Daniel Jones is trying to chase the same kind of career rescue Sam Darnold pulled off, and the Colts are betting the setup in Indianapolis can help him do it.
The connection between the two quarterbacks is easy to see. Both were drafted in the top 10.
Both were supposed to be the answer for New York teams that viewed them as franchise saviors. Darnold landed with the Jets in 2018, Jones with the Giants a year later, and both eventually washed out in that spotlight.
In New York, that kind of failure sticks.
They also crossed paths in Minnesota. In 2024, Darnold was rebuilding himself into a Pro Bowl-caliber quarterback, and late in the season Jones joined him there after being released by the Giants.
He never played for the Vikings, but simply getting away from New York seemed to help. By the next season, both were with new teams.
Now Colts fans are hoping Jones can follow Darnold’s path all the way to the finish line. Darnold completed his comeback last year by leading the Seattle Seahawks to the Super Bowl title. The question hanging over Indianapolis is whether Jones can help the Colts do something similar in 2026.
That is a big ask for a team that has not reached the postseason since 2020. Even getting into the playoffs would count as a major step for Shane Steichen’s group.
Still, the Seahawks offer at least one useful comparison. They had missed the playoffs in back-to-back seasons before winning it all last year.
Their run came with one of the league’s top defenses and the Offensive Player of the Year at receiver in Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Indianapolis does not appear to have that kind of firepower.
What the Colts do have is a strong foundation up front. A recent Pro Football Focus ranking placed their offensive line fourth overall, while Seattle’s line was ranked 15th. Jones will also have an elite running back and an ascendent tight end to work with.
And when he was healthy last season, with many of the same offensive pieces around him, Jones was at the controls of one of the league’s most explosive offenses.
There are still real reasons for skepticism. Players usually need time to fully regain their form after an Achilles tear, and while Jones’ recovery has been impressive, nobody will really know how ready he is until he gets hit in live action.
His résumé also invites caution. Jones has had stretches where he played well, only to follow them with a disappointing season.
Darnold faced the same kind of questions after his big year in Minnesota. He had done it once, but could he do it again?
That same history is now working against Jones.
I don’t have those doubts. I always believed Daniel Jones could be a plus QB if given the proper tools.
With the Giants, he rarely had a quality line or dangerous receivers. His one major weapon, running back Saquon Barkley, was hurt too often.
Jones also spent six seasons in New York bouncing through three different head coaches and three different offensive coordinators. He never seemed fully synced with that revolving door.
That looks different in Indianapolis, where Jones and Shane Steichen have reportedly built a very close relationship.
So Jones enters 2026 with some real advantages. But he also has one huge issue staring him in the face.
Who is going to catch his passes? The Colts no longer have Michael Pittman. New WR1 Alec Pierce has not practiced this training camp after surgery to repair his damaged ankle.
Keenan Allen is now in the mix and could fill the role of the possession receiver that Pittman handled well last year. But if Pierce misses significant time, or if the ankle affects his production, Jones will have a hard time driving an explosive offense.
The top quarterbacks can cover for average talent. Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen have shown that.
Jones is not in that tier, even if he can be very good. He already showed last season that he can run a talented, creative offense effectively.
What he has not shown is that he can carry a thinner group to success.
If Jones is going to truly mirror Darnold’s Seattle finish, he will need plenty to go right. The defense has to be better than it was last season.
Jonathan Taylor has to keep being the workhorse. The Colts have to stay healthy.
And above all else, Alec Pierce has to be out there and operating at full speed. With that kind of support, Indianapolis and its quarterback could surprise people. Without it, the season could go sideways fast.
In Other News...
Colts Ownership Is Already Facing A Sideline Debate Fans Will Notice
Carlie Irsay-Gordon has already become one of the more visible figures around the Colts, taking over as principal owner and CEO in May 2025 after the passing of her father, Jim Irsay. With Indianapolis coming off an 8-9 finish in 2025 and working through the rest of its 2026 preseason schedule, her presence on the sideline has naturally drawn more attention than it might for a first-year owner in a steadier situation.
Jason Whitlock recently seized on that visibility, criticizing Irsay-Gordon for being on the field level during preseason action and questioning how involved she should be compared with other NFL owners. It is the kind of sideline debate that can linger when a franchise is already under a microscope, especially for a team trying to reset its footing and move beyond a middling season. [Read more 🡒]
Former Colts Pick Is Back On Fans' Radar For A Reason
Eric Johnson II is getting another NFL shot, and it has put the former Colts draft pick back into familiar conversation for Indianapolis fans who remember his arrival in 2022. The defensive tackle has already made the rounds in the league, spending time with the Colts, Patriots and Vikings, and now he is headed to Atlanta after the Falcons signed him for a summer competition on the defensive line.
For Colts followers, the name carries a little more weight because Johnson was part of that fifth-round class and once fit into the teams long-term development plans. He will also have a familiar face on the other side of the building, reuniting with former defensive line coach Nate Ollie as he tries to carve out a roster spot with the Falcons. [Read more 🡒]
Kenny Moores Colts Exit Is Looking Riskier By The Day
Kenny Moore IIs split with the Colts has settled into an uneasy holding pattern, and it has only sharpened the sense that Indianapolis has already moved on. Moore asked for a trade and then a release after his playing time dwindled in Lou Anarumos system, a sign that the veteran corner no longer saw a clear fit in a defense that has leaned younger at his position.
Justin Walley has been one of the names benefiting from that shift, drawing attention in training camp and looking like the player the Colts are lining up to replace Moore. For Moore, the next step has been less certain, as he remains unsigned and is working out locally to stay ready while he waits for the right opportunity to open up. [Read more 🡒]