The Chiefs’ kicker situation got another strange wrinkle on Tuesday, and it only made the whole thing harder to read.
Matt Prater was among the players who worked out for Kansas City ahead of Week 11, a move that would normally fit the routine business of keeping tabs on available talent. Teams do that all the time. But in this case, the workout lands in the middle of a much messier picture, with the Chiefs already carrying two kickers and still refusing to make a clear move.
Harrison Butker remains on the active roster, while veteran Justin Tucker sits on the practice squad. Butker has missed all but two of eight field goals from 50 yards or more, which has put his job in obvious jeopardy even as the Chiefs continue to lean on the clutch work that helped build their dynasty. Tucker, meanwhile, is a recently suspended veteran accused of sexual misconduct who was inconsistent back in 2024, when he last kicked in the NFL.
That combination has left Kansas City in a strange spot. The questions have piled up, the criticism has followed, and Andy Reid has kept backing Butker when asked about the situation. Even with Tucker occupying a practice squad spot, the Chiefs have stayed with Butker through thin and... thin.
The odd part is timing. In Week 10’s win over the Atlanta Falcons, Butker went 5-for-5 on extra points and hit an unofficial 41-yard field goal, his only attempt of the game. After that steadier outing, Kansas City still chose to bring in another veteran kicker for a look.
Prater, 42, is no stranger to the league. He’s spent most of his career with the Detroit Lions and Denver Broncos, and he went 18 of 20 on field goals a year ago with the Buffalo Bills. He has been a free agent for the first half of the ’26 campaign so far, and on paper he would be a reasonable option if the Chiefs were ready to move on from Butker.
That’s the part that makes this even more puzzling. If Kansas City is truly preparing for a change, why wait until after Butker’s best performance in weeks?
If the team wants a new answer, why not turn to the kicker already on the practice squad? And if Tucker’s presence is part of the plan, why bring him in at all knowing the optics would be messy from the start?
Keeping tabs on the market makes sense. Staying ready for an emergency makes sense. But for a team that already has two kickers and still hasn’t settled on a direction, adding Prater to the mix only deepens the confusion.
In Other News...
Chiefs Are Quietly Addressing A Roster Problem Fans Cant Ignore
The Chiefs kept working the back end of their roster with a set of moves that speaks to how they are trying to stabilize depth before it becomes a bigger issue. Kansas City terminated the practice squad contracts of wide receivers Jacob De Jesus and Bub Means, then added tight end John FitzPatrick and running back E.J. Smith to the practice squad as the team continues to shuffle pieces around its developmental group.
Fred Johnson also visited the Chiefs after clearing waivers, a notable step for a team that has been looking for more help along the offensive line. With tackle depth always under the microscope in Kansas City, the interest in Johnson fits the broader pattern here: the Chiefs are quietly trying to patch holes now rather than wait for them to show up on game day. [Read more 🡒]
Chiefs Suddenly Have A Roster Decision Fans Need To Watch
The Chiefs are staring at one of those midseason roster calls that can quietly shape the rest of the year. Defensive tackle Omarr Norman-Lott has been working back from a torn ACL and has not played since early in his rookie season, but Kansas City has until November 18 to decide whether to activate him from injured reserve or shut him down for the season.
Jared Wileys ankle injury only adds another layer to the equation, since it is likely to send the tight end to injured reserve and open a spot on the roster. Kansas City can use that opening on Norman-Lott if the medical staff and coaches think he is ready, or it can use the flexibility elsewhere as the Chiefs weigh immediate depth against a longer view. [Read more 🡒]
Former Chiefs QB Just Jumped Into The Patriots' Quarterback Mess
Drake Mayes right ankle fracture has left the Patriots scrambling at quarterback, and Mike Vrabel is now weighing every possible path to keep the position afloat while Maye is out for an extended stretch. With the injury landing in Week 10, the conversation in New England has quickly shifted from development to survival, and that has opened the door to familiar names surfacing around the team.
Among them is Matt Cassel, the former Patriots quarterback who publicly offered to come back. For Chiefs fans who remember Cassels time in Kansas City, it is another reminder of how quickly quarterback depth can become a league-wide issue, and how a veteran with ties to New England can suddenly re-enter the picture when a team is forced to rethink its plan under center. [Read more 🡒]
