The Colts and Texans are back at it Thursday night in Houston, and this AFC South matchup has spent more than two decades producing the kind of swings that stick. Since Houston entered the league in 2002, the teams have met 50 times, with Indianapolis owning a 34-15-1 edge in the rivalry’s all-time record.
That number tells part of the story, but not all of it. There was the long run when the Colts had Houston’s number, then a stretch when the Texans flipped the script. In between came overtime drama, a playoff-style season finale, a tie, a coach’s frightening halftime collapse, and even a game remembered for something that had nothing to do with football.
Here’s a look back at some of the matchups that defined the series.
The first meeting came on Sept. 22, 2002, when the Colts rolled to a 23-3 win in Houston. Peyton Manning threw for 272 yards and two touchdowns against the expansion Texans and rookie quarterback David Carr, setting the tone for the early years of the rivalry.
Indianapolis opened the series with nine straight wins before Houston finally broke through in 2006. The Texans’ 27-24 win in Houston snapped that streak, even though the Colts would go on to win the Super Bowl that season.
One of the more memorable Colts wins came in 2011, when Indianapolis was slogging through a 2-14 season without Peyton Manning. Backup Dan Orlovsky found Reggie Wayne for a last-minute touchdown, and the Colts escaped with a 19-16 home win. It was one of the few bright spots in a lost year.
The rivalry also produced its first tie in Week 1 of 2022 in Houston, a 20-20 overtime finish that became the first tie in Texans history. Rodrigo Blankenship missed a 42-yard field goal that would have won it for Indianapolis, and the Colts waived him days later.
A year later, the stakes were much higher. In Week 18 of 2023 at Lucas Oil Stadium, rookie C.J.
Stroud and the Texans won 23-19 in a game that was win-and-in for Houston. The result knocked Indianapolis out of playoff contention and sent the Texans to the postseason for the first time in four years.
Houston then carried that momentum into a five-game winning streak in the series, but the Colts snapped it in Week 3 of this season. Spencer Shrader’s late field goal gave Indianapolis a 19-17 win, its first of the season, after C.J.
Stroud’s final heave fell incomplete. That game also marked the debut of the Colts’ Rivalry jerseys.
There was also the night in 2018 when Frank Reich made the kind of call that tells you exactly how he wanted to coach. In overtime at Lucas Oil Stadium, he chose to go for it on fourth down on his own side of the field with seconds left instead of playing for a tie.
The pass fell incomplete, and Houston answered with a field goal to win 37-34. The decision became a defining snapshot of Reich’s aggressive style in his first season.
And then there was 2013, a Sunday night game in Houston that became unforgettable for a reason far bigger than the final score. Texans coach Gary Kubiak collapsed on the field while walking off at halftime.
After that, the Colts rallied behind T.Y. Hilton, who caught three touchdown passes in a 27-24 Indianapolis win.
Those are the kinds of games that have made Colts-Texans feel bigger than a typical divisional series. The records matter, but the moments are what linger.
In Other News...
Texans Win Now Comes With One Ugly NFL Discipline Question
The Texans left Thursday night with a win, but the conversation around the game quickly shifted to what happened after Kamari Lassiters interception. The Houston cornerback was caught on live television using a racial slur, and the clip spread fast across social media, turning a routine postgame highlight into a much bigger leaguewide issue.
For Colts fans watching a division rival, the football part of the result is only part of the story now. The NFL has fined players before for similar conduct, and discipline is already being discussed, but whether Lassiter faces a fine or something more serious remains unclear as the league weighs the incident. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Lineup Questions Just Got Bigger After Another Injury Shaken Loss
The Colts Week 11 trip to Houston only added to the lineup puzzle they have been trying to manage for much of the season. With multiple injured players inactive, the game forced Indianapolis to lean on backups in key spots and reshuffle the offensive line again, while the snap counts offered a clear look at how the coaching staff tried to patch things together on the fly.
On defense and special teams, the rotation also reflected the strain of playing shorthanded, with several players taking on expanded roles to keep the unit afloat. The linebacker pairing of CJ Allen and Bryce Boettcher has become a more regular part of the picture in recent weeks, and their emergence is one of the few stabilizing developments as the Colts keep sorting through injuries and trying to settle on a workable lineup. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Just Made Their Defining Daniel Jones Decision
Daniel Jones run in Indianapolis is over after the Colts latest loss to Houston, a game in which the quarterback never found a rhythm and finished with a rough afternoon through the air. Head coach Shane Steichen said the team is releasing Jones, ending a stint that began when he re-signed with the Colts in the 2026 offseason on a two-year contract.
It is a sharp turn for a move that was supposed to give Indianapolis stability at quarterback, but instead became a season-long struggle. The Colts now have to move on quickly after Jones inconsistency piled up, leaving the organization to sort out what comes next at the most important position on the field. [Read more 🡒]
