The Cy-Hawk trophy is headed back to Iowa City after Iowa survived Iowa State in Kinnick on a game-winning field goal, and the win had all the familiar ingredients of a traditional rivalry scrap. The Cyclones arrived with the goal of wrecking Iowa’s massive recruiting weekend, but the Hawkeyes did enough to escape and take the trophy home to its “rightful resting place.”
And yet, for all the relief that comes with a rivalry win, there was still plenty to sort through the morning after. Iowa State had this game down to the wire in Week 2 with a portal-built group, which leaves one obvious question hanging over both teams: are the Cyclones really that good, or is Iowa possibly bad?
I’m going with The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly, in reverse order.
The ugly part started with Iowa’s offense, which looked far less inventive than it did in Week 1. On first down especially, the Hawkeyes were predictable and plain. That was a sharp drop from the opener, when they mixed in multiple first-down passes and showed a level of creativity that hasn’t been part of the program in years.
The special teams picture wasn’t much prettier. Reece Vander Zee mostly settled for fair catches or let punts bounce and roll, and it wasn’t until the fourth quarter that he actually brought one back.
Evan James didn’t field a punt return until late either. That’s a different kind of efficiency: if you never try to return punts, you can’t muff them.
Iowa also kept trying quarterback sneaks, and none of them worked. At some point, someone needs to remind the staff that Mark Gronowski graduated last year.
The bad section is short on one level and ugly on another. Iowa had red-zone problems in Week 1, but in Week 2 the bigger issue was that it barely got there at all.
The run game never really found a rhythm, finishing at 3.2 yards per carry and 93 yards total on the ground. It didn’t feel good in real time, and it’s fair to wonder whether Iowa State’s transfer-heavy group was just that strong in Week 2.
Defensively, Iowa State quarterback Jaylen Raynor had a relatively clean afternoon. He wasn’t pressured much and was never sacked, even though the ISU offensive line was not known as a strength of that team.
The good news for Iowa starts with the defense. Cam Buffington piled up 10 tackles by halftime and finished with 15, and this was only his second start, in Week 2.
Jayden Montgomery and Jaylen Watson also played well, and the linebacker group as a whole stood out. That fits with what the staff said in fall camp, when it described the room as deep with seven or eight players expected to contribute.
There were some bright spots on offense too. Brown did a solid job running the ball outside of the quarterback sneak calls, and he scored on a second-quarter end around to the left. He also kept his composure when pressure came and delivered several throws as the pocket started to break down.
The Hero
In Other News...
Kirk Ferentz Just Kept Iowas Quarterback Debate Alive
Iowas in-state rivalry win gave Kirk Ferentz enough reason to sound encouraged about a young roster still learning on the fly, and quarterback Hank Brown was a big part of that. Brown handled a tough defensive atmosphere with poise, completing 21 of 30 passes for 191 yards and adding a rushing touchdown, the kind of performance that suggested he can keep the offense steady even when the pocket gets busy.
Still, the postgame message left the larger quarterback picture open. Ferentz said the position will be evaluated week by week, and he made clear the staff still believes in both Brown and Jeremy Hecklinski, which keeps the discussion alive as Iowa moves deeper into the season. For a team trying to build around development as much as results, the next decision at quarterback may matter just as much as the last one. [Read more 🡒]
College GameDay Just Added More Fuel To Iowas Cy-Hawk Stakes
The Cy-Hawk rivalry already carries plenty of heat, and this weeks buildup picked up another layer when College GameDay weighed in on Iowas side of the matchup. The shows hosts and analysts looked ahead to the annual meeting with Iowa State and backed the Hawkeyes, adding a little more national attention to a game that always feels bigger than the record books suggest.
Iowa State comes into the rivalry in the first season under new head coach Jimmy Rogers, which gives the Cyclones a fresh look against an Iowa team that will have the home-field edge at Kinnick Stadium. The setting is set for a late-afternoon kickoff on NBC, and with both fan bases circling the date, the spotlight around the Cy-Hawk game only seems to grow as the week goes on. [Read more 🡒]
Iowa State Win Came Down To One Overlooked Hawkeye Play
In a rivalry game at Kinnick Stadium, the spotlight usually settles on the kicker when a game-winning field goal is on the line. But the operation only works if every piece is clean, and Iowa had one of those hidden moments go exactly right against Iowa State. Tanner Philpott was part of the sequence, handling the pressure that comes with a kick that can swing the whole day.
The snap came in awkwardly, leaving Philpott to react quickly and get the ball set in place. He did his job well enough for the kick to stay true, and Caden Buhr finished the play with the game-winner. It was the kind of detail that can get lost in the postgame rush, even though it was central to how Iowa came away with the result. [Read more 🡒]