The Indianapolis Colts may have just watched one of the cleaner escape routes for Anthony Richardson disappear.
Minnesota’s decision to send J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants on Monday changes the market in a real way for a quarterback like Richardson, who remains the Colts’ backup behind Daniel Jones. At the very least, the move gives general manager Chris Ballard a clearer idea of what sort of return he could realistically expect if he decides to deal Richardson.
Per NFL insider Tom Pelissero, the Giants are sending Minnesota a fifth-round pick in 2027 for McCarthy, the No. 10 overall selection in 2024. For the Vikings, that’s a rough outcome. For Indianapolis, it’s a useful data point: if a player with McCarthy’s draft pedigree is only bringing back a fifth-rounder, Ballard probably shouldn’t be expecting much more for Richardson.
That matters because Richardson is viewed as expendable in Indianapolis. Daniel Jones is ahead of him on the depth chart, and Riley Leonard could handle the QB2 role. If Ballard wants to move Richardson, the market may not be nearly as strong as it once looked.
The Giants had been one of the more obvious landing spots. They lost their starting quarterback, Jaxson Dart, to an injury earlier in the season and were left with veteran Jameis Winston at the position. McCarthy may or may not be an upgrade over Winston - that part is still unsettled - but the Giants were clearly in the quarterback conversation.
There’s also the fit factor. Richardson and McCarthy bring similar traits to the table: big-arm talent, inconsistent accuracy, and the ability to create with their legs.
That kind of overlap makes sense for some teams and not for others, which only narrows the list of possible suitors for Richardson. With New York now off the board, the Colts could be left holding onto him.
And maybe that’s the most likely outcome anyway. Richardson is a free agent next offseason, and he’ll probably want a situation where he has a legitimate shot to become QB1. That path doesn’t exist in Indianapolis.
The best-case scenario for the Colts may be that Daniel Jones stays on the field. Jones has had three seasons end early because of injury, so there’s always a chance Richardson gets thrown into action. If that happens, it could give him a chance to audition for any team that might consider signing him in 2027 or trading for him.
But with one of the few teams that might have made sense for Richardson now gone, the Colts’ options look thinner. Ironically, the cleanest outcome for Ballard might be to keep Richardson around and hope he never has to play another meaningful snap for Indianapolis.
In Other News...
Spencer Shrader Fought Through More Than Colts Fans Realized
Spencer Shrader gave Colts fans a performance worth remembering, drilling four field goals from 39, 58, 37, and 53 yards in a single game while carrying an injury he picked up during warmups. It was the kind of quiet, steady day that can change the shape of a game, and it also offered a reminder that kickers often spend just as much time managing pain and pressure as they do putting points on the board.
Shrader spoke about the mental side of kicking and the path that brought him here, including growing up near the Colts and working his way to the NFL. For Indianapolis, that background adds another layer to what looked like a clean outing on the scoreboard, because it turns out the success came with more behind-the-scenes grit than many in the stadium realized. [Read more 🡒]
Colts May Have Found A Defensive Answer At The Perfect Time
Adetomiwa Adebawore gave the Colts a timely jolt in Week 3, flashing the kind of interior pass-rush burst that can change a game in a hurry. In just 15 snaps against the Texans, he piled up four pressures and 1.5 sacks, a strong reminder that his growth as a disruptive force up front is no longer just a projection. For a defense looking for answers early in the season, that kind of production stands out.
The Colts are 1-2, and the schedule ahead figures to keep testing them in different ways, from offenses built on the pass to groups that lean on a more varied attack. Adebawores development, and the likelihood that his role keeps growing, gives Indianapolis a useful piece at exactly the right moment. If he keeps affecting quarterbacks the way he did last week, the Colts may have found a defensive spark they can lean on. [Read more 🡒]
Josh Downs Is Becoming The Colts Passing Game Safety Valve
Josh Downs has quietly moved from promising slot target to one of the most dependable parts of the Colts' passing game, and the timing could hardly be better. With other receivers banged up, Indianapolis has leaned harder on him over the last two weeks, and he has responded with steady volume, reliable hands and a growing role in the offense's weekly game plan.
The encouraging part for the Colts is not just that Downs is getting the ball, but that he is doing more with it in the situations where offenses often stall. He has been better on third downs and has held up against the blitz, giving the passing game a safety valve when the protection gets stressed and the options narrow. For a team still sorting through injuries and adjustments, that kind of trust can matter as much as any big-play threat. [Read more 🡒]