Colts' Free Agency Moves: A Closer Look at Three Questionable Signings
The Indianapolis Colts kicked off the free agency period with a bold move, re-signing wide receiver Alec Pierce to a lucrative four-year deal. Bringing back quarterback Daniel Jones was another notable decision. However, some of the subsequent moves by GM Chris Ballard have raised eyebrows, particularly on the defensive side of the ball.
Let's dive into three free-agent signings that might not be sitting well with Colts fans.
Edge Rusher: Arden Key
The need for a solid edge rusher was clear, especially after losing Kwity Paye to free agency. Arden Key was brought in to fill that void, but his track record suggests he might not be the game-changer Indy needs.
With a career-high of just 6.5 sacks and only four last season, Key’s impact as a pass rusher is questionable. His tackling woes are another concern, missing 22.2% of his attempts last season.
For the Colts to get the most out of Key, these numbers need significant improvement.
Defensive Tackle: Derrick Nnadi
Derrick Nnadi's signing raises questions about what the Colts see in him. While he has plenty of starts under his belt, his production has been underwhelming.
Nnadi has managed just 22 pressures over the past four seasons and struggles against the run, with only 13 run stuffs in the last two years. His missed tackle rate of 14.3% in 2025 is particularly troubling for an interior lineman.
If Nnadi can turn things around in Indianapolis, it would be a surprising turnaround.
Edge Rusher: Michael Clemons
Michael Clemons' addition seems to contradict the Colts' goals of getting younger and more athletic. Clemons had a rough 2025, missing 26.9% of his tackle attempts.
His contribution in terms of pass rush was minimal, with just one sack and five quarterback hits. Colts fans are hoping for more from their defensive line, and Clemons will need to step up to meet those expectations.
As the Colts look to bolster their roster, these signings will be under the microscope. The team may need to look toward the draft to address lingering needs, but without a first-round pick, finding top-tier talent will be a challenge. Colts Nation will be watching closely to see how these moves play out on the field.