The Colts went young and fast at linebacker, and early on, that gamble has come with some rough edges.
Indianapolis expected Bryce Boettcher, Jaylon Carlies and CJ Allen to help reshape the position, but each rookie is running into the same thing in different ways: the NFL moves quicker, thinks harder and punishes hesitation. Linebackers coach James Bettcher is trying to thread the needle between letting them grow and needing immediate results while the Colts keep pace with some of the league’s top quarterbacks.
Allen, the team’s top pick in April’s draft, is the clearest example of how steep the adjustment can be. He didn’t play a defensive or special teams snap in his debut Sunday, and for now the middle linebacker job he was brought in to fill belongs to veteran Akeem Davis-Gaither, who has taken over green-dot duties. That setup suggests Allen may still be a few weeks away from making a real impact.
Bettcher likes the work Allen puts in. What he wants more of is certainty.
“His preparation’s been awesome. He comes in early, stays late,” Bettcher said. “There isn’t anything CJ’s not doing from a preparation standpoint, it’s just time on the grass for him, it’s time on task."
The rookie is coming from Georgia, where the SEC version of offensive football is one thing and the NFL version is something else entirely. Bettcher pointed to the league’s motion-heavy run schemes, shifting fronts and the way offenses use linemen and movement to mess with a linebacker’s eyes before the snap. In the passing game, the space gets stretched thin in a hurry.
“The complexity of the run game, and then the space that you play in, in the pass game,” Bettcher said. “There’s a lot of islands you’re on, there’s a lot of isolations offenses create.”
For Allen, the read-and-react part is still catching up to the speed of the league.
“His time will come,” Bettcher said. “When it does, he’s going to go out there and play, and he’s going to play well.”
The two young weak-side linebackers are producing different kinds of tape, but both are still works in progress.
Boettcher, the fourth-round pick out of Oregon, flashed immediately against Baltimore. He piled up six tackles in only 23 snaps, playing with the kind of burst that jumps off the screen. Bettcher likes the way he attacks, but that same edge can get him into trouble if he arrives in the wrong place.
“A guy that was decisive, quick-trigger, he played fast,” Bettcher said. “He’s continuing to grow and find out when he can do that, and when he can’t. … He had a lot of production in his 20 snaps he played on early downs.”
Carlies is the more frustrating puzzle. Bettcher called him arguably the Colts’ best coverage linebacker, but against Baltimore he didn’t register a statistic in 42 snaps. He’s often in the right neighborhood, just not there fast enough to make the play.
“He’s really still in that phase of learning how to play the linebacker position,” Bettcher said. “He’s a position-move guy.
There’s going to be things where his decisiveness isn’t the same as it will be a month from now, two months from now, a year from now. J.C. did some great stuff in coverage.
He was in the right spots in the run game, it’s just the decisiveness factor. We can’t play the game and not have any tackles at the linebacker position.
We all understand that.”
So for now, the Colts’ linebacker rotation is still being sorted out. The talent is obvious.
The speed is there. What’s still missing is the kind of snap-to-snap conviction that turns potential into production.
In Other News...
Colts Now Face A Keenan Allen Problem The NFL Could Escalate
Keenan Allens arrival in Indianapolis was supposed to be about giving the Colts another proven target in the passing game, but now the discussion around him has shifted far away from football. The veteran wide receiver was charged with two misdemeanor counts tied to operating a vehicle while intoxicated after his arrest in downtown Indianapolis, turning what should have been an early-season roster storyline into a far more serious off-field issue for the organization.
Police said they observed signs of intoxication, and Allens breathalyzer test registered a blood alcohol concentration of 0.224. Colts general manager Chris Ballard said the team is handling the matter internally, while any discipline from here would fall to the NFL, leaving Indianapolis to wait on the leagues next move while trying to keep the focus on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Fans Already Have A CJ Allen Question Ballard Didn't Expect
CJ Allen arrived with the kind of draft pedigree that usually invites an immediate role, and Colts general manager Chris Ballard only added to that sense by describing the second-round pick as a potential defensive communicator. But when Week 1 arrived, the plan on the field looked different. The green dot assignment went to safety Cam Bynum, while Allen stayed on the sideline and did not see action in the opener.
Now the conversation shifts quickly to what comes next. Akeem Davis-Gaither is expected to handle the green dot duties in Week 2, and the linebacker rotation appears headed toward more work for Bryce Boettcher and Jaylon Carlies as well. For a player Ballard seemed to have pegged for an important early job, Allen's first month is already starting with more questions than anyone around the Colts likely expected. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Suddenly Face Another Alec Pierce Concern Before Chiefs Game
Alec Pierce was back on the Colts' injury report Thursday, this time sidelined by a heel issue tied to an old injury after fully participating Wednesday. It adds another layer of attention to a receiver who has become a meaningful part of Indianapolis' passing plans, especially with Kansas City coming to town and the margin for error shrinking.
The Colts still expect to use Pierce fully against the Chiefs, with official injury designations coming Friday. Indianapolis had its own brief scare at quarterback too, as Anthony Richardson missed Wednesday with a groin injury before returning to full practice Thursday and is expected to back up, leaving the bigger focus on whether Pierce gets through the week cleanly. [Read more 🡒]