Jac Caglianone has already pushed Royals fans into big-money territory, and the latest reaction survey makes that clear.
Earlier this week, fans were asked how much they’d be comfortable giving Caglianone in a hypothetical contract extension, and the answers came back loud. More than one-third of respondents said they’d go all the way to $140 million over seven years.
Another quarter landed at $15 million per year, which works out to 7 years and $105 million. Nineteen percent said the Royals should simply wait and see.
The case for an extension starts with the math on what Caglianone might earn through arbitration if he keeps producing the way he has this season. The estimate used here pegs him at $1 million in 2027 and again in 2028, then $5 million in 2029, $13 million in 2030, and $18 million in 2031, with the note that that final number could be a little lower if he is 1B/DH only by then. That adds up to about $38 million over the next five seasons, or roughly $40 million rounded up.
Under that projection, Caglianone would reach free agency before his age-29 season in 2032. Even if he settles in as a 1B/DH rather than an outfielder, the open market could still be very kind to him if he keeps hitting at this level, with room for even more if his bat keeps climbing.
That’s why the early-extension number here starts at buying out a couple of free-agent years. The estimate lands at at least $20 million more, which would put the deal at 7 years and $80 million. The view here is that the Royals should do that immediately, and even 7 years and $90 million would be acceptable, especially if some of the money could be tied to playing time and All-Star appearance incentives.
The fan response, though, pushed higher than that. The comparison to Kevin McGonigle helps explain why Caglianone may not command the same kind of money as some other young stars: McGonigle has been an equal hitter while offering better defense and better baserunning. The same logic applies when comparing Caglianone to Bobby Witt Jr., who has hit about as well as Caglianone this year but does so much more in every other phase.
The “wait and see” crowd may not love where this is headed. These deals are built on security for the player in exchange for cheaper years for the team, and there’s a point where that security stops being worth it.
The Royals got Bobby Witt Jr. locked up before it was too late, and even then the price was enormous. If they had waited until partway through his third season, during his MVP-runner-up 2024, they likely wouldn’t have kept him at all.
So if Kansas City wants to extend Caglianone, the timing is now. The hope here is that the Royals mark the next step of their stadium deal by keeping their large Italian little brother in town for the long haul.
In Other News...
Royals Fans Just Got A Tough Reminder About Scott Barlow
Scott Barlows return to the Royals organization has ended much the way his 2025 season has gone overall: without much momentum. After signing a minor league deal in early July, Barlow was released by Kansas Citys Triple-A affiliate following a stretch in which he continued to battle both command and velocity, the same issues that have followed him through stops with the Athletics and the Royals top farm team.
For Royals fans, it is a tough reminder of how quickly a once-trusted arm can lose his footing. Barlow still has a path back to a contender, though, since a team in the playoff race could still take a chance on him with another minor league deal before the postseason eligibility deadline. [Read more 🡒]
Royals May Regret Letting This Veteran Arm Get Away
Eli Morgans next stop is within the Yankees system, where the veteran right-hander has signed a minor league deal and will report to Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. For Kansas City, it is another reminder of how quickly bullpen depth can disappear in late-season roster churn, especially when a pitcher with major league experience gets through the waiver process and reaches the open market.
Morgan elected free agency after being designated for assignment by the Royals, and New York is bringing him in as extra pitching insurance with the postseason approaching. He has already been used in the majors several times this season, which is exactly the kind of practical experience contenders tend to value this time of year, and it leaves Kansas City wondering whether it let a useful arm slip away. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Suddenly Have A New Infield Problem To Solve
Maikel Garcias latest setback gives the Royals another infield wrinkle to manage, and it comes at a time when they were already trying to keep the lineup and roster moving with as little disruption as possible. Garcia landed back on the Injured List after suffering a hamstring strain while rounding third base, a frustrating turn for a player the club had been counting on to provide stability around the infield.
Matthew Lugo was brought up from Omaha to fill Garcias roster spot, while the Royals also made a pitching shuffle by optioning Carlos Durn and recalling Jose Cuas. For a club trying to stay flexible, the moves make sense on paper, but Garcias absence leaves another question hanging over how Kansas City will piece together the infield in the near term. [Read more 🡒]