The Colts’ kicker competition got a jolt in preseason Week 1, and it came from the guy who had been the less convincing long-range option.
Spencer Shrader drilled a 61-yard field goal against the New England Patriots, while Blake Grupe missed from the same distance. That was enough for FanSided’s Adam Fromal to name Shrader’s boot the “Kick of the Week.”
Fromal wrote, "Shrader isn't typically viewed as a power kicker. Before tearing his ACL and MCL last year, he went 13-of-14 with an average make of 35.1 yards and a long of just 52.
In 2024, his five makes for the Kansas City Chiefs and New York Jets averaged 33.4 yards, and none came from beyond 45. Even his collegiate long was a 54-yarder for Notre Dame during the 2023 season.
This is newfound territory for Shrader..."
That kind of strike also drew a reaction from Patriots coach Mike Vrabel, who noted what Indianapolis had on hand after the game.
Vrabel said after the preseason clash, "(Indianapolis is) banging them in from 60 yards. They got two kickers on the roster, so Andy (Borregales) knows that we have to make those field goals.
Still, one preseason kick does not settle a battle that appears to be heading toward a simple roster math problem. The Colts can keep only one kicker, and the other would be available to sign elsewhere. A practice squad return is possible, but the source says that is not likely.
And even with Shrader’s big moment, the case for Grupe remains the stronger one. He has had the better training camp, and he has been the more reliable kicker in the larger sample. He has shown more consistency from long range and has more NFL production to lean on.
Grupe’s career numbers from 50 yards and beyond back that up. He has made 19 of 27 from that range, and after joining the Colts late last season, he was perfect on all four attempts from 50-plus.
Shrader may have won the headline play of the week, but the source makes clear that Grupe should be the one on the roster when the season opens. If Shrader does end up elsewhere, the New England Patriots are floated as a possible landing spot, since they could use help at the position.
In Other News...
Colts Ownership Is Already Facing A Sideline Debate Fans Will Notice
Carlie Irsay-Gordon has already become one of the more visible figures around the Colts, taking over as principal owner and CEO in May 2025 after the passing of her father, Jim Irsay. With Indianapolis coming off an 8-9 finish in 2025 and working through the rest of its 2026 preseason schedule, her presence on the sideline has naturally drawn more attention than it might for a first-year owner in a steadier situation.
Jason Whitlock recently seized on that visibility, criticizing Irsay-Gordon for being on the field level during preseason action and questioning how involved she should be compared with other NFL owners. It is the kind of sideline debate that can linger when a franchise is already under a microscope, especially for a team trying to reset its footing and move beyond a middling season. [Read more 🡒]
Former Colts Pick Is Back On Fans' Radar For A Reason
Eric Johnson II is getting another NFL shot, and it has put the former Colts draft pick back into familiar conversation for Indianapolis fans who remember his arrival in 2022. The defensive tackle has already made the rounds in the league, spending time with the Colts, Patriots and Vikings, and now he is headed to Atlanta after the Falcons signed him for a summer competition on the defensive line.
For Colts followers, the name carries a little more weight because Johnson was part of that fifth-round class and once fit into the teams long-term development plans. He will also have a familiar face on the other side of the building, reuniting with former defensive line coach Nate Ollie as he tries to carve out a roster spot with the Falcons. [Read more 🡒]
Kenny Moores Colts Exit Is Looking Riskier By The Day
Kenny Moore IIs split with the Colts has settled into an uneasy holding pattern, and it has only sharpened the sense that Indianapolis has already moved on. Moore asked for a trade and then a release after his playing time dwindled in Lou Anarumos system, a sign that the veteran corner no longer saw a clear fit in a defense that has leaned younger at his position.
Justin Walley has been one of the names benefiting from that shift, drawing attention in training camp and looking like the player the Colts are lining up to replace Moore. For Moore, the next step has been less certain, as he remains unsigned and is working out locally to stay ready while he waits for the right opportunity to open up. [Read more 🡒]