The Indianapolis Colts may have turned over a lot of the offensive conversation this offseason, but one issue still hangs over the group: wide receiver.
Indianapolis made its biggest move at the position by sending Michael Pittman Jr. to the Pittsburgh Steelers, a decision that cleared his $29 million salary and opened up more room for Alec Pierce to take on a larger share of the passing game. The Colts also brought in free-agent receiver Nick Westbrook-Ikhine and used a seventh-round pick on Deion Burks, but neither player is being asked to step in as a direct replacement for Pittman.
That’s the heart of the concern. Pierce, Josh Downs, and tight end Tyler Warren are all expected to absorb more of the targets, but the shape of the receiver room still looks unsettled.
As one assessment put it, “After shipping Michael Pittman Jr. to Pittsburgh, the Colts have a notable hole at wideout opposite Alec Pierce, whom they signed to an eyebrow-raising $114 million contract,” Okada wrote. “Josh Downs is an underrated asset in the slot, but at 5-foot-9 and 171 pounds, he’s pigeonholed into that role.
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine and seventh-round rookie Deion Burks are depth pieces, not starters of Pittman’s caliber.
“And while tight end Tyler Warren will pick up a lot of the target slack, Indy’s three-receiver sets are going to look very underwhelming. Depending on the finances, the Colts may want to consider free agent Stefon Diggs as a stopgap.”
Pierce, who missed the offseason program while recovering from ankle surgery, is now positioned to take over as the Colts’ top wideout after signing a four-year deal worth up to $116 million this offseason. That should expand his role beyond what he has done before, while Downs is expected to see more work on the outside than he has over his first three seasons.
There’s also a bigger opportunity waiting for Ashton Dulin. The team’s longest-tenured receiver, who joined in 2019, is in line for his largest role yet and is the leading candidate to become Indianapolis’ new third receiver.
But that spot is far from settled. Westbrook-Ikhine, Burks, and Laquon Treadwell are all in the mix to chip away at Dulin’s snaps, and head coach Shane Steichen made clear in June that the job is open.
“That's going to be an open competition," Colts head coach Shane Steichen said in June. "Obviously, Dulin's been here.
He's taking a lot of reps right now, but we got Treadwell, and we signed Westbrook-Ikhine, who's a good player that's played this league for a while. So, we'll see how camp goes, but I'm excited for that battle.”
Steichen said the key trait he’s looking for is simple.
“I think the biggest thing is consistency," Steichen said. "Who's going to be the most consistent there, day in and day out, play in and play out, to go help us win games.”
For now, that competition is one of the clearest unresolved questions on the Colts’ offense.
In Other News...
Colts Eye Former Starter As Another Key Camp Decision Looms
With camp decisions still taking shape, the Colts are weighing another veteran option in the secondary after Jordan Whitehead recently visited the team. The former starter is drawing interest elsewhere too, including a stop with the Texans, which underscores that Indianapolis is not the only club looking for a proven safety who can help stabilize the back end without forcing a long-term commitment.
For Chris Ballard, the appeal may be in a short-term deal that keeps the roster flexible while adding competition to a room still sorting out backup snaps. Whitehead would not arrive with a clear path to a starting job, but he could push for reserve safety reps and enter the mix with Hunter Wohler as the Colts continue to evaluate how the pieces fit under Lou Anarumo. [Read more 🡒]
Two Colts Backups Just Got Recognition That Could Matter Soon
A couple of Colts backups just picked up some outside recognition that says as much about roster construction as it does about individual talent. ESPNs Bill Barnwell put together a hypothetical 53-man All-Backup team, and Indianapolis landed two names on it in wide receiver Ashton Dulin and defensive tackle Adetomiwa Adebawore, a reminder that depth can swing a season as much as headline starters do.
Dulin drew notice for the value he brings on special teams and the fact that he can still flash as a receiver when called upon, while Adebawore got credit for his growing pass-rush presence and increased production in 2025. For the Colts, it is the kind of acknowledgment that matters because these are the players who can quietly keep a team afloat when injuries hit and the rotation gets tested. [Read more 🡒]