’ best chip after the 2024 season, given his value and how replaceable that role was, and the Royals ended up getting negative WAR back from India across two seasons.
There is still some open-ended intrigue here, because the shoulder issue may help explain why India’s power has never really returned to the level he showed as a rookie. He is now set to hit free agency after a season that was already disappointing and then a year that never happened at all.
Whether a team wants to guarantee him a major league deal is another question. Someone might see the surgery as a reset and take a shot at getting the rookie version back.
The Royals, meanwhile, were reminded that second base was not as steady as it looked. They posted an 89 wRC+ at the position, even with Michael Massey turning in a bounce-back year and putting up 2.3 fWAR, most of it at second. There was still room for another hitter who could handle the spot and give the lineup more punch.
India’s absence did not wreck the season, but it did become part of the broader injury grind that exposed how thin the Royals’ depth could be. J.J.
Picollo deserves plenty of credit for the trades he has made, but this one, at minimum, looks like a missed opportunity. If India has played his last game in a Royals uniform, he’ll be remembered by at least one observer every time a shoulder starts acting up and needs a closer look.
In Other News...
Royals Face One Costly Arbitration Call In Bigger 2027 Roster Picture
The Royals are already getting an early look at a few pieces that could matter in the next wave of roster construction, and the conversation starts with players in very different stages of their careers. Left-hander Justin Lamkin is still working through mixed results in the Arizona Fall League, a reminder that his long-term path remains more projection than certainty, while the front office is also weighing more immediate decisions on the major league side as it sorts through the depth it may want to carry into 2027.
One of the bigger calls involves second baseman Michael Massey, whose arbitration outlook forces the club to balance cost, role, and upside rather than simply look at the name on the lineup card. The Royals are also kicking around possible pitching fits for the future, including veteran reliever Steven Okert and a reunion with right-hander Luke Weaver, two options that speak to how much the bullpen picture could change by the time that next roster cycle arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Could Lose A Rising Front Office Piece To Houston
The Astros search for a new general manager has pulled in another name with ties to Kansas City, with Royals senior vice president Scott Sharp reportedly among the candidates under consideration. Sharps inclusion is notable for a front office that has been on the rise, and it speaks to how much demand there is for executives who have worked their way into meaningful responsibility around the game.
Houston is casting a fairly wide net, with Braves assistant general manager Ben Sestanovich also in the mix along with Matt Kleine, Josh Barfield and Randy Flores. At the same time, the Astros are moving ahead with another key hire, bringing in Spencer Medick as director of pitching to oversee pitching development, a sign the organization is trying to bolster multiple layers of its baseball operations structure at once. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Still Have One Big Jac Caglianone Decision Ahead
Jac Caglianone gave the Royals plenty to build on in 2026, and he did it while wearing multiple hats. He led the club in several offensive categories and spent time both in right field and at first base as injuries forced Kansas City to shuffle the lineup and patch holes wherever it could.
The bigger question now is where he fits best going into 2027. Caglianone dealt with shoulder and elbow issues during the season, and his time in right field was affected as a result, leaving the Royals to weigh whether a return to first base makes more sense depending on how the roster settles this winter. The bat clearly belongs in the middle of the conversation, but the defensive side of his future is still very much up in the air. [Read more 🡒]