Not everybody is buying the Indianapolis Colts’ plan this offseason.
General manager Chris Ballard and the front office chose not to blow things up. Instead, they leaned into what they believed already worked, kept the roster from getting bloated, and tried to add youth and athleticism where they thought it mattered most. That approach came with conviction, especially on offense, where the Colts committed to quarterback Daniel Jones and wide receiver Alec Pierce on multi-year deals worth about $144 million in guaranteed money.
NFL.com’s Matt Okada wasn’t nearly as enthusiastic. In his offseason grades, he gave Indianapolis a C- and singled out those two moves as the biggest reason for the low mark.
" Indianapolis Colts, Grade: C-
"Standout moves:
Re-signing QB Daniel Jones, WR Alec Pierce
Trading WR Michael Pittman Jr.
Making solid Day 2 draft selections
"My grade on Indianapolis' offseason hinges quite a bit on my disapproval of the Jones and Pierce signings," Okada wrote. "The veteran quarterback penned a two-year, $88 million deal after putting together a half-season of high-level play before tearing his Achilles in December.
Pierce landed a four-year, $116 million contract -- top-15 wide receiver money -- after posting (mediocre) career highs of 47 catches and 1,003 yards in 2025. The rest of Indy's free agency action was largely lateral, though trading Pittman to Pittsburgh might leave the offense with a bit of a hole on the outside.
"The Colts' draft was fine, highlighted by the selections of Allen and safety A.J. Haulcy on Day 2 (after missing out on Day 1 festivities due to the Sauce Gardner trade). But, for me, it wasn’t enough to make up for the risky, optimistic investments they made into Jones and Pierce."
That criticism starts with Jones, and it’s easy to see why. The Colts are betting he can come back from the Achilles injury he suffered in December and pick up again at the level he showed in the first half of last season.
But Indianapolis also boxed itself into a difficult corner. The offense was humming early, and once that happened, tearing it down for a new quarterback was never going to be a simple call. Going after Malik Willis, Aaron Rodgers, Kirk Cousins, or Kyler Murray would have carried its own risk, and it would have forced the Colts to rebuild the offense around a new quarterback learning Shane Steichen’s system from scratch.
The Michael Pittman Jr. move brought the same kind of debate. Indianapolis sent him to the Pittsburgh Steelers and handed the WR1 job to Alec Pierce.
That decision looks bold on paper, but the Colts clearly believe they’ve already seen enough from Pierce over the last two seasons to make him the centerpiece. Pittman, meanwhile, was headed toward being the NFL’s seventh-highest-paid receiver in 2026 with a $29 million cap hit, even as the Colts appeared to view him as nearing the back end of his prime.
The defense got its own reset through the draft, with linebacker CJ Allen and safety A.J. Haulcy positioned as important pieces of the future.
The Colts needed to refresh the linebacker room, and they did it by trading Zaire Franklin to the Green Bay Packers and letting Germaine Pratt leave in free agency. Allen brings the kind of intelligence and all-around game that should keep him out of the bad spots that hurt his veteran predecessors.
Haulcy fills a different need. He’s stepping in for Nick Cross, who developed into a strong box safety but doesn’t bring the same coverage instincts or ball skills. Haulcy has the physical style to handle work in the box, too, which gives Indianapolis a chance to keep that role intact while upgrading it.
So yes, the Colts’ offseason wasn’t built for universal approval. But with the team in win-now mode, the front office clearly decided the bigger gamble would have been ripping up the foundation in the sport’s most important spots.
In Other News...
NFL Verdict On Colts' Sauce Gardner Raises One Big Question
Sauce Gardners first year with the Colts has already become more about projection than production, and the latest leaguewide read on him reflects that. In ESPNs annual poll of coaches, executives and scouts, Gardner landed ninth among NFL cornerbacks, a step back from where he stood a year ago, even though evaluators still see the traits that made him such a coveted addition in Indianapolis.
The concern is less about whether Gardner can cover and more about how complete his game looks when he is on the field. He was limited by a calf injury after arriving from the Jets in 2024, and his brief run in Indianapolis left the usual mix of praise and skepticism intact, with teams still weighing his length and ball skills against questions about tackling, zone consistency and whether the Colts will get enough healthy snaps to see the full version of him. [Read more 🡒]
ESPN Just Singled Out A Young Colts Corner Fans Can't Ignore
A young cornerback has become one of the more intriguing names in the Colts secondary conversation, and ESPN analyst Aaron Schatz recently pointed to him as a key nonstarter who could still wind up playing a major role this season. The expectation is that he can handle the nickel spot, which would put him in the middle of a defense that needs reliable coverage help and some immediate answers from a player whose college rsum already showed strong ball production and pass deflections.
Justin Walleys path to this point has not been smooth, with his rookie year interrupted by a knee injury before he could fully get going, but he has been back in offseason work and has clearly kept the staffs attention. The Colts have seen enough to believe there is real upside here, and the buzz around him is not just about surviving camp or filling a spot, but about whether his development can keep moving fast enough to match the teams expectations. [Read more 🡒]