The Colts had plenty to worry about in Week 1, but the biggest rookie storyline might be the one that never happened: CJ Allen never got on the field.
Allen, Indianapolis’ second-round linebacker, dressed for Sunday’s game but did not play a snap. That alone raised eyebrows. Shane Steichen didn’t exactly calm anyone down afterward, either.
“He was banged up in camp; we’re getting him back into football shape, and we’ll see where it goes from there.”
That’s not the kind of update that settles nerves, especially for a player the Colts expected to help anchor a defense down the line. Instead, Allen’s debut landed somewhere between puzzling and discouraging.
Other rookie linebackers wasted no time making noise. Tennessee’s Anthony Hill Jr. exploded for 16 tackles in his first NFL game.
Miami’s Jacob Rodriguez, the No. 43 pick, and Tampa’s Josiah Trotter, taken at No. 46, both started and finished with double-digit tackles. After one week, and with Monday night still to come, Hill sits first in tackles and Rodriguez is second.
Allen, the No. 53 pick, still hasn’t logged a snap.
What makes the Colts’ decision harder to explain is the state of the linebacker room on Sunday. Indianapolis carried only five linebackers, and Austin Ajiake was unavailable against the Ravens. That left Akeem Gaither-Davis, Jaylon Carlies, and rookie Bryce Boettcher as the active options beside Allen.
The results weren’t pretty. Early Pro Football Focus grades gave Gaither-Davis a decent mark, while Carlies and Boettcher checked in below average.
All three had trouble in coverage, and Baltimore kept finding space in the middle of the field. Even with that, Allen stayed planted on the bench.
He wasn’t hurt on Sunday. He was healthy enough to appear in the Colts’ final preseason game two weeks earlier, and he was in uniform for Week 1. The coaches simply opted not to use him.
That choice stands out even more when you look around the league. Of the 64 players taken in the first two rounds this year, six opened on IR and two were set to play Monday night. Among the other 56, Allen was one of only five who didn’t see the field on Sunday.
The others all had clear explanations. The Jets’ D’Angelo Ponds was out with a calf injury.
The Rams’ Max Klare was a healthy scratch on a crowded depth chart. The remaining two were backup quarterbacks Fernando Mendoza and Ty Simpson.
Linebacker, though, is supposed to be a position where rookies can make an immediate impact. Hill did it.
Rodriguez did it. Trotter did it.
Allen did not even get a chance.
That makes Steichen’s “we’ll see where it goes from there” line sound even colder, because it reads like a coach backing away from the early hype. And there was plenty of hype. Back in April, general manager Chris Ballard said this about Allen:
“He’ll be a green dot guy for us from the get-go. I mean, he’s a face of the program type guy. He’s a really special dude now.”
A week into Allen’s career, none of that has shown up yet. It’s still very early, and the Colts can still get where they expected to go with him.
But for now, the questions are louder than the answers. Colts fans aren’t asking for a star turn.
They’d just like to see their top pick take the field.
In Other News...
Colts Week 1 Loss Put Early Pressure On Three Key Names
The Colts 41-23 loss to Baltimore did more than open the season on a sour note. It also put an early spotlight on three players whose roles and expectations already carried plenty of weight, with rookie Justin Walley and Sauce Gardner drawing attention on the back end and Tyler Warren trying to live up to the buzz surrounding his arrival.
Walley had a difficult time dealing with Zay Flowers, while Gardner was not targeted often but still had to watch a defense give up points in bunches. Warren, meanwhile, made only a limited impact despite the preseason hype around him, leaving Indianapolis with some immediate questions about how quickly those key names can settle in after a rough Week 1 showing. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Have One Growing Concern After A Far More Encouraging Loss
The Colts came out of Week 1 with something they badly needed after a long offseason: signs that the roster can still be competitive if the pieces settle in quickly. Even in a loss, the tone around Indianapolis was far more encouraging than the flat, discouraging openers some teams around the AFC put on tape, and the early ranking of conference teams reflects that distinction. There were enough positive individual performances to suggest the Colts are not staring at a broken start, just a team that has some sorting out to do.
Still, the postgame read is not all comfort. The broader AFC evaluation points to one growing concern for Indianapolis, and it is the kind that can linger if it is not corrected fast enough, especially with adjustments coming on both sides of the ball. The encouraging part is that the Colts are not far from looking like a different team, but the opening week also made clear that their margin for error is already thin. [Read more 🡒]
DeMeco Ryans Just Put Houstons Defense On Notice
The Colts are still sorting through the sting of that season-opening loss to Baltimore, and Jonathan Taylors read on it was blunt enough to fit the moment. He called it a wakeup call, the kind that forces a team to confront where it stands right away instead of waiting for the standings to do the talking. For Indianapolis, it is a reminder that the margin in the AFC South is thin, and the early weeks can shape the tone for everything that follows.
Across the division, DeMeco Ryans was already drilling into what went wrong for Houston after its loss to Buffalo, pointing to a defensive line that settled in better after halftime but still left too much uncovered in key moments. The Texans know the standard has to rise quickly, especially with the Colts and the rest of the division watching for any sign of vulnerability. Ryans postgame assessment suggested the fixes are there to be made, but the challenge now is tightening the coverage before those lapses start piling up. [Read more 🡒]