Josh Simmons’ story has already taken one sharp turn after another, and the latest chapter is the most confusing one yet.
The Chiefs’ first-round tackle entered the league with a reputation built on grit. Two years ago on Oct. 12, while playing for Ohio State at Oregon, he tore his patellar tendon and instantly lost the rest of his season, his Outland Trophy chase and any chance to help in what became a national championship run. The injury also threatened his NFL future and wiped out the easy version of his draft stock.
Simmons answered it the way elite competitors are supposed to. At the 2025 NFL Combine in Indianapolis, he made it clear how he approached the rehab grind: “You have to go in and be angry at every rep.” He brushed the injury off as “just a little speed bump.”
“Once you get all that in your mindset, that you’re going to come back a lot stronger (and) wake up a demon inside you,” he said then, nobody “can stop you.”
That mindset helped fuel the belief that Kansas City had landed a player ahead of schedule when it took him 32nd overall. The Chiefs said he was “well ahead of where he should be,” and Simmons backed that up by starting the first five games of the 2025 regular season at left tackle, a huge deal for a spot that had been the team’s biggest vulnerability the year before.
Around the anniversary of that knee injury, Simmons seemed ready to put the whole ordeal in the rearview mirror. Speaking at his locker before the Chiefs played the Detroit Lions, he said, “That day definitely, like, changed who I kind of was. But I try not to look at it as a haunting thing, if that makes sense,” and later added, “I try to wear that scar like a badge of honor in a way.”
He also acknowledged the mental toll without getting too deep into it, saying he went through some “crazy” stuff and that a situation like that can leave a player in “a bad mental space.”
At the time, it all sounded like the kind of answer that comes from someone who has already fought his way through the worst part and come out sharper on the other side.
Then the story changed.
Simmons missed that Detroit game for what the club listed as a family matter or “personal,” and he was out for the next three games as well. After that, he played only three more times before landing on injured reserve because of a season-ending wrist issue. What had looked like a case study in relentless rehab quickly became a public debate over his commitment.
Since joining the Chiefs, Simmons has played in only eight of the team’s 21 games, and that reality has shaped how plenty of people talk about him now. His status is still unclear as Kansas City, now 4-0, gets set to host the 0-4 Chargers on Monday, Oct. 18 at Arrowhead Stadium.
More recently, he has been sidelined for nearly two months with a lower-back injury, and Andy Reid finally offered specifics on Sept. 30.
“He’s had a bulging disk in his lower back, and it’s kind of hindered the strength of his leg,” Reid said. “He’s working through it.
He’s here every day, grinding it away, and we didn’t have to make any roster moves, so we didn’t have to put him on (injured reserve) or anything.
“It’s all worked out good that way. The positive is he is making progress and getting stronger, which is important with those backs, as we all know. Backs can be a little tricky.”
That last part may be the understatement of the year. It also left open the possibility that the Chiefs might have placed him on IR if they had known he would miss the required four-game stretch.
In the absence of a firm timeline, the speculation has filled the gap. Fans have had theories, the internet has had even more, and the noise around Simmons has grown louder by the week.
Maybe some of that could have been softened if Reid had explained the situation earlier. Maybe not. Either way, the bigger issue is that Simmons is still only 23, and the pace of his return is his story to tell.
That’s where perspective matters. This is the same player who, not long ago, was all-in on getting back from the knee injury - “immediate 110% effort,” multiple rehab sessions a day and “drinking unhealthy amounts of collagen.”
“I was doing whatever it took to get back to where I needed to be,” he said. “And that’s really what it kind of takes.”
It’s also the same player Brett Veach praised before the season for “just his nastiness and willingness to put a bad play behind … Just pushing through that, putting that bad play behind. Let’s go.
On to the next play. Not going to live in the past.”
So where does that leave him now?
We’ll see ... even if we’d rather know now.
In Other News...
Chiefs Got The Bye Week Break They Needed Before A Tricky Stretch
The bye week gave Kansas City a chance to sit back, rest up and watch the AFC West landscape shift around it while the Chiefs stayed undefeated at 4-0. Their lead in the division held firm as the Las Vegas Raiders fell to the New England Patriots, even as the Denver Broncos managed to win despite some offensive trouble, a reminder that the standings can look steadier than the football underneath them.
Now the attention turns to the bigger race, where the Chiefs are tracking the Jacksonville Jaguars and Baltimore Ravens as some of the most relevant challengers, with Buffalo still set to take the field on Monday night. The next test on the schedule is a tricky one against the Los Angeles Chargers, and after a week off, Kansas City enters it with a little more clarity on the road ahead and a lot less margin for error. [Read more 🡒]
Chiefs Unbeaten Start Is Rewriting What Fans Thought About This Roster
The early weeks of the season have given Kansas City a very different kind of storyline than many around the league expected. A perfect 4-0 start has pushed the Chiefs into a place where the usual questions about aging stars and depth pieces have, at least for now, been replaced by evidence that this roster is producing in all the right places. Kenneth Walker III has been one of the biggest drivers of that surge, Travis Kelce has been dependable again, and rookie cornerback Mansoor Delane has already looked like he belongs after going sixth overall.
What makes the opening month especially interesting is how much of this success has come from players who were not penciled in as the main attraction when the season began. Kahlil Benson, in particular, has carved out an unexpected role up front, giving the Chiefs stability at a spot that often decides how far a team can go. The bigger question now is whether this fast start reflects a real reworking of what the roster can be, or just the kind of early-season momentum that still needs to survive the grind ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Chiefs Receiver Shakeup Leaves Bigger Questions After The Bye
Andy Reids post-bye injury update left the Chiefs with another reshuffle to manage at receiver, where depth has already been tested and the room may look different once the team gets back to work. Reid said Tyquan Thornton is likely headed for injured reserve because of an ankle injury, while linebacker Cam Jones is expected to be activated from the practice squad, and Kansas City is bringing back Justin Watson, who spent the 2022-2024 seasons in the building.
The bigger question, though, is what comes next for the passing game once players return to the facility and the team gets a clearer read on Rashee Rice and left tackle Josh Simmons. Reid indicated more information is coming after that next round of evaluations, which leaves the Chiefs waiting on two important pieces while trying to sort out how much of their offensive plan can be stabilized coming out of the break. [Read more 🡒]