Carlie Irsay-Gordon isn’t backing away from the Colts’ sideline, and she’s not apologizing for the notebook, either.
The Indianapolis principal owner has become a frequent talking point this season as videos of her watching games with the playbook in hand and taking notes have spread online. Some fans and observers have admired the hands-on style. Others, including analyst and podcaster Bill Simmons, have made her a target of sharp criticism.
Speaking in London with Bridget Condon of Front Office Sports Tonight during the Colts’ NFL International Series game against the Washington Commanders, Irsay-Gordon explained the way she sees her role.
"I like to say on a good day I have like a fifth-grade reading level understanding of the game and just the basic concepts of what we’re trying to do, depending on the week and depending on our opponent and depending on the situation," she said of her approach.
She said the point is to ask better questions and stay engaged with what the team is trying to accomplish.
"But I think, then, it just helps to understand and to ask questions because I think one of the things, in my opinion, like being a good leader is about listening, really to understand. And I think that’s what the best teams do," Irsay-Gordon also said.
Simmons fired back the same day on his podcast, calling her sideline presence over the top.
"I think the owner on the sidelines taking notes is [expletive] nuts" and adding, "I can't believe people in her life haven't talked her out of it."
He went on to say the reaction would be very different if a male owner were doing the same thing.
Simmons also said everyone would find it funny if "some, you know, rich guy male owner" was "hovering over and giving advice to the coach" on the sidelines. He added, "Even Jerry Jones wouldn't do that."
Irsay-Gordon, 46, has served as the Colts’ principal owner and CEO since her father, Jim Irsay, died in May 2025. The team’s path since then has already had its share of highs and lows. Indianapolis opened last season 7-1 with Daniel Jones at quarterback, then faded badly, losing eight of its final nine games.
Jones later suffered a season-ending injury in December 2025, tearing his Achilles against the Jacksonville Jaguars. He is back this season as the Colts try to stay in the AFC South race, with the 3-1 Jaguars currently standing as their only real competition.
Indianapolis improved to 2-2 with its 30-17 win over Washington this past weekend. The Colts piled up only 257 yards, but Jonathan Taylor scored twice on the ground and Jones added another rushing touchdown. The Commanders also lost backup quarterback Marcus Mariota to an early injury, which may have helped the Colts’ cause.
Next up is a road trip to face Aaron Rodgers and the Pittsburgh Steelers on Sunday, Oct. 11. And based on Irsay-Gordon’s comments, her sideline routine is not changing anytime soon.
In Other News...
Colts Suddenly Have A Khalil Mack Decision Fans Can't Ignore
The Colts pass rush remains a talking point as the season approaches, and the latest name to surface is a familiar one: Khalil Mack. Indianapolis has been searching for more help off the edge after injuries thinned that group, and Macks track record would instantly change the tone of that conversation if the Colts decide to get aggressive. He is on a one-year contract, which makes him the kind of short-term fix teams often explore when a roster hole becomes too obvious to ignore.
Still, any potential move is not entirely in the Colts hands. Mack also carries a no-trade clause, so he would have to sign off on any deal, and the Chargers would likely want draft compensation in return if they are willing to listen at all. That leaves Indianapolis weighing a familiar NFL dilemma: whether to pay for immediate help now or hold its picks and trust the current rotation to survive the next stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Add A Familiar Pass Rusher With Anarumo Ties
The Colts added a familiar edge presence to the practice squad on Wednesday, bringing in veteran defensive end Carl Lawson as they continue sorting through their pass-rush depth. Lawson arrives with a clear connection to defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo from their time together in Cincinnati, which gives Indianapolis a built-in level of familiarity as the team looks to fortify the front seven.
Lawson has been around plenty of NFL locker rooms over his eight-year career, with stops in Baltimore, New York, and Dallas in addition to his years with the Bengals. He has 32 sacks to his name, and the question now is whether that experience and Anarumo familiarity can quickly translate into a larger opportunity in Indianapolis. [Read more 🡒]
Sauce Gardner Just Made Colts Fans Even More Uneasy About That Trade
The Colts got the win in Week 4, but Sauce Gardners latest public self-scouting did not exactly calm anyone down. After being acquired by Indianapolis last season, the cornerback acknowledged a rough outing against the Washington Commanders and admitted there were multiple plays in which his effort was not where it needed to be, a blunt admission that lands differently for a player brought in to stabilize a secondary.
Gardner still carries the reputation of a top corner with strong career numbers, and the Colts are counting on him to look like that again as the season moves forward. Daniel Jones is also expected to improve, which gives Indianapolis a little more reason to believe the early noise will fade, but Gardners comments only added another layer of unease around a trade that already had plenty of eyes on it. [Read more 🡒]