The Indianapolis Colts are still in the thick of the playoff race, but they’re getting there the hard way. Injuries have reshaped this team from top to bottom, forcing a shift in offensive identity and putting even more weight on the defense’s shoulders. What started as a high-ceiling offense under Daniel Jones has transitioned into a more methodical, efficient approach with veteran Philip Rivers now steering the ship.
That change means the Colts' defense has to carry even more of the load-and they might just be up to the task, especially with a major reinforcement on the way. DeForest Buckner, the heart of Indy’s defensive front, is set to return in Week 16 against the San Francisco 49ers. He’s been sidelined since Week 10 with a neck injury, but head coach Shane Steichen confirmed Buckner will be back under the lights on Monday Night Football.
And this isn’t just any return. Buckner is lining up against the team that drafted him back in 2016 and then traded him away after the 2019 season.
The 49ers got a first-round pick in return, but the Colts got a foundational piece. Since landing in Indianapolis, Buckner has been one of the most consistently dominant interior defenders in the league.
Whether it’s collapsing the pocket or stuffing the run, he’s a game-wrecker-and his presence could be the jolt this defense needs heading into a critical stretch.
The timing couldn’t be better. The Colts are hanging around in the AFC playoff picture, but they’ll likely need to win at least two of their final three games to get in.
That path includes matchups against the Jaguars and Texans, two teams also fighting for playoff position. A win over Jacksonville in Week 17 could be a swing game with major implications.
But before that, it’s San Francisco-and this 49ers offense is no joke. They’re one of the most versatile units in the league, capable of beating teams through the air or on the ground.
That’s where Buckner’s return becomes even more important. His ability to anchor the line and disrupt timing up front could be the key to slowing down a multifaceted attack.
Even without Buckner, defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo dialed up a strong performance against Seattle in Week 15. The Colts defense held firm, and the game plan was sharp.
With Buckner back in the mix, expect Anarumo to get even more creative. The Colts don’t need to dominate-they just need to control the tempo, limit big plays, and give Rivers and the offense a chance to grind out wins.
Speaking of the offense, the Colts are no longer leaning on explosive plays to get it done. The days of Jonathan Taylor setting up deep shots to Alec Pierce and company are on hold.
With Rivers under center, it’s about sustaining drives, converting third downs, and avoiding mistakes. It’s not flashy, but it can work-especially if the defense holds up its end.
There are still some injury concerns to monitor. Left tackle Bernhard Raimann is dealing with an elbow injury and will be a game-time decision for Monday night.
That’s a spot to watch closely, especially with San Francisco’s pass rush looming. Meanwhile, cornerback Sauce Gardner has been ruled out for Week 16, but Steichen expressed optimism that he’ll return before the regular season wraps up.
Bottom line: the Colts are battered, but not broken. With Buckner back in the trenches and the defense rounding into form, they’ve got a puncher’s chance. The margin for error is slim, but this team is still fighting-and with the postseason in reach, every snap matters.