The Indianapolis Colts’ season has already turned into a teardown, and the trade deadline made that plain. Four players on expiring contracts were shipped out, a move that fit the direction of a 2-7 start. Still, even in a year this rough, a few players have given the team something to hang onto.
That’s the sliver of good news in a season that has otherwise gone sideways. A handful of Colts have done enough to suggest there’s something worth building around, even if the bigger reset may eventually require a new head coach.
Jonathan Taylor is the easy call for the best offensive player. That’s been true in one form or another just about every year, and this season is no different.
He remains one of the best running backs in the NFL and arguably the best in Colts history. Even with fewer carries than he has had at this point in past seasons, Taylor still ranks eighth in the league in rushing yards with 656 and sixth in rushing touchdowns with six.
On the other side of the ball, Adetomiwa Adebawore has emerged as the top defensive performer so far. If DeForest Buckner had not been traded to the San Francisco 49ers, he would have had a strong case for this spot.
But Adebawore has made real progress after already showing signs of growth in 2025, and he has pushed beyond that in 2026. He has 20 pressures, four sacks - matching his career high from 2025 - and 11 quarterback hits, which is nearly double his previous best.
He has also been better against the run, and after signing a recent extension, he’s not going anywhere.
The most surprising success story has been Laquon Treadwell. His production may owe as much to opportunity as anything else, but he has been better than he was last season.
The 2016 first-round pick never lived up to the billing with the Minnesota Vikings, and he’s not suddenly a Pro Bowler in Indianapolis. Even so, he has 16 catches, and with Keenan Allen and Josh Downs traded, he should see even more chances in the second half.
Those 16 receptions are his most since he had 33 in 2021, and he could pass that total - and his career high of 35 - before the season ends.
The coaching nod goes to Reggie Wayne. It’s hard to give anyone on this staff a glowing review, but Wayne has had a difficult assignment with very little to work with at wide receiver.
Even so, he has gotten improved play out of players like Treadwell. With Allen and Downs gone and Alec Pierce not expected back until next season, the receiver room is thin, and Wayne’s job figures to get even harder.
Still, his energy and approach have stood out enough that the thought of him handling the rest of 2026 as head coach doesn’t sound far-fetched.
Rookie honors go to Seth McGowan, even though CJ Allen has started to show more after finally getting a real chance. McGowan has been the more productive first-year player overall.
The seventh-round pick is averaging 4.8 yards per carry with 208 rushing yards, and he has added value as a kick returner at 27.9 yards per return. That kind of production makes him look like a steal and a player who should stick around in Indianapolis for a while.
Taylor could have been in the rookie discussion too, but the team’s record keeps that from making much sense. And if not for Shrader, the Colts might be sitting on only one win.
His long kicks helped seal the 19-17 win over the Houston Texans, and he has missed only two field goals. Without that kind of stability, Indianapolis likely would have been blown out a couple more times.
In Other News...
Colts Win Couldnt Hide The Bigger Problems Waiting After Miami
The Colts got the result they needed in Week 10 against Miami, but it did little to quiet the larger questions hovering over the roster. Indianapolis remains 3-7, and the win only briefly masked the uneven play that has followed the team through much of the season, especially on offense where Daniel Jones has been under growing scrutiny.
Shane Steichen is also facing pressure as the next game approaches, with injuries piling up and discipline still an issue for a team trying to stabilize itself. A narrow victory can buy a little time, but it does not erase the concerns about the quarterback situation, the offensive direction or whether the Colts have enough healthy pieces to make the most of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Rebuild Just Created A Jonathan Taylor Decision Fans Will Question
The Colts rebuild has already taken a sharp turn, with the front office moving on from general manager Chris Ballard and dealing away major pieces like DeForest Buckner, Quenton Nelson and Josh Downs. In the middle of that reset, one decision stood out: Indianapolis kept Jonathan Taylor, even as the roster around him thinned out and the long-term direction of the team became harder to read.
Reportedly, the Colts turned down trade interest that included a second-round pick from the Giants, a choice that will invite plenty of debate as the season unfolds. Taylor remains one of the few proven stars left on a team now trying to piece together its future, but with the quarterback situation still unsettled and the supporting cast stripped down, retaining him raises as many questions as it answers. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Face A Brutal Week 10 Test After A Roster Shakeup
The Colts head into Week 10 with a very different look after a recent roster shakeup, and the timing hardly could be tougher. Indianapolis is trying to keep moving forward while also leaning into the future, all while getting ready for a Miami team that is dealing with its own injury issues and will turn to Kyle McCord at quarterback.
Even with the Dolphins scrambling under center, this still shapes up as a tricky matchup for Indianapolis. The early read is a tight, low-scoring game with the Colts narrowly favored, but for a team in transition, the bigger question is how quickly the new pieces and new priorities can settle in against a battered opponent that still has enough talent to make things messy. [Read more 🡒]
