Shane Steichens Next Move May Come Faster Than Colts Fans Think

Despite a challenging record, Shane Steichen's coaching acumen and past achievements could secure his future in the NFL.

Shane Steichen’s time in Indianapolis has been rough enough that a change feels close, but that doesn’t mean his next stop has to be far away.

The Colts have gone from 9-8 in Steichen’s first season to 8-9 in each of the last two years, and they’re sitting at 3-8 so far this season. He has not delivered a winning season in Indianapolis, and the Colts’ playoff drought is about to stretch to six years. With offseason changes ahead, Steichen looks likely to be on the way out.

Still, the bigger question is whether that would close doors for him elsewhere. The answer may be no.

One thing working in Steichen’s favor is the offensive reputation that helped get him the Colts job in the first place. His best NFL quarterback work came with Jalen Hurts, who posted his best statistical regular season in 2022 when the Eagles reached the first of two Super Bowls in three years. Steichen was the brains behind Philadelphia’s offense, and the source material argues Hurts has never looked the same since.

That connection makes Philadelphia an interesting possibility if both the Eagles and Colts move on from their head coaches. If Nick Sirriani is fired in the offseason and Steichen is let go in Indianapolis, the Eagles could be a natural landing spot.

The other major factor is the situation Steichen has been dealing with in Indianapolis. Over his three-and-a-half years there, he has worked with what the source describes as one of the least talented teams in the league. Jonathan Taylor and Alec Pierce stand out on offense, but not enough to turn the Colts into a real playoff threat.

Quarterback play has been part of the problem too. Steichen has not had a top-10 or even top-15 quarterback to build around, with Gardner Minshew, Joe Flacco, Daniel Jones, and Philip Rivers all cycling through the position. Rivers’ short stint last season was fun for nostalgia, but it “fell dead.”

The broader roster picture hasn’t helped either. The source points to poor roster construction throughout Steichen’s tenure and raises the possibility that, with even a mid-level roster, the results could look very different.

So while Steichen appears headed for the exit after this season, that may not be the end of his head coaching run. If teams buy into his offensive background and give him a better setup than the one he had in Indianapolis, another opportunity could come quickly.

In Other News...

Colts Quarterback Mess Just Sparked A Bigger Debate About The Franchise

The Colts quarterback situation has already turned into a bigger organizational conversation, and Breiden Fehoko poured fuel on it with a public critique of owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon after Daniel Jones was released. Indianapolis had already taken a major swing by trading first-round picks and players for Sauce Gardner, then moved on from Jones after a rough season and a costly contract extension, leaving the roster churn and the front office decisions under a brighter spotlight than usual.

Shane Steichen said the release was made in the best interests of both sides, but the reaction around the move has gone well beyond the depth chart. Former Colt Stephon Gilmore stepped in to defend Irsay-Gordons football knowledge and leadership, underscoring how quickly a quarterback decision can turn into a referendum on how the franchise is being run. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Ownership Debate Just Got More Uncomfortable For Carlie Irsay-Gordon

Carlie Irsay-Gordon has been a familiar sight on the Colts sideline for years, and not everyone has loved the optics of it. The principal owner and CEO has taken her share of criticism for being so close to the action on game days, even as she has said the hands-on approach is part of her effort to understand the game better and lead the franchise more effectively.

Mark Cuban recently stepped in to defend that style of ownership, arguing that being near the field can help an owner learn and make better decisions. His support adds a notable outside voice to a debate that has followed Irsay-Gordon for a while, and it only underscores how unusual, and uncomfortable for some, her sideline presence continues to be. [Read more 🡒]

Anthony Richardson Sideline Scene Fuels Bigger Colts Quarterback Debate

Anthony Richardsons afternoon against the Texans was over almost as soon as it began, with the Colts quarterback appearing for just three snaps before the conversation around Indianapolis shifted from the game itself to what comes next. Shane Steichen did not publicly break down Richardsons performance afterward, but he made clear the evaluation process would be broader than one player, saying the staff would review everything, including Daniel Joness play.

For a Colts team sitting at 3-8, the loss only sharpened the scrutiny on a quarterback situation that has been unsettled for much of the season. The timing matters, too, with New York up next on the schedule and every decision at the position now carrying extra weight as Indianapolis tries to steady a season that keeps raising more questions than answers. [Read more 🡒]