Iowa State may have landed a big one for next season, and it came from a courtroom, not the transfer portal.
Judge Kara Krothe of Indiana’s Monroe County Circuit Court granted an injunction Wednesday morning that gives Tamin Lipsey - along with about 90 other athletes - a fifth year of eligibility. For Iowa State, that opens the door for the Ames native to return for the 2026-27 season.
Lipsey’s name was added to the lawsuit on Monday, September 14, as part of a larger challenge aimed at blocking the NCAA from enforcing its new age-based eligibility rule. That policy excluded players from the 2022 high school class, and the suit is one of many around the country pushing for a fifth season. In all, roughly 80 cases involving about 450 athletes are working through the same issue.
The NCAA’s updated rules, adopted in the summer, give players five years of eligibility beginning at their 19th birthday or high school graduation, whichever comes first. But courts have been siding with plaintiffs who argue the policy is being applied in an arbitrary and unfair way to the 2022 class.
With the injunction in place, Lipsey can now move forward as a college player for the upcoming season. A portion of the litigation reviewed by Cyclone Alert indicated that if Lipsey won another year, he would play at Iowa State in 2026-27.
That would be a major lift for a backcourt that suddenly needed help. Killyan Toure, the projected starter, is out after a shoulder injury and is expected to miss at least until January, with February also a possibility.
That leaves Iowa State relying on JaQuan Johnson and Ryan Prather Jr., the two guards on the roster with college experience. Prather, though, has been dealing with a hip issue since the summer.
The Cyclones also bring back second-year guard Jamarion Batemon, but he had limited on-ball chances as a freshman. Incoming first-year guard Yusef Gray Jr. is another option, though he missed the first half of the summer while recovering from a shoulder injury he suffered during his senior season of high school.
Lipsey, meanwhile, is coming off a knee injury sustained in NBA Summer League competition, so he’ll need to get back to full strength before Iowa State opens against Memphis. His Summer League stint does not block him from returning to the Big 12 because his Exhibit 10 deal with the Pacers was never executed.
Over the last four seasons, Lipsey has built a decorated résumé. He’s a three-time All-Big 12 selection, a three-time All-Big 12 defensive team pick and a 2024 All-Big 12 Tournament team honoree. In 2025-26, he put together a career year, averaging 13.5 points, 3.9 rebounds, 5.1 assists and a Big 12-best 2.3 steals per game.
The legal fight may not be finished, though. In similar cases around the country, the NCAA has appealed rulings or asked for stays while the appeals are pending.
"The next step the NCAA usually takes is when they appeal it up to the appellate court, they ask that court to stay the injunction while their appeal is pending," sports law expert Mit Winter said on the Cyclone Alert podcast. "So, I presume the NCAA would do the same thing here, and it's kind of been a mixed record with that approach for the NCAA."
If an appeals court rules for the NCAA, Lipsey and the other plaintiffs would lose their eligibility. If a stay is granted, that same result would follow. Even then, the athletes could still try again in another court to pursue eligibility.
In Other News...
Iowa State Gets An Early Big 12 Test It Cant Fake
Utah has spent the opening month looking every bit like a Big 12 heavyweight, outscoring its first three opponents by a combined 142-24 and stacking up impressive numbers on both sides of the ball. Now the Utes step into conference play against Iowa State, a team that has built its own early case with strong defensive production and a run game led by its top rusher. It is the kind of league opener that should tell both programs something real about where they stand.
For Iowa State, this is less about surviving an early test than meeting a contender on the same field and finding out whether its defensive foundation can travel. The matchup also carries some added familiarity, with the two programs having a recent history that gives this one a little more edge than a typical opener. Both coaches have already acknowledged the stakes of the moment, and the Cyclones now get a first Big 12 measuring stick they cannot really sidestep. [Read more 🡒]
Tamin Lipsey Just Changed Iowa States Ceiling Again
A court ruling in Indiana has opened the door for nearly 90 college athletes to play another season, and that includes a familiar name for Iowa State fans in Tamin Lipsey. Judge Kara Krothe granted a preliminary injunction in Monroe County Circuit Court, giving the group access to a fifth year of eligibility and setting up a potential ripple effect across college basketball.
For the Cyclones, Lipseys possible return matters because it keeps one of the programs most important pieces in the picture as the roster takes shape for another run. The ruling also touches several other notable players around the country, from Malik Reneau to Tre White, and the NCAA is expected to appeal, so the final answer is still unsettled even if the immediate impact is already being felt. [Read more 🡒]
Arnold Barnes Is Giving Iowa State A New Edge Before Utah
Arnold Barnes III has quickly carved out a niche in Iowa States backfield, giving the Cyclones a more physical option as they head into the Utah game. The Tulane transfer made an impression against Bowling Green, where he found the end zone twice and showed the kind of downhill running that fits what Iowa State wants to establish in its ground game.
Jimmy Rogers has already pointed to Barnes as a player who takes coaching well and brings a tougher edge to the offense, which matters even more as the Cyclones prepare for a matchup where every yard figures to be earned the hard way. Barnes is expected to factor heavily in short-yardage spots, and for Iowa State, that kind of reliability could become one of the more important parts of the game plan. [Read more 🡒]