The Jacksonville Jaguars are getting tagged as one of the NFL’s offseason losers, but the way their summer has actually played out tells a different story.
With training camp now fewer than four weeks away and the league nearing its late-July wake-up call, the window for teams to reshape their rosters is basically closed. That’s why the Jaguars’ work has started to get picked apart in national offseason rankings, including a recent one from USA Today. Still, there’s a case to be made that James Gladstone and company deserve a lot more credit than they’ve received.
A big part of the disconnect comes down to how offseason success gets judged. The league and its media spend plenty of time warning teams not to overdo it in free agency, especially clubs coming off losing seasons. But then when a team keeps its powder dry, spends carefully, and avoids headline-grabbing mistakes, it gets labeled boring - or worse.
Jacksonville finished No. 32 in offseason spending this year, and that number would probably look a lot different if the Jaguars had gone on a Tennessee Titans-style spree or followed the Arizona Cardinals into a big-money spending push. But the Titans handed out bloated deals to role players, and the Cardinals spent like they could afford to. That kind of activity can make an offseason look busy fast, even if the actual payoff is questionable.
Instead, the Jaguars put their money into their own core. They extended Travon Walker, Montaric Brown, Jakobi Meyers, Brenton Strange, and others.
Before May, the only outside free agent they added was veteran running back Chris Rodriguez Jr. on a minor deal. They also let several free agents walk.
That approach should matter because it comes with future value attached. Devin Lloyd, Travis Etienne, and Greg Newsome are expected to bring the Jaguars Day 3 compensatory picks in the 2027 draft, a nice return for a team that chose not to chase outside names just for the sake of activity.
The exits of Lloyd and Etienne have drawn the loudest criticism. Lloyd is now with the Carolina Panthers, Etienne with the New Orleans Saints, and both departures have been treated like major losses. But the reality is a little less dramatic than the reaction suggests.
Lloyd was valuable last season, but he was hardly untouchable. He didn’t even win the starting linebacker job out of training camp, opened Week 1 rotating with Ventrell Miller, and didn’t really settle in until his turnovers started showing up the following week.
Even after he became the clear starter, the Jaguars still took him off the field on most third downs. That’s not the profile of a player whose departure should wreck an entire offseason.
Etienne brought energy, touchdowns, and plenty of moments in an eventful 2025 season. But the Jaguars’ rushing attack still wasn’t good, and Etienne has been one of the more inefficient backs in the league over the course of his career. Given the price difference between him and the new running back room, Jacksonville may actually find it easier to build a stronger ground game now.
In the end, the Jaguars didn’t chase splashy headlines. They kept the players they wanted, added draft capital, and avoided the kind of moves that can haunt a team later.
They lost a couple of productive players, sure, but neither was treated as indispensable. If Jacksonville believed it needed them, they would still be here.
That’s what makes this offseason feel more disciplined than disappointing. The Jaguars did the kind of work that used to be praised: stay out of the March frenzy, protect the roster, and think ahead. For some reason, that hasn’t been enough for everybody.
In Other News...
ESPN Just Said Something Jaguars Fans Will Argue About All Summer
ESPNs Seth Walder didnt exactly light up Jacksonvilles offseason, but he also didnt bury it, handing the Jaguars a B grade and pointing to a few moves that gave the front office some tangible wins. The extensions for Travon Walker and Cole Van Lanen drew praise, with Van Lanens growth over the last year helping make the deal look especially sensible from an outside view.
The bigger debate, though, may be the one that sits at the center of Jacksonvilles next roster-building cycle. Walder questioned the Jaguars first-round 2026 pick of Nate Boerkircher as a reach, even as the team has talked up his ability to make a real offensive impact and sees him as an instant impact candidate after a promising offseason. That kind of split between outside skepticism and internal belief is exactly the sort of thing that tends to linger all summer. [Read more 🡒]
Jaguars Suddenly Getting A Much Lower Ceiling Than Fans Expected
A year out from the next NFL playoff picture, the Jaguars are already being viewed as a team with a narrower runway than fans might have hoped. In this speculative look ahead, Jacksonville still lands in the postseason conversation, but only as a lower-end AFC seed after an offseason that did not do much to raise the ceiling or restore the kind of momentum teams want to build around their young core.
The concern is less about whether the Jaguars can hang around the playoff race and more about whether the roster has enough juice to do much more than that. With key departures from the front seven and backfield, plus no obvious splash with premium draft capital to soften the blow, the current projection has Jacksonville in the mix for around 10 or 11 wins and back in the bracket, but still searching for the kind of upgrade that turns a solid team into a dangerous one. [Read more 🡒]
Josh Hines-Allen Still Sets The Tone For Jaguars Defense
Josh Hines-Allen keeps looking like the kind of defender who can anchor a whole side of the ball, which is why he remains such a central figure as the Jaguars turn toward the 2026 season. The pass-rush starts with him, and so does the broader tone of the defense, even if the conversation around his value is bigger than any one game or one stretch of production.
He already sits atop the franchise sack record book, a marker that matches the way opponents have had to account for him for years. Still, there is a familiar wrinkle to the discussion around Hines-Allen: his impact goes well beyond the raw sack total, and the next step is tied less to chasing numbers than to finishing plays with even more consistency. [Read more 🡒]