The Colts have spent the first half of 2026 looking like a team stuck in the middle of a hard reset. At 2-7, the season has gone off the rails for Indianapolis, and the roster has plenty of spots where expectations have simply not been met.
That said, the whole picture isn’t bleak. A few groups have held up, and a couple have even given the Colts real reasons to feel better about what comes next. Here’s how every Indianapolis positional group stacks up at the halfway point.
- Quarterback
Daniel Jones has had a rough season, plain and simple. He is the first quarterback since 1950 to go nine games without ever averaging at least seven yards per attempt or posting a game with more than one touchdown pass. The absence of his best receiver has been part of the story, but it doesn’t explain away how little production he has given this offense.
- Wide receiver
Alec Pierce has been missed for most of the year, but one absence shouldn’t drag an entire passing game this far down. Josh Downs, who is now traded, has had issues with drops lately, and no other receiver has managed to show up consistently from week to week.
Right now, this group sits at the bottom of the league, and Peyton Manning likely couldn’t even make much happen with what Indianapolis has here.
- Cornerback
This is another unit where the disappointment has been tied to expectations. Sauce Gardner has not delivered, and Charvarius Ward has also slipped recently. The numbers don’t make the group look disastrous, but ninth feels right because so much more was supposed to come from it.
Gardner’s quarterback rating allowed is 102.4, which is easily the worst of his career. Ward also had a rough Week 9, giving up 66 receiving yards on two catches and a touchdown.
- Inside linebacker
This position has been a mess for much of the season, mostly because the Colts couldn’t settle on a starter or a rotation until recently. The good news is that second-round pick CJ Allen has started to play much better and now wears the green dot on defense. He looks like a long-term starter at the spot.
- Tight end
Tyler Warren’s numbers suggest there may be some scheme issues here, because Indianapolis could have done more with him downfield when the receivers weren’t getting open. He has 38 catches, but he’s averaging only 7.2 yards per catch, and he hasn’t scored since Week 2. The rest of the tight end room has barely registered.
- Offensive line
The big name change here was Quenton Nelson getting traded to the Seattle Seahawks, but the bigger problem has been right tackle Jalen Travis. He’s hurt now, but after stepping in for longtime starter Braden Smith, Travis has allowed 30 pressures and seven sacks.
- Edge rusher
This group opened the season in rough shape. Laiatu Latu and Jaylahn Tuimoloau weren’t generating much pressure, and the defense was paying for it.
Lately, though, both have improved, and rookie Caden Curry has helped as well. Latu has been involved in sacks in back-to-back games and posted five pressures in Week 9.
- Safety
AJ Haulcy has had the usual ups and downs you’d expect from a rookie, but Cam Bynum has been steady and productive, especially against the run. He’s been one of the few real standouts on this defense.
- Defensive line
This unit could be even higher if not for the fact that DeForest Buckner has now been traded, which takes some shine off the group. Still, Adetomiwa Adebawore has been excellent and recently earned an extension because of how much his play has improved. Grover Stewart continues to be one of the league’s better run defenders.
- Running back
As long as Jonathan Taylor is healthy and still in a Colts uniform, this group is going to rank near the top. He isn’t leading the league in rushing yards or touchdowns, and he hasn’t topped 100 rushing yards in a game since Week 11 of last season, but that feels more tied to the offense around him than to Taylor himself.
Rookie Seth McGowan has also been a strong No. 2 option. His future could even include becoming Indianapolis’ RB1 if Taylor ever moves on.
- Specialists
Rigoberto Sanchez has long been one of the NFL’s best punters, and Spencer Shrader has been the biggest pleasant surprise on the roster. He has hit 22 of 24 field goals, including eight of nine from beyond 50 yards. The return game has been just okay, but Sanchez and Shrader have carried this group.
In Other News...
Colts Win Couldnt Hide The Bigger Problems Waiting After Miami
The Colts got the result they needed in Week 10 against Miami, but it did little to quiet the larger questions hovering over the roster. Indianapolis remains 3-7, and the win only briefly masked the uneven play that has followed the team through much of the season, especially on offense where Daniel Jones has been under growing scrutiny.
Shane Steichen is also facing pressure as the next game approaches, with injuries piling up and discipline still an issue for a team trying to stabilize itself. A narrow victory can buy a little time, but it does not erase the concerns about the quarterback situation, the offensive direction or whether the Colts have enough healthy pieces to make the most of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Rebuild Just Created A Jonathan Taylor Decision Fans Will Question
The Colts rebuild has already taken a sharp turn, with the front office moving on from general manager Chris Ballard and dealing away major pieces like DeForest Buckner, Quenton Nelson and Josh Downs. In the middle of that reset, one decision stood out: Indianapolis kept Jonathan Taylor, even as the roster around him thinned out and the long-term direction of the team became harder to read.
Reportedly, the Colts turned down trade interest that included a second-round pick from the Giants, a choice that will invite plenty of debate as the season unfolds. Taylor remains one of the few proven stars left on a team now trying to piece together its future, but with the quarterback situation still unsettled and the supporting cast stripped down, retaining him raises as many questions as it answers. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Face A Brutal Week 10 Test After A Roster Shakeup
The Colts head into Week 10 with a very different look after a recent roster shakeup, and the timing hardly could be tougher. Indianapolis is trying to keep moving forward while also leaning into the future, all while getting ready for a Miami team that is dealing with its own injury issues and will turn to Kyle McCord at quarterback.
Even with the Dolphins scrambling under center, this still shapes up as a tricky matchup for Indianapolis. The early read is a tight, low-scoring game with the Colts narrowly favored, but for a team in transition, the bigger question is how quickly the new pieces and new priorities can settle in against a battered opponent that still has enough talent to make things messy. [Read more 🡒]
