The Colts wasted no time making a splash after firing Chris Ballard, and according to Dan Patrick, their first call may have gone straight to Peyton Manning.
Indianapolis dismissed Ballard after the 2-3 Colts lost to the Tennessee Titans in Week 6 of the 2026 NFL season, dropping to 2-4 while the 0-5 Titans moved to 1-5. That defeat triggered a major front-office reset, with the 10th-year general manager out and the search for a new leader now underway.
On The Dan Patrick Show, Patrick said a source told him Manning is a name to watch in the process.
"The Colts' first call will be/has been to Peyton Manning. The call will not only get names and suggestions, but the call will explore whether or not Peyton would be interested in a general manager for the Colts as the entry point that would include ownership interest in the Colts," Patrick shared.
Patrick added, "The Colts' first call will be/has been to Peyton Manning." - DP shares what his source has told him. https://t.co/MgTbuJIxhW
- Dan Patrick Show (@dpshow) October 19, 2026
That makes this more than a simple courtesy check. The reported pitch would reportedly go beyond asking Manning for advice on the job and into whether he’d actually want the GM role itself.
The more striking part of the report is the possibility of ownership being part of the conversation. If true, that would put Manning in a very different kind of position with the franchise he once led at quarterback.
Manning remains active around the league and could step into a role somewhat similar to what Tom Brady is doing with the Las Vegas Raiders, serving as a major voice in the front office while also working for FOX on NFL broadcasts.
A move into a GM role would almost certainly pull Manning away from his ESPN work, since it would require a full-time focus on helping run the team. That would be more in line with the path Matt Ryan has taken with the Atlanta Falcons.
Whatever comes next, the report shows the Colts still hold Manning’s opinion in high regard. Enough, apparently, to make him one of the first names in the conversation as they move on after nearly a decade with Ballard in charge.
In Other News...
Colts Suddenly Have A Problem That Looks Bigger Than One Collapse
The Colts loss to the Titans was ugly enough on the surface, but the way it unraveled after halftime made it feel bigger than a single bad Sunday. Indianapolis had problems all over the field, with the offense coughing up the ball and stalling in scoring range, while special teams helped turn a competitive game into a lopsided one. Even with the defense holding up better than the final score might suggest, the Colts could not string together the kind of stops and clean possessions needed to survive a collapse like that.
Daniel Jones and Jonathan Taylor were both part of the turnover mess, and the offense never recovered once the mistakes started piling up. At 2-4, the Colts are staring at a stretch that will demand a much cleaner operation on offense and far fewer hidden-yardage disasters on special teams, because the next few matchups leave little room for a repeat. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Now Have A Daniel Jones Problem They Can't Ignore
Daniel Jones first season with the Colts has already become a topic the team cant avoid, even with a new week and a new opponent on deck. Signed to a two-year deal after suffering a torn Achilles in December 2025, Jones has not delivered the kind of stability Indianapolis was hoping for, and the rough showing in the loss to the Tennessee Titans only sharpened the scrutiny around the quarterback move the franchise made this offseason.
Shane Steichen has said Jones will start again against the Minnesota Vikings, a decision that keeps the focus squarely on how much patience the Colts can afford to show. With Chris Ballard out as general manager and Steichen still holding the head-coaching job, the organizations next steps at quarterback matter even more now, because every start is beginning to look like part evaluation, part damage control, and part referendum on a decision Indianapolis can no longer pretend is routine. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Now Face Another Brutal Test As Things Start Sliding
A loss at home to Tennessee put the Colts in a tougher spot than they wanted, especially with the schedule now steering them straight into a matchup with one of the leagues most complete teams. The next stop is Minnesota, where the undefeated Vikings bring a strong record and a defense that has made life difficult for plenty of opponents.
For Indianapolis, the challenge is about more than simply bouncing back from one bad Sunday. The Colts are trying to steady things after a game that slipped away on avoidable mistakes, and now they have to do it against a team oddsmakers trust more heavily, with Minnesota laying 5.5 points and the Colts sitting at +210 on the money line. [Read more 🡒]