The Colts don’t need a long look to know where the pressure is coming from this season. With holes all over the defense heading into the draft, Indianapolis was always going to need rookies to grow up fast. And outside of linebacker CJ Allen, who looks like a Week 1 starter, a few other first-year players have a real shot to get on the field early.
The most obvious opening may be at wide receiver, where Deion Burks enters a room with a clear top two and a messy battle behind them. Alec Pierce and Josh Downs are set at No. 1 and No. 2, but the third spot is still up for grabs.
Ashton Dulin, Nick Westbrook-Ikhine, Anthony Gould, and Burks are in the mix, though Gould is likely out of the picture. That leaves Dulin, Westbrook-Ikhine, and the rookie fighting for position.
Dulin has spent six seasons in Indianapolis as a depth receiver and kick returner, and he has never really climbed beyond that role. If he doesn’t take a bigger step this offseason, Burks could slip into the conversation. The Colts were high on Burks before the draft, and with the receiver room lacking proven depth, he has a believable path into the passing game if he holds up in training camp.
Linebacker Bryce Boettcher is in a different kind of spot, one shaped by how unsettled the Colts are at the position. In a normal year, he’d be looking at a long shot for real snaps.
This isn’t a normal year. Allen is locked in at middle linebacker, and Akeem Davis-Gaither, who played under Colts offensive coordinator Lou Anarumo for five seasons with the Cincinnati Bengals, is expected to start on the weakside.
That leaves Boettcher competing for the strongside job.
He might win that role outright, but even if he doesn’t, the Colts may still need him early and often. In this linebacker group, playing time looks very much within reach.
Then there’s safety A.J. Haulcy, who may have the most crowded path but also the clearest upside if things break right.
The Colts have plenty of bodies in that room, including Juanyeh Thomas and Jonathan Owens, both of whom have starting DNA. Haulcy is also battling Hunter Wohler and Nasir Adderley.
Still, his route to the field is easy to see. If he beats out the others, he could line up next to Cam Bynum.
Anarumo clearly values the kind of defender Haulcy is, and that could matter. If he doesn’t win the job in Week 1, he still has a strong chance to be part of the rotation right away, with a path to a starting role down the line.
In Other News...
Colts Fans Would Love This Jaguars Move For All The Wrong Reasons
A speculative move involving Tyrel Dodson has put the Jaguars in a familiar spot for AFC South observers, because any shuffle on that side of the ball can ripple well beyond Jacksonville. Dodsons recent track record has already raised questions, with inconsistency showing up in both run defense and pass coverage, and Seattle was frustrated enough to move on from him during the 2024 season.
For Colts fans, the appeal is obvious even if it comes for the wrong reasons. If Jacksonville were to add a linebacker with those kinds of recent concerns, it could leave a rival defense less reliable in a division where every edge matters, and Indianapolis would be happy to see that kind of uncertainty show up across the field. [Read more 🡒]
ESPNs Colts Trade Value List Leaves Out Two Fan Favorites
ESPNs latest trade-value exercise put a familiar spotlight on the Colts roster, and it also showed how much roster value can depend on position as much as talent. Bill Barnwells list of players who could realistically bring back first-round draft-pick value included a few obvious premium assets, with Sauce Gardner at the top end of the discussion and young building blocks like Laiatu Latu and Tyler Warren also drawing attention for what they could command in a hypothetical deal.
What stood out just as much was who Barnwell left out. Quenton Nelson and Jonathan Taylor were among the notable omissions, a reminder that even star-level production does not always translate cleanly into trade value when positional economics come into play. For Colts fans, it is the kind of list that invites debate about how the league sees the roster, and which names are prized enough to move the needle if another team came calling. [Read more 🡒]