Chris Ballard’s run as Colts general manager ended the way so many of his moves did: with Indianapolis stuck paying for it later.
Ballard was fired on October 19 after a decade in charge, a stretch that was supposed to push the Colts back into annual Super Bowl contention. Instead, the results never came close to matching the vision. In 10 years, the Colts won zero division titles, reached the playoffs twice and won just one postseason game.
That lack of success put Ballard near the center of the franchise’s problems, and a few of his biggest decisions left scars that will linger well beyond his exit.
The clearest example was the quarterback situation after Andrew Luck retired right before the 2019 regular season. Ballard wasn’t responsible for Luck’s sudden decision, but he never truly solved the most important position on the field after it happened.
From 2019 through 2022, Indianapolis cycled through four Week 1 starters: Jacoby Brissett, Philip Rivers, Carson Wentz and Matt Ryan. Rivers was 39, Ryan was 37, and the whole approach amounted to a string of short-term fixes instead of a real plan for the future.
When Ballard finally used a premium draft pick on a quarterback, he swung big on Anthony Richardson with the No. 4 pick in 2023. Richardson came with obvious upside, but the concerns were just as obvious: accuracy, footwork, touch and timing.
Ballard bet a top-five selection on a raw project, and it never turned into the answer the Colts needed. Richardson’s career completion rate sits at 50.6%, he has thrown more interceptions than touchdowns, and he has struggled to stay healthy.
The draft problems didn’t stop there. Ballard’s track record on defense was just as shaky, especially when it came to premium talent.
He never managed to land a premier edge rusher or a lockdown cornerback, and the defense paid for it. The Colts finished in the bottom half of the league in scoring defense in seven of his 10 seasons.
Too often, his early defensive picks fizzled out - JuJu Brents was waived, Quincy Wilson was traded away for pennies, and Ben Banogu was banished from the league entirely.
What made all of that worse was Ballard’s refusal to change course. His roster-building philosophy stayed almost exactly the same throughout his tenure: draft well, develop from within, and keep free agency and trades on a short leash.
Even as the losses piled up, he stuck with that approach instead of moving on from underperformers sooner or being more aggressive in finding outside help. The same template kept producing the same results.
Then came the move that looked like a late push to fix everything, but only made the future messier. After a promising but brief 10-week stretch in 2025, Ballard went all-in.
He traded 2 first-round picks midseason for Sauce Gardner, then followed that by spending over $200 million on contract extensions for Daniel Jones and Alec Pierce. The payoff never arrived.
The Colts collapsed, missed the playoffs, and were still not close to being a playoff team.
By the time Indianapolis opened the 2026 season 2-4, Ballard was out and the reset was already underway. The Colts are rebuilding now, but the damage from those decisions - especially the lost draft capital and future cap space - will hang around for a while.
In Other News...
Shane Steichen Suddenly Faces A Colts Situation He May Not Survive
The Colts have already spent the week ripping up the old order, starting with the firing of Chris Ballard and then the stunning departures of Pro Bowl guard Quenton Nelson and All-Pro defensive tackle DeForest Buckner. Shane Steichen didnt try to minimize what those losses mean, acknowledging the value of both veterans while also pointing to the younger players now being asked to absorb a much bigger role in a hurry.
For Steichen, the challenge is no longer just replacing talent on the field. With speculation already swirling around possible moves involving Jonathan Taylor and Josh Downs, the roster feels like it is still in motion, and so does the coachs own standing. The Colts are suddenly in a place where every decision carries extra weight, and Steichens future may hinge on how well the next wave of players handles the pressure. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Face One Huge Free Agency Question Around Anthony Richardson
The Colts uneven season has already produced one major shakeup, with Chris Ballard out as general manager while Shane Steichen remains in place. With Indianapolis expected to be a seller before the Nov. 10 trade deadline, the focus is starting to shift from this years disappointments to what the roster could look like next fall, especially with several notable names moving toward free agency.
Among the biggest questions is Anthony Richardson, whose future is tied to how the quarterback picture settles over the rest of the season. Grover Stewart is also nearing a crossroads, and Keenan Allen is in the same uncertain group, but Richardsons situation carries the most weight because it could reshape the Colts long-term direction at the games most important position. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Finally Get A Needed Boost In A Very Strange Week 8
For a Colts team that has spent a strange week sorting through injuries, lineup shuffling and the fallout from a pair of major trades, there was at least some clarity heading into Week 8. Shane Steichen said cornerback Sauce Gardner and tight end Tyler Warren will be available against the Jaguars, giving Indianapolis a needed boost on both sides of the ball as it tries to steady itself after parting with DeForest Buckner and Quenton Nelson.
The availability report still leaves the roster in a mixed state, though, with Anthony Gould and Justin Walley ruled out because of injuries. Add in the uncertainty around players such as Josh Downs and Jonathan Taylor, who were not played in a week when trade considerations seemed to be part of the backdrop, and the Colts are still navigating a very unusual stretch even with a couple of key names set to return. [Read more 🡒]