Colts Quarterback Mess Just Sparked A Bigger Debate About The Franchise

After the controversial release of quarterback Daniel Jones, former NFL players are divided on Colts owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon's ability to lead the franchise.

Breiden Fehoko didn’t hold back after the Colts moved on from Daniel Jones, and his post on X went straight at Indianapolis owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon.

The former Chargers and Steelers defensive tackle blasted the Colts’ leadership in a message that tied together the team’s quarterback decision, the trade deadline, and the broader direction of the franchise.

“Carlie Irsay-Gordon has no clue how to run a football organization, and too many simps defended it. Jonathan Taylor is splitting snaps post trade deadline.

No first-round pick because she wanted Sauce. Released Daniel Jones months after the biggest 2-year extension in history, when he could’ve been traded two weeks ago.

What a joke.”

Some of the specifics in Fehoko’s criticism are backed by the record. Indianapolis dealt its 2026 and 2027 first-round picks, along with wide receiver Adonai Mitchell, to the Jets for Sauce Gardner at the 2025 trade deadline. Jones, meanwhile, had signed a two-year, $88 million extension in March.

The Colts cut Jones after Thursday night’s 26-3 loss at Houston, a game in which he went 12 of 27 for 144 yards and an interception before being replaced by Anthony Richardson. Across 11 starts, Jones finished with 1,974 passing yards, seven touchdowns and a career-high 13 interceptions. His 65.4 passer rating was last among qualified quarterbacks, and Indianapolis sits at 3-8.

Fehoko’s point about timing also lines up with reporting from ESPN. Adam Schefter said the Colts had interest from the Vikings and Ravens on Jones before the deadline but kept him anyway.

Minnesota later traded for Kirk Cousins, while Baltimore landed Jacoby Brissett. Once Indianapolis released Jones, the team got no draft compensation and took on a $35.2 million dead cap hit for 2027.

Shane Steichen said Jones did not ask out, framing the move as a football decision.

“a decision that was made for, you know, the best interests of both parties,”

“It’s just where we’re at in our season.”

Not everyone piled on Irsay-Gordon. Stephon Gilmore pushed back on the criticism the same day, saying her football acumen gets overlooked.

“Y’all have to chill on Carlie Irsay. I’ve seen her in meetings she knows more ball than a lot of so called football people.

She’s very passionate about the game and the Colts. I’ve seen her in meetings.

She will get the @Colts right in due time. Watch.”

Gilmore, who won a Super Bowl and was named 2019 Defensive Player of the Year, played one season in Indianapolis in 2022, finishing with 66 tackles, 11 pass breakups and two interceptions before retiring in April 2026 after 13 seasons.

Irsay-Gordon took over as principal owner and CEO in June 2025 after the death of her father, Jim Irsay, at 65. Since then, the Colts have undergone a major reset.

General manager Chris Ballard was fired Oct. 19, and the deadline purge sent Quenton Nelson, DeForest Buckner, Josh Downs and Keenan Allen out of town. Anthony Richardson is set to start at quarterback Nov. 29 against the New York Giants.

In Other News...

Texans Win Now Comes With One Ugly NFL Discipline Question

The Texans left Thursday night with a win, but the conversation around the game quickly shifted to what happened after Kamari Lassiters interception. The Houston cornerback was caught on live television using a racial slur, and the clip spread fast across social media, turning a routine postgame highlight into a much bigger leaguewide issue.

For Colts fans watching a division rival, the football part of the result is only part of the story now. The NFL has fined players before for similar conduct, and discipline is already being discussed, but whether Lassiter faces a fine or something more serious remains unclear as the league weighs the incident. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Lineup Questions Just Got Bigger After Another Injury Shaken Loss

The Colts Week 11 trip to Houston only added to the lineup puzzle they have been trying to manage for much of the season. With multiple injured players inactive, the game forced Indianapolis to lean on backups in key spots and reshuffle the offensive line again, while the snap counts offered a clear look at how the coaching staff tried to patch things together on the fly.

On defense and special teams, the rotation also reflected the strain of playing shorthanded, with several players taking on expanded roles to keep the unit afloat. The linebacker pairing of CJ Allen and Bryce Boettcher has become a more regular part of the picture in recent weeks, and their emergence is one of the few stabilizing developments as the Colts keep sorting through injuries and trying to settle on a workable lineup. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Just Made Their Defining Daniel Jones Decision

Daniel Jones run in Indianapolis is over after the Colts latest loss to Houston, a game in which the quarterback never found a rhythm and finished with a rough afternoon through the air. Head coach Shane Steichen said the team is releasing Jones, ending a stint that began when he re-signed with the Colts in the 2026 offseason on a two-year contract.

It is a sharp turn for a move that was supposed to give Indianapolis stability at quarterback, but instead became a season-long struggle. The Colts now have to move on quickly after Jones inconsistency piled up, leaving the organization to sort out what comes next at the most important position on the field. [Read more 🡒]