Colts Suddenly Have A New Name To Watch In WR Battle

Emerging from obscurity, undrafted wide receiver Eli Pancol is making a compelling case for a coveted spot on the Colts' starting lineup.

The Indianapolis Colts’ wide receiver battle has a new name in the conversation.

After Thursday’s practice, the Indy Star’s Joel Erickson reported that Ashton Dulin, Laquon Treadwell and Nick Westbrook-Ikhine have all been working at outside receiver, which lines up with the expectation that those three are the main contenders for the open starting job next to Alec Pierce and Josh Downs.

But Eli Pancol has also started to get a look.

With Pierce sidelined, Erickson said Pancol has “gotten chances,” giving the young receiver a path into a competition that already has a few established faces. Erickson also said it is “far too early” in training camp to figure out who will claim the No. 3 wide receiver role, though he pointed to Treadwell and Westbrook-Ikhine as players who made plays on Thursday.

Pancol’s route to this point has been a winding one. He went undrafted in 2025, initially signed with the Jacksonville Jaguars, was released during roster cutdowns in late August and later joined the Colts’ practice squad in November.

He also arrives with a solid college résumé. In the 2024 season at Duke, Pancol was a major part of the offense, working mostly on the boundary and catching 67% of his 89 targets for 800 yards, 13.3 yards per catch, and nine touchdowns.

It’s still an open question whether Pancol can turn those chances into real playing time, but his involvement with this group at least puts him in the mix for a roster spot.

In Other News...

Anthony Richardsons Colts Camp Day Left One Big Question

Training camp in Westfield has already taken on the tone the Colts want, with principal owner Carly Irsay-Gordon stressing the simple message of Find a way as the team opens its work in earnest. On the field, there was plenty to watch as veteran wideout Nick Westbrook-Ikhine and quarterback Anthony Richardson Sr. got chances to show their value, while the coaching staff kept things moving by rotating players through drills and giving the rookies a real look.

C.J. Allen and A.J. Haulcy were among the newcomers active in practice, the kind of early camp reps that can matter later when roster decisions start to tighten. For Richardson, the bigger question is not whether he can flash talent in camp, but how consistently he can carry that into the kind of daily work the Colts are pushing under this new standard. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Wide Receiver Battle Is Already Raising One Familiar Concern

Training camp has given the Colts exactly what they asked for at wide receiver, a real competition for the spots that will line up alongside Alec Pierce and Josh Downs. Chris Ballard and Shane Steichen have both stressed that the room is still in flux, with Ashton Dulin, Laquon Treadwell, Nick Westbrook-Ikhine and rookie Deion Burks all part of the mix as Indianapolis sorts through the depth chart and tries to identify who fits best.

It is also a reminder of how unsettled this group still is, even with camp underway. The Colts have left the door open to adding a free agent at the position, which keeps the focus on performance but also suggests the team is not ready to treat the current battle as finished business. For a receiving corps trying to find order, the next stretch of practices could matter just as much as the opener. [Read more 🡒]