The Jaguars have taken plenty of swings in free agency over the years, and not all of them have connected. Some were expensive.
Some were brief. A few were flat-out disasters.
With the release date for Grand Theft Auto VI finally here, it’s a fitting time to look back at the Jaguars’ own history of “grand theft” in free agency - the signings that never came close to paying off.
Before Jacksonville became a team willing to spend big in free agency, the choices were a little different. That’s why wide receiver Desmond Howard makes the list from the early days.
The former Heisman Trophy winner and No. 4 overall pick arrived in the 1995 expansion draft, and while he carried plenty of name value from Michigan, his lone season with the Jaguars produced just 26 catches for 276 yards and a touchdown. He also failed to make much of an impact on return teams.
Zach Wiegert is another case where the fit matters more than the contract label. He never signed a major deal with Jacksonville, so it’s not really fair to frame him as a classic free-agent bust.
Still, in a period when the Jaguars weren’t spending like they would later, Wiegert’s four seasons with the team were solid but limited by injuries. He started at both guard and tackle, but he was never an every-week fixture.
When the Jaguars did start chasing bigger names, the misses got louder. Hugh Douglas was brought in to provide the kind of pass-rush help that could line up opposite Tony Brackens, but the $27 million deal never came close to delivering that return.
Douglas managed just 3.5 sacks in 16 games with Jacksonville after posting 37 combined sacks over the previous three seasons. In franchise terms, he was a complete zero.
The receiver market brought its own pain. Jerry Porter signed a six-year, $30 million deal in 2008, then lasted only one season in Jacksonville.
He played in 10 games, caught 11 passes for 181 yards and a touchdown, and was cut the following year. He never appeared in another regular-season NFL game.
Then came the quarterback swing that still stands out as one of the most misguided decisions in team history. The Jaguars handed Nick Foles a four-year, $88 million deal with over $50 million in guarantees, even after watching his career up close.
Foles had just won a Super Bowl in a handful of flukey starts the year before, and while he could hardly be blamed for taking the money, the Jaguars were the ones who made the bet. He spent one season in Jacksonville before being traded to the Chicago Bears in 2020.
The Jaguars’ receiver search kept going after that, with the team cycling through names like DJ Chark, Laviska Shenault, Christian Kirk, Zay Jones and Calvin Ridley before another round of moves in 2024. Jacksonville drafted Brian Thomas Jr. in the first round and signed Gabe Davis to a three-year, $39 million deal in March. Thomas has had so-so results, but Davis was the real miss.
In his only season with the Jaguars, Davis caught 20 passes for 239 yards and two touchdowns. Injuries played a part, but the outcome was still ugly enough that the new regime released him the next season, even with a dead money hit that the Jaguars are still paying this season. Among the team’s free-agent swings, Davis stands as the biggest bust in some time.
In Other News...
Giants Pass Rusher Has Extra Motivation For Jaguars Showdown
Abdul Carter has found a little extra fuel heading into the Giants matchup with Jacksonville, and it comes from a decision the Jaguars made on draft night. The second-year pass-rusher made clear he has not forgotten the fact that Jacksonville passed on him, and he is carrying that into a game that gives him a direct chance to make his case on the field.
Carter has also been candid about his own production, acknowledging that his sack totals have not been where he wants them to be. Still, his focus remains on helping the Giants win, and this meeting with the Jaguars offers a timely stage for him to show the kind of impact he believes he can make. [Read more 🡒]
Jaguars Suddenly Have A Big Week 11 Question Around Bhayshul Tuten
The Jaguars injury report got a little heavier Thursday, with 11 players listed as limited or not participating in practice, and Bhayshul Tuten was one of the more notable names on it. After opening the week with a limited session Wednesday, the running back was downgraded to a non-participant, a development that naturally drew attention given how important he has become to Jacksonvilles offense alongside Trevor Lawrence and Parker Washington.
Liam Coen has already made clear how much he values Tutens toughness and what he has brought even while dealing with the injury, and the early expectation is that he will be out there for the Week 11 matchup with the New York Giants. Still, the shift from limited work to no practice at all is enough to keep this situation on the radar as the Jaguars move through the week and sort out who is truly ready to go. [Read more 🡒]
Jaguars Face Two Huge Questions In Push For A Fourth Straight Win
The Jaguars head to MetLife Stadium with a chance to stretch their winning streak to four, but this one comes with a few moving parts that could shape the afternoon in a hurry. Jacksonville is trying to keep its momentum going against a Giants team that will test the Jaguars in the trenches and on the perimeter, while the offense also has to adjust up front after Robert Hainseys injury pushes Jonah Monheim into a bigger role.
The biggest early question is Bhayshul Tuten, whose ankle-foot issue leaves his status uncertain just as Jacksonville would like to lean on the run game. On the other side, Malik Nabers gives New York a dangerous target, and the Jaguars secondary will be under the microscope with Jessie Bates III expected to make his debut. For a team trying to keep stacking wins, those two matchups could go a long way toward deciding how comfortable this trip to New Jersey feels. [Read more 🡒]
