Jac Caglianone’s latest injury scare gave the Royals a brief jolt, but the bigger question hanging over Kansas City is still the same one: can their young slugger stay on the field long enough to become a true middle-of-the-order fixture?
Caglianone left the Royals’ September 5 game against the Toronto Blue Jays in the third inning after suffering an elbow injury. According to MLB.com’s Anne Rogers, the issue appeared to happen after two outfield throws early in the game. Anytime an elbow comes into the picture, the alarm bells go off fast, and this one had all the makings of a season-altering problem.
Instead, the diagnosis brought relief. Caglianone has a Grade 1 left flexor strain, and the expectation is that he will not need to go on the IL. That’s about as good as it gets when a player is dealing with an elbow issue, and the Royals sound willing to let him ramp back up without rushing the process.
“Now that we know it’s low grade, then we can progress a little more aggressively when the time comes,” Royals’ manager Matt Quatraro said of Caglianone’s injury.
Still, the episode fit a pattern that’s worth watching. Caglianone has already dealt with minor injuries this year, including a mild ankle injury in August that kept him out for a couple of games. At 23, he’s young enough to bounce back quickly, and these kinds of bumps can be part of the grind of a full Major League season.
But for a player of Caglianone’s size, the conversation always circles back to durability. The Royals know what they’re getting with the bat.
They also know he’s not likely to become a defensive standout overnight. That’s why the team has been weighing whether he should remain in the outfield or move to first base, and why a future as a full-time DH could eventually make sense if it helps preserve him.
For Kansas City, that matters because the bat is the whole point. If the Royals want to push toward contention next season, they need Caglianone in the lineup.
After his rough 2025 debut, Bobby Witt Jr. still had to wait for the kind of supporting piece this team has been searching for. Caglianone has looked more like that player in 2026, even if the season has had its uneven stretches.
Through 131 games, he’s hitting .283 with an OPS of .825.
That progress becomes even more important when Carter Jensen is added to the mix. If Jensen keeps developing the way Kansas City hopes, the Royals could be looking at a dangerous three-headed force in the lineup for years. But that picture only works if Caglianone stays healthy enough to be part of it.
In Other News...
Royals Still Have One Unsettled Infield Spot After Latest Veteran Move
The Royals have trimmed another layer from their infield mix, releasing Brandon Drury after a quiet run in Triple-A. A former Silver Slugger and a 10-year big league veteran, Drury had signed a minor league deal with Kansas City over the offseason in hopes of carving out a role, but his latest stint never gained traction offensively.
For a club still sorting through the edges of its roster, the move leaves one more question hanging around the dirt work on the infield. Drury last played for the Angels in 2024, and his experience made him a logical depth option, but the Royals now have to decide how they want to fill that remaining spot as the season moves along. [Read more 🡒]
Diamondbacks Survived A Wild Road Finish Fans Will Be Talking About
Corbin Burnes is set to make his return to the major leagues tonight against the Royals, and it gives Kansas City another big-name arm to navigate as the stretch run keeps tightening. It will be Burnes first appearance since June 2025, a notable spot for any lineup to draw, especially with the Royals trying to keep their footing against pitchers who can change a game with one outing.
Around the league, the pitching headlines have been just as loud. Phillies left-hander Jesus Luzardo authored a complete-game shutout with 12 strikeouts to help Philadelphia split its series with the Braves, while Aaron Judge was activated from the 60-day injured list and is expected to play for the Yankees against the Rockies after working back from a rib injury. For the Royals, it is another reminder that every night can bring a different kind of challenge, from elite arms returning to the mound to star hitters rejoining the mix. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Wasted A Brilliant Pitching Night In A Brutal Extras Collapse
Noah Cameron gave the Royals exactly the kind of start they needed, working deep into the game and keeping Arizona off the board while the offense searched for any kind of breakthrough. The matchup with the Diamondbacks stayed scoreless through nine innings, a frustrating but familiar sort of setup for a team trying to squeeze value out of a strong pitching night.
The game finally cracked open in extras, and the tension only grew from there as both clubs found late offense in a wild 10th inning. Kansas City made things interesting with a quick answer, but the rally still came up short in a 5-4 loss that turned a crisp pitching performance into a bitter finish for the Royals and a costly one for bettors leaning on the under. [Read more 🡒]