Indianapolis, IN - When the Indianapolis Colts picked wide receiver Alec Pierce with the 53rd overall selection in the 2022 NFL Draft, many saw him as a project. Fortunately, the Colts had the patience to nurture his development.
Fast forward to 2026, and Pierce has emerged as the most sought-after wide receiver in this year's free agency. The Colts, keenly aware of his value, are determined to keep him on their roster.
With a strategic social media campaign already in motion, the Colts are prepared to use the franchise tag if necessary to secure Pierce’s future with the team.
Why Keep Pierce?
Alec Pierce stands out as the premier wide receiver in this free agency class. Leading the league in yards per reception for two consecutive seasons and coming off his first 1,000-yard season, Pierce is the downfield threat every team dreams of.
In 2025, he achieved career-highs across the board, making him a coveted target for fans across the league. With 47 catches on 84 targets, totaling 1,003 yards and 6 touchdowns, his 21.3 yards per reception speaks volumes about his big-play capability.
Pierce’s presence elevates any offense, particularly in the deep passing game. With Michael Pittman Jr.'s future in Indianapolis uncertain, Pierce is poised to step up as the Colts’ WR1. His growth into a top target makes retaining him an obvious choice.
Potential Concerns
There’s little downside to Pierce as a free agent prospect. The Colts know him well, both on and off the field, and the only worry might be a potential regression.
Pierce has improved his short-area quickness and contested catch ability, shedding the label of being just a deep threat. However, his career-best 47 receptions in 2025 suggest that handling a larger workload could challenge his current trajectory.
While he may need another season as the top target to fully prove himself as a WR1, even maintaining his recent performance would justify a new contract.
The Final Word
Alec Pierce’s prowess as a deep threat is just the beginning. His work ethic and development have made him invaluable to the Colts. With several key players entering free agency, re-signing Pierce should be the top priority.
The Colts drafted Pierce with a vision, and that vision has come to fruition. Now, they hope he will continue to grow with the organization.
Whether through a long-term deal or a franchise tag leading to one, securing Pierce is essential. Sometimes, you have to pay a premium for talent, and the Colts should be ready to do just that for Alec Pierce.