The Colts got enough early movement to keep drives alive in Week 5, but not enough finishing power to cash in. The ball moved.
The scoring didn’t. Indianapolis kept settling for field goals, and the passing game was a big reason why.
Daniel Jones had a mixed afternoon that ended up looking better than Week 4, but still not nearly good enough. He protected the football, took only one sack, and posted a respectable success rate. Even so, the downfield passing attack never really came to life, and the offense spent too much time stuck short of the goal line.
Jones finished with one of the deepest average target depths in the league, as the Colts leaned into a far more aggressive approach than they did a week earlier. His average depth of target jumped from 3.8 yards to 11.5 yards, one of his highest marks over the past 17 weeks.
But the payoff wasn’t there. His average depth of completion rose only from 3.7 to 6.1 yards, a clear sign that Indianapolis took shots without connecting often enough.
Accuracy was the real problem. Jones completed just 57.1% of his adjusted passes after removing throwaways and drops, which was about the worst mark among Week 5 quarterbacks.
His adjusted completion rate fell to its lowest point in the last 17 weeks, and he was especially shaky on throws over 20 yards. His best work came on throws within five yards of the line, but even with target difficulty factored in, he still landed below expectations.
That hurt the efficiency numbers across the board. Jones moved the chains on fewer than 30% of his dropbacks and didn’t throw a touchdown.
He also rarely scrambled or threw the ball away, and with just one sack, he limited the damage on the plays that didn’t work. The result: just above zero in EPA per play, which was slightly below league average.
There were a few encouraging signs. Jones was more consistent than he had been in Week 4, and all four of the core measures - EPA per play, success rate, first-down rate and net yards per play - improved.
But they’re still sitting at or below average, and the broader trend still points the wrong way. The overall line was better, not fixed.
The game also split cleanly by half. Jones looked productive early, stacking together some positive plays and helping the Colts move the ball despite the occasional miss.
Then the second half turned muddy fast. Incompletions piled up, especially on deeper throws, and the offense stalled out.
By the fourth quarter, the Colts’ passing game had lost its rhythm and never got it back.
The workload around him told the same story. Indianapolis got slightly above-average production from the run game while leaning hard on the pass on early downs.
The protection was decent enough, too, since Jones faced less than average pressure even with a roughly average time to throw. The line did its part well enough to keep him upright.
The passing game just didn’t finish the job.
As for where the yards came from, Tyler Warren led the way with 83 yards on seven catches, doing most of his damage through the air. Josh Downs and Keenan Allen also chipped in, with Downs piling up almost all of his yardage before the catch. Laquon Treadwell was targeted eight times and caught only two passes.
On the season, Downs still leads the Colts in receiving yards, with Warren close behind, but they’re getting there differently. Downs has made his hay through the air, while Warren has leaned much more heavily on yards after the catch. Allen and Treadwell round out the next tier of contributors, and Treadwell’s production has come mainly on deeper completions.
Jones’ target distribution changed again in Week 5, with the Colts pushing the ball farther downfield. Downs and Treadwell both finished below average in EPA per target despite being targeted well beyond the league’s average depth.
Warren was the exception. His intermediate work produced positive value, which is the kind of result the Colts have been waiting to see from him all season.
There was one more positive note: Jones avoided turnovers entirely. After last week’s mess, that mattered. But without more completions, more yards, or more explosive plays, the clean sheet wasn’t enough to tilt the day in Indianapolis’ favor.
His season-long profile is still uneasy. Jones ranks near the bottom of the league in yards per attempt at 6.0, and while his time to throw has been faster than expected for the depth of his targets, the passing game as a whole still hasn’t found a stable gear.
In Week 5, the aggressive approach showed up. The efficiency did not.
In Other News...
Colts Face A Week 6 Reality They Cannot Ignore Against Titans
The Colts head into Week 6 with a clear set of concerns against Tennessee, and the numbers behind the matchup paint a fairly simple picture of what needs to go right. Over the past two seasons, recent history suggests Indianapolis usually puts itself in position when it can keep the Titans from getting loose offensively, while also doing enough through the air to avoid a grind-it-out slog that favors the other sideline.
Indianapolis will also need to be sharp with the football in a division game that rarely gives away extra chances. The Colts have seen enough of these matchups to know that a clean afternoon on offense and a modest passing output can be the difference between control and catching up, which is why this one feels less like a toss-up than a test of whether they can meet the basic standards that have shown up again and again in the recent data. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Found Two Bright Spots In A Loss Fans Hated
After a Week 5 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers that left plenty of Colts fans frustrated, Pro Football Focus still found a pair of bright spots worth noting. Left guard Quenton Nelson and return specialist Anthony Gould landed on PFFs NFL Team of the Week, a small silver lining on a day when the final result overshadowed much of the good.
Nelson graded out at 86.9, which was the best mark among left guards, a reminder that Indianapolis still had some high-level play in the trenches even in defeat. Gould gave the Colts a lift in the kicking game with two returns that averaged 40.5 yards, highlighted by a career-long 54-yard burst that offered one of the more explosive moments in an otherwise rough afternoon. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Turn To A Familiar Fix As Pressure Builds On Defense
The Colts keep searching for stability at WILL linebacker, and they turned to a familiar face this week by signing veteran Germaine Pratt to the practice squad. Pratt arrives with a built-in connection to defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo from their time together in Cincinnati, which gives Indianapolis at least some comfort as it tries to patch a spot that has been under pressure.
Indianapolis also promoted tight end Pharaoh Brown from the practice squad, adding another move to a roster that has needed practical fixes rather than splashy ones. The defenses personnel shuffle comes with the bigger concern still hovering in the background: Jonathan Taylor has gone more than 570 plays without a run of 25 yards or more, a stretch that underscores how much the Colts are waiting for a burst that has not been there lately. [Read more 🡒]