The NFLPA's annual report cards, though no longer publicly available, provide an insightful glimpse into how players view their organizations. Thanks to ESPN's Kayln Kahler, we have a peek at the 2025 season's evaluations, and the Indianapolis Colts find themselves comfortably in the middle of the pack.
These report cards are a comprehensive assessment, capturing player feedback on everything from ownership to training facilities. This year, 1,759 players shared their thoughts, giving us a well-rounded picture of each team's standing.
So, how did the Colts fare this time around?
The Colts secured the 17th spot overall. Let's dive into the specifics of their grades:
Indianapolis Colts' 2026 NFLPA Report Card Grades
Despite a five-year playoff drought, head coach Shane Steichen and general manager Chris Ballard received commendable scores, reflecting confidence in their leadership.
In their debut year as primary owners, Carlie Irsay Gordon, Kalen Jackson, and Casey Foyt impressed with an A grade, signaling a strong start at the helm.
However, it wasn't all smooth sailing. The field at Lucas Oil Stadium struggled with a disappointing D, and the locker room didn't fare much better with a C+. These were the lowest marks on their report card.
On a brighter note, the Colts climbed two spots from last year's 19th place finish. Notable improvements were seen in their Food/Dining grade, which rose from a C to a B, and their Team Travel score, which improved from a D+ to a B-.
Overall, the Colts are making strides in some areas, but there's still room for growth, especially when it comes to facilities. With continued focus, they could climb even higher next year.