ESPN’s Ben Solak doesn’t believe the Indianapolis Colts are going to get back to the version they showed in the first half of 2025, and his case starts with two things: Daniel Jones’ health and the roster turnover around him.
Jones is the biggest swing factor. Indianapolis re-signed him to a two-year contract extension that could reach $100 million in earned incentives, but the quarterback is still working back from the season-ending torn Achilles he suffered late in Week 14 of last year.
For a passer whose game leans heavily on mobility, a full recovery in this window would be a surprise. His rehab has reportedly been encouraging, but 2026 may end up functioning more like a redshirt year, which could have been part of the thinking behind the deal.
Where Solak’s argument gets more debatable is in how much weight he puts on the Colts’ veteran departures. Michael Pittman Jr. stands out as the one loss that really matters on offense, especially for all the little things he did to keep drives alive and help the unit stay on schedule. But the changes at other spots look more like calculated resets than damaging losses.
Indianapolis traded Zaire Franklin and let Braden Smith walk in free agency, and both moves make sense from a roster-building standpoint. Franklin didn’t appear to be an ideal fit in Lou Anarumo’s scheme, and his play had tailed off.
Smith’s durability was also a real concern, especially with his price tag. The Colts clearly wanted to get younger and more affordable at both starting linebacker and right tackle.
That’s why the expectation is that rookie CJ Allen can replace Franklin without much drop-off in production, while second-year tackle Jalen Travis can step in for Smith and hold his own. The experience and leadership won’t be the same, but the on-field difference may not be dramatic.
There’s a similar view in the secondary. Nick Cross had his moments as a run defender and in the box, but he was also something of a coverage gamble. Rookie safety AJ Haulcy is viewed as a better fit for Anarumo’s defense and a more natural, versatile option, with the hope that his pass coverage becomes more consistent over time.
Solak may still be right about the bigger picture, but the stronger concern for the Colts is elsewhere. The real problem is the lack of meaningful upgrades at edge and wide receiver, along with the uncertainty surrounding Jones’ health in 2026.
In Other News...
Colts Swing Tackle Battle May Already Have An Undrafted Favorite
The Colts have a familiar offseason theme playing out again up front, with a cluster of undrafted free agents trying to carve out jobs and, in particular, a swing tackle role that always carries outsized value. Nolan Rucci and Bayron Matos are among the young tackles in the mix, and Indianapolis has given itself reason to believe it can keep finding useful pieces in that part of the roster by developing linemen who arrive without much draft pedigree.
Rucci, in particular, is drawing the kind of attention that can turn a camp battle into a real roster conversation. His physical traits and upside have put him near the front of the pack, and the Colts track record with undrafted offensive linemen only adds to the intrigue. The question now is whether that promise shows up quickly enough for him to become a trusted swing tackle before the roster starts to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Just Got Pulled Into Another Quarterback Debate Fans Dread
The Colts have spent enough time in quarterback uncertainty already, so it is no surprise that another outside suggestion would land with a thud. Bleacher Reports latest idea tied Indianapolis to Minnesotas J.J. McCarthy as a possible backup option, a move that would only add another young passer to a room already trying to sort out where Anthony Richardson fits and how much stability the team really has behind him.
McCarthys profile does not exactly scream clean solution, either. He has battled injuries, is still trying to prove he can hold down an NFL job, and comes with a contract that would ask Indianapolis to pay more for a quarterback who might not be any more settled than the one already on the roster. With Riley Leonard also in the mix, the Colts may have a cheaper and simpler answer in-house, which is why this latest quarterback link feels less like a fix and more like another reminder of how unresolved the position still is. [Read more 🡒]
Shane Steichen Just Gave Colts Fans A Troubling Alec Pierce Update
Alec Pierces offseason has taken a more complicated turn than the Colts probably wanted when he went under the knife in late March to address an ankle issue he had been playing through. Shane Steichen said the wide receivers target is to be ready for Week 1, which at least gives Indianapolis a clear benchmark, but it also leaves the team waiting on a player who has become an important part of the passing game.
The uncertainty matters because Pierce was expected to use the offseason to get back on track, not spend it rehabbing a surgery that has already pushed his timeline into the summer. For a Colts offense trying to build continuity, every missed practice rep counts, and the closer this recovery gets to the start of the regular season, the more the team has to think about how it will manage his workload if he does make it back on time. [Read more 🡒]