Colts Have A Bigger Rest-Of-Season Question Than Their Record

As the Colts shift focus to their future, keep an eye on these four emerging players who may shape the team's long-term plans.

Now that the trade deadline has come and gone, the Colts can shift the conversation from who’s leaving to who might matter next.

This season may not be about a meaningful chase, but there’s still plenty to learn from the players who are getting chances down the stretch. The roster has its veterans, sure, but it also has a handful of younger pieces who could shape what comes next. Four names stand out.

Jalen Farmer is the first one worth tracking. Replacing Quenton Nelson was never going to be realistic - that’s a nearly impossible standard, and Nelson is one of the best left guards ever to do it.

Still, the Colts have usually been able to keep their offensive line stable during the Chris Ballard era, with 2022 being the obvious exception. Farmer now has a real opening, even if the long-term answer at the spot is still unclear.

There’s a lot still to sort out around him. The next offensive line coach, the next general manager, and the team’s willingness to invest in the position will all matter.

Compared with Tanor Bortolini, Matt Goncalves, and especially Bernhard Raimann, Farmer has less of a track record to lean on. But the traits are there.

He’s a force in the run game and can generate movement, even if his athleticism shows up as a limitation when he has to climb to the second level. In pass protection, stunts and twists have given him problems, and some of the Run ID’s have been an issue too.

Even so, there’s still something to work with.

Seth McGowan is another player with a chance to carve out a bigger role. Jonathan Taylor’s future remains uncertain, especially after he has not denied that he asked for a trade request.

The Colts would be smart to keep him, but if Taylor wants out, that kind of situation can stretch into the offseason. If that happens, McGowan suddenly becomes a much more important name.

He doesn’t need to be Jonathan Taylor to matter. He could grow into a lead back, even if the production gap would be enormous.

The comparison that comes to mind is what’s happening in Los Angelas with Kyren Williams and Blake Corum. McGowan doesn’t have elite twitch or breakaway speed, but he runs with toughness, keeps his pads low, and usually falls forward.

He has burst in gap scheme, can hit the hole quickly, and he’s already the best pass protecting running back on the team. He also brings a style that recalls Zack Moss, who played a pivotal role for the Colts in 2023.

On the defensive side, Jaylahn Tuimoloau has become one of the more interesting developments. Defensive players are always difficult to project, and that’s especially true when the scheme itself may change. There’s a real chance that, even with the progress he’s made as both a run defender and pass rusher, he won’t be the right fit for what comes next.

But the growth has been hard to ignore. After the preseason he had, it wasn’t even clear he would play on defense.

Instead, he’s improved week by week, which is exactly the kind of thing a new general manager wants to see while building a roster. He’s shown the ability to kick inside and rush guards, set the edge better against the run, and handle his role as a contain rusher.

His ceiling may not be that of a perennial double-digit sack player, but that was never really the expectation when he was drafted. For now, he looks like he’s developed about where the Colts hoped he would.

CJ Allen rounds out the group, and his situation is a little trickier to read because the expectations around him were probably too high from the start. The Colts didn’t do much to address the position, then made things even louder by talking up his potential to be a green dot from Day 1. That’s a lot to ask of any rookie linebacker, especially in today’s NFL with all the motion, condensed sets, under center play action, and unusual body types at tight end.

Allen also didn’t get a full offseason, and that made his path even tougher. It’s hard enough for a rookie to get up to speed without full training camp reps, and even harder when the early-season opportunities aren’t there either. The linebacker rotations have been strange, so the sample size is still thin, and any early take should come with a very small grain of salt.

What has shown up so far is encouraging in spots. Against the run, he’d probably fit best in a fast-flowing defense that lets him shoot gaps, because right now offensive linemen are moving him off the ball more than you’d like.

In coverage, he’s shown decent instincts in vision zone. His change of direction looks a little stiff, but that’s manageable for a middle linebacker.

More than anything, the energy jumps off the screen. He flies to the football, and that kind of play style stands out, especially when it’s been missing elsewhere on the defense.

At the very least, Allen has done enough to earn a shot to compete for the MLB spot next year.

In Other News...

Colts Deadline Shakeup Put Several Familiar Names On The Clock

The Colts trade deadline activity has added another layer of uncertainty to a roster already in transition, with familiar names moving out and the front office clearly willing to keep reshaping the group. Dealing away players such as Keenan Allen and Josh Downs signaled that Indianapolis was not just tweaking around the edges, but making decisions with an eye on what comes next.

Now the attention shifts to a cluster of impending free agents who could define the next phase of the roster build. Anthony Richardson, Grover Stewart, Spencer Shrader and Ashton Dulin all sit in that uncertain space where the Colts have to weigh value, role and future fit, and the choices they make there will say plenty about how aggressively they want to keep this core intact. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Get One Key Return As Injury Trouble Keeps Growing

The Colts got a needed boost on the defensive front this week by activating Arden Key from injured reserve ahead of their Week 10 matchup. Keys return gives Indianapolis another experienced edge presence as the roster continues to be reshuffled around a growing list of injuries, and the team also added linebacker West Weeks to the 53-man roster to help fill out the depth chart.

Mo Alie-Cox and Akeem Davis-Gaither both landed on injured reserve, adding to the uncertainty the Colts have been managing on both sides of the ball. With those losses, the focus now shifts to how Indianapolis pieces together enough healthy bodies for Sunday and whether the latest roster moves can steady a group that has been stretched thin. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Shuffle Key Depth Pieces Before A Crucial Dolphins Test

The Colts made a pair of notable roster moves as they turn the page toward a Week 10 meeting with the Dolphins, activating defensive end Arden Key from injured reserve and adding linebacker West Weeks to the 53-man roster. It gives Indianapolis a little more flexibility on defense at a time when every healthy body matters, especially with the schedule tightening and the margin for error shrinking.

Mo Alie-Cox and Akeem Davis-Gaither, meanwhile, were both placed on injured reserve, which means they will miss at least four games and leaves two more holes for the Colts to manage. For a team trying to stay steady heading into a key AFC matchup, the timing underscores how quickly the depth chart can shift from one week to the next. [Read more 🡒]