The Colts’ defense heads into 2026 with a very different look, and PFF’s 2025 grades give a clear snapshot of where this projected starting group stands.
Indianapolis spent the offseason trying to get younger and faster on that side of the ball, a response to a 2025 defense that allowed 24.2 points per game, good for 21st in the league. Injuries in the secondary and an inconsistent pass rush were major reasons the unit struggled, and general manager Chris Ballard responded with plenty of roster turnover.
On paper, the group has some real high-end pieces. Laiatu Latu posted an 84.1 grade, the strongest number among the projected starters listed here, while safety AJ Haulcy checked in at 86.6.
At corner, Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward both landed in the high-quality range with grades of 77.5 and 77.1, respectively. Safety Cam Bynum also graded well at 70.8, and DeForest Buckner came in at 74.0.
There are also some clear question marks. Grover Stewart’s 57.3 lands in average territory, Arden Key finished at 63.7, and Akeem Davis-Gaither came in at 49.9. Justin Walley is listed with no grade because of injury.
For context, PFF’s scale runs from poor at 39.9 or less to elite at 90.0 and above, with the middle tiers filling out the rest of the range. It’s useful for measuring performance, but it’s still just one piece of the evaluation puzzle.
Here’s how the projected starters graded out in 2025:
Laiatu Latu: 84.1
DeForest Buckner: 74.0
Grover Stewart: 57.3
Arden Key: 63.7
CJ Allen: 75.8**
Akeem Davis-Gaither: 49.9
Sauce Gardner: 77.5
Charvarius Ward: 77.1
Justin Walley: N/A (injured)
Cam Bynum: 70.8
AJ Haulcy: 86.6**
In Other News...
Colts Were Handed A Dream Win-Now Draft Colts Fans Will Debate
NFL.coms hypothetical seven-round redraft handed Indianapolis a kind of wish-list scenario, one that invites Colts fans to argue over both the ceiling and the realism of the haul. In the exercise, the Colts came away with a stacked mix of talent across the board, highlighted by an edge rusher in Will Anderson Jr. and a few other names that would instantly change the tone of the roster.
The fun for Colts followers is in the fit as much as the star power, because the mock puts real help around the lineup in places that have been easy to talk about for a while. Drake London would give Indianapolis a legitimate top target, Sauce Gardner would be back in the fold in a way that makes the secondary look far different, and even the later-round choices point to a team that would be trying to win now rather than think several seasons ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Why This Colts Rookie Keeps Coming Up In Anarumo's Defense
Bryce Boettchers path to the Colts has been anything but ordinary. Drafted with the 135th pick, the rookie linebacker arrives with the kind of toughness and competitive streak Indianapolis likes to tout, plus a rare versatility that could let him handle either MIKE or WILL in Lou Anarumos defense. It is the sort of profile that stands out even before a player takes a meaningful NFL snap, especially for a team still sorting out how its young linebackers fit together.
Boettcher also brings a background that makes him easy to notice in a room full of rookies. Before football became the clearer lane, he was drafted by the Astros and walked on at Oregon in both baseball and football, a route that helped shape the passion for the game Colts scout Kasia Omilan pointed to when discussing his fit. Even in the spring, when he spent most of his time with the second unit and only briefly mixed in with the starters, Boettcher kept showing up for the same reasons that got him here in the first place. [Read more 🡒]