Jonathan Taylor is still getting treated like one of the league’s best backs, and that matters for the Colts as they stare down a major decision on his future.
Indianapolis has to choose between extending Taylor or trading him before next offseason, and there’s no mystery about what Colts fans want. They want the team to keep the six-year veteran in place, and they want the front office to do whatever it takes to make that happen. Given how Taylor has looked, that’s not hard to understand.
Taylor turned in the best season of his career outside of his second NFL year in 2021, and he remains as explosive as ever. The Colts know exactly what he brings to the offense, especially with another big season expected as they try to stay in the AFC South race. The only real question is where he stands among the NFL’s elite running backs.
According to ESPN’s latest rankings, Taylor belongs in the top five. The list was compiled with input from league executives, scouts and coaches, and Taylor came in fifth. Ahead of him were Bijan Robinson of the Atlanta Falcons, Jahmyr Gibbs of the Detroit Lions, Saquon Barkley of the Philadelphia Eagles and Christian McCaffrey of the San Francisco 49ers.
That placement keeps Taylor in rare company. ESPN has ranked him as high as No. 2 in the past, and he slipped to No. 7 last year. This year’s spot feels like a fair middle ground, especially with the names sitting above him.
Right behind Taylor is Derrick Henry of the Baltimore Ravens at No. 6. James Cook of the Buffalo Bills, De'Von Achane of the Miami Dolphins and Kenneth Walker III of the Kansas City Chiefs follow him, with Breece Hall of the New York Jets completing the top 10.
Taylor’s standing only sharpens the Colts’ dilemma. The market for running backs is not exactly overflowing with players who can match his level, and the source material points out that D'Andre Swift and Chase Brown are the only other notable backs expected to hit free agency next season. Neither is close to Taylor.
That’s why the Colts’ next move carries so much weight. Taylor has already given them enough to know what they have, and the longer they wait, the tougher the decision gets.
In Other News...
Why Colts Believed Deion Burks Was Too Good To Last
Deion Burks did enough at the NFL Combine to make teams take notice, and the Colts were among the clubs that saw more than just a quick slot target. His 4.3-second 40-yard dash ranked with the fastest times among wide receivers, and he added 26 bench press reps, tied for the most at the position, a rare show of strength for a smaller-framed receiver.
That blend of burst and power is why Indianapolis believes Burks can be used in more ways than the usual inside role. The Colts think he can threaten defenses from multiple alignments and see a path for him to help in the return game as well, even though that part of his profile is still more projection than proven production. [Read more 🡒]
Jaguars Rookie Is Suddenly A Bigger Deal For Trevor Lawrence
The AFC South is getting a fresh layer of intrigue in 2026, and the rookie class could end up shaping more than just training camp storylines. Houston, Indianapolis, Jacksonville and Tennessee all added players who are expected to matter quickly, but the Colts interest in the division goes beyond simply keeping pace. Their defense is in the middle of a reset, and the next wave of young talent is being asked to help stabilize it.
For Indianapolis, the linebacker spot is one of the clearest pressure points, which is why the rookie brought in to handle that area has drawn so much attention. He arrives with the kind of profile that can change a units tone right away, even if his path into the league came with some draft-day hesitation because of injury concerns. If he settles in the way the Colts believe he can, it would give them a much-needed answer in the middle of a defense that has to improve if they want to stay in the division race. [Read more 🡒]