Iowa State left Week 5 with the kind of loss that can disguise bigger problems if you only look at the final score. The Cyclones fell to BYU, 24-10, in a defensive fight on the road, and they did manage to stay close for stretches against the eighth-ranked team in the country. But once the Cougars started grinding away, Iowa State never had enough offense to respond.
The concern starts with the passing game, and it lands squarely on Jaylen Raynor. He turned in what was easily his roughest outing of the season against BYU, finishing 16-for-29 for just 98 yards.
He did not throw an interception, but the lack of production was glaring. For a team that already wants to lean on defense and the run game, that kind of output leaves very little margin.
Aiden Flora at least gave Iowa State something to hang onto. He ran for 86 yards on 17 carries and was the bright spot in an otherwise sluggish offensive showing. But his effort couldn’t cover for a passing attack that spent most of the night going nowhere.
That has become a familiar issue. Raynor now has 1,001 passing yards on the season, along with a 57.4% completion percentage and seven touchdown passes. Through six games, those numbers simply haven’t matched the kind of lift Iowa State needs from its quarterback.
The backdrop makes it even more complicated. Raynor arrived from Arkansas State with plenty of experience and looked like a sensible fit for the job. Instead, his play has raised real questions about where this offense goes from here.
At 3-3, Iowa State is still in decent shape relative to preseason expectations. A bowl game remains within reach, and after the kind of offseason the program went through, that would count as a strong result. But if the Cyclones want to get there, they need far more from the quarterback position than they’re getting now.
And at this point, the conversation about whether another option deserves a chance can’t be ignored.
In Other News...
Jimmy Rogers Sounds Alarm As Iowa State Hits Bye Week
BYUs 24-10 win left Iowa State heading into its bye week with plenty to sort through, and Jimmy Rogers wasted little time pointing to the defensive end of the field. Bear Bachmeier did damage through the air and on the ground, but the bigger concern for the Cyclones was how often the game got away from them in key moments, especially after an offense that produced its fewest yards since 2018 could never fully help steady things.
Jaylen Raynors line told part of the story, but not all of it, because the overall picture was one of a team that never found rhythm and now has extra time to reset. Rogers said the defense needs to be better, and the bye week gives Iowa State a chance to address the issues before the seasons next stretch gets any less forgiving. [Read more 🡒]
Iowa State Women's Basketball Faces An Emotional Bill Fennelly Turning Point
Bill Fennelly has given Iowa State womens basketball a long runway to process what comes next. After 31 years at the helm, the Hall of Fame coach said the 2026-27 season will be his last, a decision that brings the Cyclones to a familiar place for a lot of long-running programs: gratitude for what has been built, and uncertainty about how to replace it. Fennelly is the winningest coach in Iowa State athletics history, going 656-335 with the Cyclones and guiding the program to 24 NCAA Tournament appearances.
For Iowa State, the announcement is as much about legacy as it is about the future. Athletics director Jamie Pollard praised Fennellys impact on both the program and the community, a reminder that his reach has gone well beyond the scoreboard. The timeline gives the Cyclones some breathing room, but it also starts the clock on an emotional transition that will shape the program long after his final season ends. [Read more 🡒]
Tamin Lipsey Is Already Impacting Iowa State In One Crucial Way
Tamin Lipsey is already giving Iowa State something it values even before the season tips off. Officially added to the roster on Sept. 28, the veteran guard is in the middle of a bid for a fifth year of eligibility under the NCAAs five-in-five rule, but the immediate impact has been less about paperwork and more about presence. As the Cyclones piece together a roster with returning players and new transfers, Lipseys competitiveness and leadership have stood out for head coach T.J. Otzelberger.
For a team trying to build depth and stay in the Big 12 race, those traits matter as much as any box-score number. Iowa State is still waiting on the larger eligibility picture to settle, and that uncertainty leaves one important part of the roster in limbo heading into the season. Even so, Lipseys place in the program is already clear enough to be felt in practice, where the Cyclones are banking on his edge to help set the tone. [Read more 🡒]