The Indianapolis Colts have a real chance to solve a problem before it gets bigger, and Khalil Mack sits right at the center of it.
With the Los Angeles Chargers headed nowhere in 2026 and the Colts still trying to punch their way into the postseason, the fit makes too much sense to ignore. Los Angeles needs to think about the future.
Indianapolis needs help right now. That’s why a trade package for Mack could work for both sides.
Mack is 35 and playing on a one-year deal, so a long-term contract isn’t coming from anyone. But age has not dulled the production. Through four games, all of them losses for the Chargers, he has posted three sacks, five quarterback hits and five tackles for loss.
That kind of edge production would matter a lot in Indianapolis, especially with Arden Key set to miss 3-4 games because of a hamstring injury. The Colts’ edge rush group was already thin, and now it’s even more stretched.
Mack wouldn’t just patch that hole. He would lift the whole unit well beyond where it was before Key got hurt.
There are still obstacles. Mack has a no-trade clause, so any move would need his approval. He might not want to leave the Pacific coast for the Midwest, which complicates things from the start.
Money is another wrinkle, though not a major one for Indianapolis. According to Spotrac, a team trading for Mack before Week 5 would owe him $6.22 million for the rest of the season, and the Colts have that kind of room.
The Chargers would be left with $11.78 million in dead cap, but since Mack is off the books after this season unless Los Angeles re-signs him, that hit may not mean much to them. They could still bring him back even if they deal him now.
What the Chargers might want most is draft compensation. Mack is not fetching a first- or second-round pick, but a third-rounder could be enough to get something done if he agrees to the move.
For Indianapolis, the football case is easy to see. The defense has looked better over the last two weeks, though that came against the Houston Texans without Nico Collins and the Washington Commanders with a third-string quarterback for most of the game. Even so, adding Mack would change the ceiling of the unit.
Put Lou Anarumo in charge of that group and give him the closest thing he’s had with the Colts to Trey Hendrickson, the player who did some of his best work when Anarumo was the Cincinnati Bengals’ defensive coordinator, and Indianapolis starts to look dangerous. A third-round pick for Khalil Mack could be enough to make that happen.
In Other News...
Colts Sideline Debate Just Got Bigger At A Delicate Time
Carlie Irsay-Gordons habit of planting herself on the Colts sideline has become one of the more unusual talking points around the team, especially as she continues to work in plain view with a playbook in hand and notes at the ready. The principal owner and CEO has framed her approach as part of being an attentive leader, saying in an interview that listening and understanding matter, which fits the image she has presented during games.
But the conversation around her presence has widened, and not everyone views it as harmless curiosity. Bill Simmons questioned the sideline involvement on his podcast, adding another layer to a discussion that is already unfolding at a delicate point in the season, with Indianapolis sitting at 2-2 and trying to keep its focus on football rather than the attention orbiting above it. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Add A Familiar Pass Rusher With Anarumo Ties
The Colts added a familiar edge presence to the practice squad on Wednesday, bringing in veteran defensive end Carl Lawson as they continue sorting through their pass-rush depth. Lawson arrives with a clear connection to defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo from their time together in Cincinnati, which gives Indianapolis a built-in level of familiarity as the team looks to fortify the front seven.
Lawson has been around plenty of NFL locker rooms over his eight-year career, with stops in Baltimore, New York, and Dallas in addition to his years with the Bengals. He has 32 sacks to his name, and the question now is whether that experience and Anarumo familiarity can quickly translate into a larger opportunity in Indianapolis. [Read more 🡒]
Sauce Gardner Just Made Colts Fans Even More Uneasy About That Trade
The Colts got the win in Week 4, but Sauce Gardners latest public self-scouting did not exactly calm anyone down. After being acquired by Indianapolis last season, the cornerback acknowledged a rough outing against the Washington Commanders and admitted there were multiple plays in which his effort was not where it needed to be, a blunt admission that lands differently for a player brought in to stabilize a secondary.
Gardner still carries the reputation of a top corner with strong career numbers, and the Colts are counting on him to look like that again as the season moves forward. Daniel Jones is also expected to improve, which gives Indianapolis a little more reason to believe the early noise will fade, but Gardners comments only added another layer of unease around a trade that already had plenty of eyes on it. [Read more 🡒]