The Colts have no reason to shop Jonathan Taylor just for the sake of it, but there is a scenario where moving him starts to make sense. If Indianapolis stumbles early, a bigger reset could come into focus, and that kind of thinking could even begin before the season kicks off.
If Chris Ballard does end up taking calls, the New York Giants are the team that fits best. They have a workable group of running backs, but nobody in that room brings Taylor-level impact.
For a young quarterback like Jaxson Dart, that matters. A back of Taylor’s caliber could help him grow faster and make life a whole lot easier.
The fit is easy to picture. Dart already brings a dual-threat skill set, and pairing that with Taylor would give New York something similar to what the Baltimore Ravens have with Lamar Jackson and Derrick Henry.
Dart is not Jackson, at least not yet, but the comparison is about the style of offense more than the exact player. Taylor, meanwhile, is the kind of runner who can tilt a game, and he’s younger than Henry.
For the Giants, this would be about giving Dart the kind of weapon that can speed up a rebuild. For the Colts, the logic would have to come from the return. A straight-up deal for draft value would not be enough if it left Indianapolis thin behind Taylor, especially with DJ Giddens and rookie Seth McGowan in the mix.
A deal like this would have to bring back more than just a pick:
Indianapolis Colts receive: 2027 second-round pick and running back Tyrone Tracy Jr.
New York Giants receive: Running back Jonathan Taylor
That kind of package gives the Colts a second-rounder in 2027, which matters because first-round picks are already in short supply. Indianapolis sent its first-round choice to the New York Jets last season in the Sauce Gardner trade, so adding another Day 2 pick would help offset that loss.
Tracy would step into the lead-back role in Indianapolis, though more as part of a rotation than as a true bell cow. He also fits Shane Steichen’s offense well because he can run between the tackles and catch the ball out of the backfield.
The Giants already have Cam Skattebo, who is expected to be their lead back. But he was injured in 2025, so there’s uncertainty around how healthy he’ll be. Taylor is the better player, and having both backs would give New York a chance to keep them fresh through games and deep into the season.
There’s also the contract angle. Taylor is set for free agency next offseason, and the Colts do not appear likely to give him a long-term extension. If Indianapolis is going to move him, doing it before the start of the 2026 season would at least let the team extract value instead of letting him walk for nothing.
In Other News...
Adam Vinatieri Is Finally Getting A Colts Honor He Deserves
Adam Vinatieris place in football history has long been secure, and the Colts are finally giving him a team honor that fits the rsum. The franchise will add the former kicker to its Ring of Honor in Week 6 when Tennessee visits, a fitting nod for a player whose clutch kicks helped define an era in Indianapolis and whose name still carries weight well beyond one locker room.
The timing only adds to the moment. Vinatieri was also announced as a 2024 Pro Football Hall of Fame inductee, with Canton set for August 8, giving him another milestone in a career that spanned elite runs with both New England and the Colts. For Indianapolis, the Ring of Honor recognition is less a surprise than a long-awaited formality, and it will be worth watching how the ceremony is handled when the Titans come to town. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Cornerback Battle Is Turning Up The Heat On Cameron Mitchell
Cameron Mitchell has already shown the Colts enough to stick around once, and now he is trying to do it again in a much tighter cornerback room. After joining Indianapolis practice squad last season following his release from Cleveland, Mitchell was pushed onto the 53-man roster because of injuries and ended up getting into eight games, including one start, while carving out a role on defense.
The challenge this summer is less about getting noticed and more about surviving the numbers game. Indianapolis has a crowded group at corner, and Mitchell is in the mix for one of only a few roster openings as the Colts sort out who fits best behind their top options. His path is still there, but with so many bodies in the room, every practice rep feels like it matters a little more. [Read more 🡒]
Bears Are Learning The Hard Truth Colts Fans Knew About Dayo
Dayo Odeyingbos move to Chicago was supposed to give the Bears a bigger, more disruptive edge presence after four seasons in Indianapolis, but the early returns have looked far closer to buyers remorse than a breakout. The former Colts rusher signed a three-year deal that could reach $48 million, and while increased playing time was supposed to unlock more production, the overall picture has not matched the price tag.
Even with some modest counting stats in his first year, Odeyingbo has not given Chicago the kind of impact it was expecting, and the contract still has a notable financial wrinkle attached to the back end. For Colts fans, it is a familiar reminder of what they saw in him here: useful size and effort, but not the kind of edge threat that changes an offenses game plan. [Read more 🡒]