Colts Keep Making The Same Daniel Jones Mistake

Despite mounting pressure and consistently poor performances, the Colts' decision to stick with quarterback Daniel Jones remains controversial.

The Colts keep rolling Daniel Jones out there, and the result is getting harder to justify by the week.

At this point, the question isn’t whether he’s struggling. It’s why he’s still taking snaps for Indianapolis at all. Whatever the reason is - the $50 million Chris Ballard gave him this year, something Shane Steichen sees that nobody else does, or just plain stubbornness - the bottom line is the same: Jones has been brutal, and he shouldn’t be on the field again this season.

His start with the Colts has turned into a strange, ugly ride, and Sunday only made it worse. Jones posted a 1.7 QBR, the worst of any starting quarterback this year. That number is so low it somehow topped even the kind of disasters that usually define the bottom of the barrel, including Baker Mayfield completing zero passes and Carson Wentz’s dreadful Monday night showing against the Bills.

And this wasn’t some impossible assignment against a juggernaut defense. It came against the 1-7 Dolphins, a team that was running out a quarterback making his first start.

Jones finished with 108 yards and threw two interceptions. One of those picks went back for a touchdown, and while not every interception lands fully on the quarterback, that one could have been thrown better.

So could just about everything else he’s done this year.

The Colts may not have a glamorous answer waiting behind him, but sticking with Jones now looks like a dead end. Steichen’s decision to keep riding with him has reached the point of absurdity. Nothing in Jones’ play says he’s the guy.

Calling for a change at quarterback isn’t just fan frustration. It’s a real concern based on what’s happening on the field.

Jones was flat-out awful against one of the league’s weakest teams, and if he can’t handle a home game against the Dolphins, then the Colts need to move on. The talent around him has been thinned out by trades, but that doesn’t excuse this level of play.

If Jones can’t be better, then he needs to be done. The Colts have to make the change.

In Other News...

Justin Walley Just Gave The Colts A New Defensive Question

Justin Walleys Week 10 performance against Miami gave the Colts a jolt on defense and a reminder that a young secondary can swing a game in a hurry. The cornerback forced a strip-sack on Dolphins quarterback Kyle McCord, and Adetomiwa Adebawore turned the takeaway into a fumble recovery touchdown, the kind of sequence that can change the tone of a game and a locker room.

Walleys day was good enough to earn AFC Defensive Player of the Week honors, the first league-wide recognition of his NFL career. Along with the strip-sack, he finished with five tackles, two tackles for loss and two passes defensed, leaving Indianapolis with a useful question moving forward: how much more can this defense lean on him after a breakout showing like that? [Read more 🡒]

Colts Keep Waiting On Anthony Richardson As Pressure Builds

The Colts have kept Daniel Jones in the starting job through a 3-7 start, and the message from Shane Steichen has been consistent: he is sticking with the veteran while weighing what the team has behind him. Steichen said he looks at quarterback play through film and a broader set of factors, and he confirmed Jones will start again this week, a sign that Indianapolis is not ready to make a change even as the losses keep piling up.

For Anthony Richardson, the wait continues. The 2023 first-round pick has dealt with injuries and limited snaps, leaving him in the same holding pattern that has defined much of his time in Indianapolis, while Riley Leonard also remains part of the discussion in the room. Steichen has shown little public confidence in either backup option, but Richardson is still preparing as if his chance could come at any point, and the pressure around the position only grows louder with each game the Colts stay put. [Read more 🡒]

CJ Allen Is Finally Giving Colts Fans What They Waited For

CJ Allens rookie season has started to look a lot more like the Colts probably envisioned when they spent a second-round pick on him. After a slow opening stretch, the linebacker has settled in over the past few games, and his role has grown along with his confidence. In the win over the Miami Dolphins, he was on the field for every defensive snap and showed up all over the stat sheet with nine tackles, a sack and a pass breakup.

The bigger takeaway for Indianapolis is how much better Allen has looked with more responsibility in the MIKE linebacker spot. Missing training camp clearly slowed his early progress, but the recent uptick suggests the game is starting to slow down for him. For a defense that needs young players to keep ascending, Allens latest stretch has given Colts fans a reason to believe the early frustration may have been worth the wait. [Read more 🡒]