Sean McVay’s Rams have had some real magic come through the kicker spot. Greg Zuerlein helped power the franchise to Super Bowl 53. Matt Gay later nailed the kick that finished off a playoff win over Tom Brady and the Buccaneers, setting the stage for a championship run.
But ever since Gay left after the 2022 season, Los Angeles has been trying to solve the same problem over and over again. The latest reset came after Harrison Mevis was cut following Monday night’s struggles, and Blake Grupe is now the next man up.
It’s become a familiar pattern for the Rams: find a kicker, ride the production for a bit, then start the search all over again.
Gay was the standard. After beginning his career in Tampa Bay, he arrived in Los Angeles in 2020 and quickly established himself.
In 2021, he earned a Pro Bowl nod after making 32 of 34 field goal attempts. He stayed sharp in the playoffs, going 4-for-4 during the Rams’ Super Bowl run, and in 2022 he connected on 93.3 percent of his kicks.
Then the Rams let him walk in free agency and he signed with the Colts.
The next year brought more instability. Brett Maher got the first shot at replacing Gay after his run in Dallas ended with missed extra points in the playoffs.
With the Rams, though, he went only 3-of-7 on field goals from 50 yards and beyond, and he was released in October. He later came back for the season finale and a playoff loss to the Lions after the replacement struggle.
Lucas Havrisik filled in between Maher’s two stints in 2023, but he never locked down the job. He appeared in nine games and converted just 2 of 6 attempts from 40 to 49 yards, though he did go 2-of-3 from at least 50 yards.
That wasn’t enough to keep him on the roster. His only other NFL action came with the Packers in 2025, when he played in three games.
The Rams tried a different approach in 2024, using a draft pick on Stanford kicker Joshua Karty at No. 209 overall. Karty handled his rookie year fairly well, making 85.3 percent of his field goal attempts and going 6-of-7 from 50 yards and out. But the job slipped away in 2025, when he made only 10 of 15 attempts before getting released midseason.
Mevis was the next stop. The “Thiccer Kicker” stepped in for Karty in 2025 and delivered at a high clip, hitting 12 of 13 tries, though he only got one attempt from beyond 50 yards.
This season, though, he opened just 5-of-9, including a blocked attempt on a potential game-winner against the Bills that already looked off target. That was enough for the Rams to move on.
Now Grupe gets the call. He arrives with 50 games of NFL experience after the Rams signed him off the Jets’ practice squad, where New York had kept him as insurance behind Jason Sanders. Grupe owns an 81.9 percent career field goal mark, though 2025 was a rough one by his standards, as he hit just 78.4 percent of his attempts between the Saints and Colts.
In Other News...
Jeff Saturday Shared The Colts Title Memory Fans Will Love
Jeff Saturday spent 13 seasons anchoring the middle of the Colts' line and became one of the defining figures of that Super Bowl XLI run, so when he looks back on the championship, it is not hard to understand which memories still stand out. The former five-time Pro Bowler recently revisited that title season, and his favorite recollection had less to do with the football itself than the family moment that followed once the celebration spilled beyond the field.
Saturday pointed to the postgame scene with his entire family gathered after the win, a snapshot that captured what the ring meant away from the locker room noise. The story also came with a lighter family twist involving his young son and an Xbox game, a detail that has the kind of charm fans tend to remember just as fondly as the trophy itself, especially with another Super Bowl broadcast scheduled for WRTV on Feb. 14. [Read more 🡒]
Spencer Shrader Put Colts History In Play Even In A Loss
Even in a loss to the Steelers, there were a few Colts performances worth circling for reasons beyond the final score. Spencer Shrader handled the kicking duties cleanly, converting every field goal and extra point he tried, and Tyler Warren continued building an impressive early rsum with another game that put him alongside some notable franchise company at tight end.
Akeem Davis-Gaither also kept showing up around the ball, finishing with seven tackles for the fifth straight game in which he reached that mark. Still, Shraders night stood out most because of how much of the offense he accounted for in a game where Indianapolis had to lean on every point it could find, and there was a larger piece of team history hanging in the background as the Colts tried to salvage something from an otherwise frustrating result. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Have A Real Chance To Rebound But One Problem Lingers
The Colts head into Week 6 with a chance to steady themselves against a Titans team that has not found its footing offensively, and the matchup on paper gives Indianapolis a real path back to .500. Tennessee has spent much of the early season searching for answers under center, with Cam Wards struggles continuing to shape the conversation around the franchise as the season moves along.
Indianapolis, though, is not walking into a clean fix-all game. Even with the Colts installed as a touchdown favorite, there is still a lingering issue on the other side of the ball, and it is one that could keep this from being a simple rebound opportunity. If the Colts are going to take advantage of a vulnerable division opponent, they will need to be sharper than they have been in some recent defensive outings. [Read more 🡒]