The Colts’ preseason ended the same way it started: without a win.
Indianapolis dropped a 25-16 decision to the Lions at home, finishing 0-2-1, but the bigger story was less about the record and more about how the backups held up after last weekend’s rough showing against the Falcons. This one brought a little more fight, and a few players helped themselves in the process.
At quarterback, the pecking order behind Daniel Jones looks pretty clear for now, barring a trade. Anthony Richardson Sr. remained in control of the backup battle and backed it up with a solid outing, going 7 of 10 for 80 passing yards.
He took the easy throws, flashed on a few others, and didn’t do anything to damage his standing. Riley Leonard had a tougher time, finishing 3 of 7 for 48 passing yards with an interception.
Easton Stick also got his first preseason action and went 8 of 15 for 78 passing yards in mop-up duty, a performance that should leave him on the outside looking in, though a practice squad role remains possible if the Colts want to keep a fourth quarterback around.
The backfield also offered a few clues. Rookie Seth McGowan worked with the first-team offense again and turned in another useful showing, rushing four times for 20 yards.
He seems to have edged ahead of DJ Giddens for the RB2 job behind Jonathan Taylor, especially with Giddens limited by a hamstring injury. Giddens did score on a 6-yard run late in the second quarter, but his pass protection remains a problem.
One missed block directly led to Leonard’s interception. Even so, Giddens has likely done enough as a runner to hold onto the RB3 spot for now.
Keenan Allen finally got his first catch as a Colt, and it was a good one: a 24-yard grab from Richardson Sr. early in the game. Deion Burks kept building his case too, continuing to stand out in preseason action.
The wide receiver room lower on the depth chart looks crowded, and there’s a real decision coming there. Coleman Owen added a 12-yard catch and his return ability gives him value, though he had to leave for the blue medical tent after taking a big hit.
The top of the group looks settled with Alec Pierce, Josh Downs, Keenan Allen, Ashton Dulin, and maybe Laquon Treadwell. After that, it gets murky.
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine could be squeezed out by Allen’s arrival, while Burks brings more upside as a receiver. Owen and Anthony Gould, though, have the kind of special teams versatility that can decide those last spots.
Up front, the Dalton Tucker-to-center experiment appears to have run its course. The backup center snaps were again a problem, especially in shotgun, where errant snaps kept showing up. That’s been a recurring issue through camp and preseason, and the Colts still need a reliable second-string center who can cleanly get the ball to the quarterback.
On the edge, George Gumbs Jr. flashed again as a rotational piece, while Jaylahn Tuimoloau was mostly ordinary at defensive end but made his biggest impact on special teams. Caden Curry also showed up with some pressure and later made a fumble recovery on a kick return after Bryce Boettcher punched the ball out. Curry looks like the kind of lower-roster edge defender who can stick because of his energy, effort, and special teams value.
At linebacker, rookie CJ Allen had a rough day. He’s listed as a first-team starter alongside Akeem Davis-Gaither, but he struggled to shed blocks and had little impact against the run.
It’s fair to wonder whether the Colts stick with him in that role. Boettcher, meanwhile, finished with 6 tackles.
The secondary remains a concern behind the top trio of Sauce Gardner, Charvarius Ward, and Justin Walley. Ron Carter Jr. was the latest backup corner to get targeted. Cam Taylor-Britt, who had a nice run stop, probably makes the team, but the Colts could be active on the waiver wire and reshape the depth chart at cornerback 5 and 6.
At safety, Hunter Wohler kept getting plenty of work and looks like a safe bet for the final 53. He’s the kind of versatile backup who can help on defense and special teams. Rookie AJ Haulcy should start at safety, but Wohler is going to be part of the rotation.
In Other News...
Colts Just Made Final Roster Decisions A Lot Tougher
The Colts wrapped up their preseason against the Lions backups, and even with the scoreboard taking a back seat, the finale still carried plenty of roster weight. Final cutdown day is always more about sorting through the margins than chasing a result, and this one gave Indianapolis a last look at players fighting for jobs, backup roles and a chance to stick around when the regular season arrives.
Several performances stood out as the kind that can nudge a bubble player one way or the other, while injuries and a few key position battles added another layer of difficulty for the coaching staff. A handful of snaps, good or bad, can loom large this time of year, and for the Colts the final preseason tune-up may have made some decisions clearer while leaving others even tougher to sort through. [Read more 🡒]
Anthony Richardson Just Reopened A Colts Debate Fans Thought Was Over
Anthony Richardsons path in Indianapolis has already taken another turn, and this time it comes with a little more clarity from the front office. The 2023 No. 4 overall pick has battled accuracy issues and the usual growing pains that come with limited NFL experience, then lost the starting job to Daniel Jones before asking for a trade this offseason. Still, Richardson gave the Colts something to consider by turning in a strong performance in the preseason finale, a reminder that his talent has never really been the question.
Ed Dodds then added more fuel to the conversation by saying the Colts intend to keep three quarterbacks, Richardson included, especially with Jones dealing with a recent injury. It is the kind of development that keeps Richardsons future from feeling settled, even if the team has already moved on in one sense. For a player who seemed to be drifting toward the background, the door has opened just enough to make the rest of the roster math worth watching. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Final Preseason Game Could Decide One Crucial Roster Battle
The Colts head into their final preseason game against the Lions with several roster decisions still hanging in the balance, and the stakes are especially clear at the bottom of the depth chart. Indianapolis has used August to sort through competition at backup quarterback, where Anthony Richardson Sr. and Riley Leonard have been part of the conversation, while the third running back job and the wide receiver room also remain unsettled as the cutdown deadline nears.
One of the most intriguing battles has come at kicker, where Chase Grupe and Matt Shrader have been trading off opportunities in a contest that has stayed tight through the preseason. Shrader has flashed well enough to make the choice harder, and with the final exhibition now here, the Colts still have multiple spots where one more strong showing could shape the roster that opens the season. [Read more 🡒]