Harrison Butker has spent most of his Kansas City Chiefs career building a case as one of the most dependable kickers in NFL history. Now, after two uneven seasons, the conversation has shifted from legacy to pressure.
At 30, Butker still owns a career field goal percentage of 88.4%, which ranks fourth all-time among NFL kickers. That résumé includes huge playoff moments, multiple Super Bowl wins, and a reputation for coming through when the Chiefs needed him most. But the last two years have chipped away at that image.
In 2024, Butker hit 84% of his field goal attempts, the second-lowest mark of his career. Last season, he improved to 86.8%, but that still left him 15th in the league and only slightly above average.
The bigger problem came on extra points, where he converted just 31 of 35 attempts for 88.6%. That was the lowest rate of his career, well below the league average of 95.9%, and the second-worst mark in the NFL among qualified kickers.
The misses piled up early. Chiefs fans saw Butker miss a kick in five of the first six games last season, and he finished with nine misses overall, the most of his career. One especially damaging moment came in Week 5 against the Jacksonville Jaguars, when he kicked a late fourth-quarter kickoff out of bounds and handed Jacksonville a key field-position edge on the drive that ended up winning the game.
By then, the trust seemed to be fading. The clearest example came in Week 14 against the Los Angeles Chargers, when Kansas City was down three late with a timeout left.
The Chiefs had a choice: let backup quarterback Gardner Minshew, who had played five snaps all season at that point, try to make a play, or give Butker a chance at a 50- to 55-yard field goal. Kansas City went with Minshew instead.
He threw a 20-yard pass into double coverage that was intercepted, and the Chiefs were eliminated from the playoffs.
That decision said plenty. A year ago, sending Butker out for a 55-yarder in that spot would have felt automatic. Last season, it did not.
The financial side only sharpens the issue. Butker’s $25M contract makes him the third-highest-paid kicker in the league, behind Chris Boswell and Brandon Aubrey. Kansas City is paying premium money for premium production, and last season the results did not match the price tag.
That’s where the heat comes from. The Chiefs need a steadier version of Butker if they’re going to make another serious run at a Super Bowl championship, but if the decline continues, they may be forced to look elsewhere for a kicker who is both better and cheaper.
There is also the uncomfortable comparison to Justin Tucker. The former Baltimore Raven was long viewed as the best kicker ever, yet his final three seasons fell off sharply, with field goal percentages of 86%, 86.5%, and then 73.3%. Baltimore cut him that offseason with three years still left on his contract.
Butker still has a chance to avoid that kind of ending. He could bounce back and remind everyone why he became such a trusted weapon in the first place. For now, though, the reality is plain: the Chiefs are paying a lot for a kicker who didn’t deliver enough last season, and that puts him squarely on the hot seat.
In Other News...
Chiefs Fans Will Get A Kick Out Of Clark Hunt Here
Outside MetLife Stadium during the World Cup final in New Jersey, a Kalshi reporter asked fans and a few notable figures how much they paid for their tickets, and the answers ranged from eye-popping sums to people who were invited or did not pay at all. Among the crowd was a suited Clark Hunt, the chairman and CEO of the Chiefs, taking in one of soccers biggest stages and sounding every bit like someone enjoying the spectacle.
The clip gets a little extra texture once the interviewer identifies the man in the suit, because it is not every day Chiefs fans see their owner wandering through a street interview at a World Cup final. Hunts reaction to the ticket question fit the moment, too, with the kind of enthusiasm that underscored just how singular the event felt, even for someone used to big-league settings. [Read more 🡒]
Chiefs Suddenly Have A Noah Gray Problem They Can't Ignore
Noah Grays 2025 season left the Chiefs with a much different conversation than the one they were having a year earlier. After a breakout 2024, the tight ends production fell off sharply, with career lows across the board and a noticeable drop in the kind of steady receiving work Kansas City had started to count on. Even with a three-year extension in hand, Grays place in the offense suddenly looks less secure than it did when he was emerging as a possible long-term piece.
Kansas City still has to plan for life after Travis Kelce, and Gray was supposed to be part of that answer. Instead, the Chiefs now have to decide whether he can still grow into the reliable starter they need or whether the position has to be addressed another way. With competition and alternatives already in the mix, Gray does not have much margin for another step backward before the pressure around his future gets even louder. [Read more 🡒]
Emmett Johnson Has One Big Hurdle Before Reid Trusts Him
Kansas Citys running back room looks a lot different heading into 2026, with Kenneth Walker added as the top free-agent back and Emari Demercado brought in as a third-down option. That leaves rookie Emmett Johnson trying to carve out a role in a crowded group, even though his college tape gave the Chiefs reasons to think he can help as a runner and as a receiver out of the backfield.
The path to real snaps is less about what Johnson can do with the ball than what he does without it. Training camp and preseason will be his chance to show he can handle the full job description, and for a team that needs reliability around Patrick Mahomes, that part of the evaluation matters as much as anything else. If Johnson can earn trust in the protection game, he could force his way into the conversation sooner than expected. [Read more 🡒]